Need a New EDC Pocketknife

Status
Not open for further replies.

GConn

Member
Joined
Jan 19, 2011
Messages
18
Location
VA - US
Greetings all,

I am seeking a replacement pocket knife for the Buck Redpoint 750 that I've carried the past 5-or-so years.

What I LIKE about this knife is:

1. Rubbery Grip
2. Double-locking (Locks open AND closed - I really almost "need" this)
3. Partially Serrated Edge (love having that versatility in my pocket every-day)
4. Easy "flip-open" wheel action (or whatever Buck calls it)
5. Cost only about $35 ... would "like" to stay under $50.

What I do NOT like:

1. Short blade (only 2 & 3/4" -- I would prefer a 3" blade)
2. 420HC steel (I think would prefer something in the 440 class or "better").

Any advice/ideas/suggestions/etc. greatly appreciated (ESPECIALLY pointing me to direct competitors of this particular Buck)!

Best,
Glenn
PS - Moderator(s) / Others: Am I allowed to place a link to this Buck here, please?
 
I prefer a hand filling rounded handle profile for better control over a slab sided knife.
I usually add some jibbing for a better grip too:
Jibbing.JPG
just me though,
:D
 
Spyderco Delica 4 would be my recommendation. Meets your size requirement with much better steel and overall build quality in comparison to a Chinese Buck. It may cost a few dollars more than 50 though.

Now some people don't like the looks of Spydercos. Usually these people have never actually handled one. The opening method is super intuitive, and the accompanying thumb ramp makes for very secure handling. Handle is plastic, but the texturing is very well done.

Kershaw Skyline wound be my next pick. Grippy G10 and the deep finger choil make it very nice to work with. Flipping action is pretty good, but not great. The blade steel is a notch below the VG10 of the Delica, but the price is right and it is even made in America.

Edit: Delica review video link added. Seems to me like a well rounded non-biased opinion.

 
Last edited:
It exceeds your price limit, but the Kershaw Blur would be a good choice. Its a solid knife that would seem to fulfill your other requirements pretty well. Kershaw makes a few other assisted-opening knives that would likely be good choices as well and are also assisted opening, but one potentially strong "pro" that might overcome the price issue is that the Blur is made in the USA.

I hasten to add that I make that recommendation entirely off of personal experience, though the Blur is a very popular knife. I basically carry either that or a Spyderco Endura as they are my two personal favorite EDC knives. You may have a different opinion, which is cool.
 
Easy "flip-open" wheel action (or whatever Buck calls it)

You're not going to find that anywhere made by an American knife company. It was popular in France and, IIRC, was the design of a Quebec knife maker.
 
I'll go through your points, provide a few answers, and ask a few questions. Hopefully this will help me or someone else here give you a more solid recommendation.
2. Double-locking (Locks open AND closed - I really almost "need" this)
Do you need the blade to be locked closed, or would a strong bias toward closure work for you?
4. Easy "flip-open" wheel action (or whatever Buck calls it)
As HSO already noted, that exact mechanism isn't at all common. Are you open to more readily available methods of quick opening?
2. 420HC steel (I think would prefer something in the 440 class or "better").
Buck's heat treat on their 420HC gives it surprisingly good performance. 440A and 440B (and equivalents like AUS8, 8cr13, etc) are a step up, but not the big step up like 440C is.

Also, what's your blade sharpness type preference? Some folks like highly polished razor blade type edges, while others, myself included, like steels that work well when stopped short of a high polish and left a bit toothy but still with a shaving sharp working edge.
5. Cost only about $35 ... would "like" to stay under $50.
I understand not wanting to spend too much money, but if you can bump that budget up to $50-$100 it really will open up a vast selection of much higher quality knives with better blade steels and nicer handle materials.
1. Rubbery Grip
That's also going to be hard in meeting your desire for a higher quality knife. Rubber isn't used much because it tends to cling to the inside of pockets, it's hard to clean, and it wears out rather quickly. Materials like G10 and textured high quality plastics provide great grip without the cleaning and wear issues of rubber. Are you open to these alternatives?
 
you can take a look at these, might tickle your fancy. particularly the m16.

kershaw dividend, blur or am4.
spyderco tenacious/persistance/resiliance (same design, different sizes)
sog flash ii
H&K pika 2
crkt m16
boker kalashnikov button lock
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top