Why build a 1911 when you can make a low cost one better?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I know this is a res. thread but perhaps the OP is still keeping an eye on it so what the heck.

1. Before anything else: it gun, it dangerous. Proceed with that thought ever close at hand.

2. Why a Caspian over a complete pistol? Quality. Material, finish, (usually) dimensions. If you think of your frame as a log, would you start that chainsaw on someone else’s carving? It’s nasty what true smiths do with donor frames; welding slides, adding material to re-cut the beavertail radius, blending it all back together. The Caspian is the blank canvas.

3. If you’re adding premium parts, the money is already spent. Buying a barrel, bushing, grip safety, ignition parts, thumb safety, and slide stop is costly. This isn’t a motor you can simply transplant into a chassis down the road. Once you’ve fitted parts, they are forever mated to you 1911.

I understand the question as asked and I read every post including the “wasn’t asking about that” (to paraphrase) portions but I’m compelled... The knowledge to fit every part is out there if you’re willing to acquire it. Understanding that information is an individual matter (again help is available). If you can read a print, measure precisely, afford the tools needed, are willing to persevere, and have the money, then revisit 1. above and get to work.
 
You will know the answer to that question as soon as you start measuring and fitting parts. Things like holes that are misplaced, not square to the frame, not parallel to other holes, etc. And I have seen Colts like that. Bottom line - every one is different. (voice of Forrest Gump) "You don't never know what yer going to get." If I were going to build up a GI gun I would buy a SA Mil spec. and put Brownells on speed dial. In the 90s we built some very nice guns from stock Mil spec Springfields and Norincos. Bill Wilson actually used to do custom Norinco pistols in the 80s and 90s. I don't know where the Chinese are getting their steel from but it's pretty nice stuff. It's almost as hard as a file. They do have issues with some of their slide/barrel lug mating. My opinion of cast frames is if done properly they hold up - but forged chrome moly steel will always be better.
Drail, those nice steel Norinco M1911s started out life as railroad ties.:)
 
Home gun smithing 1911s is doable and fun... just be absolutely 100% sure you know how the gun works, down to the most minute detail.... and most importantly, make sure you know how to do all of the function checks and click test. You don't want the sear to so much as wiggle a hair when it's not supposed to.

And be very discerning about what you see on Youtube.
 
Yes I know - and they are made by Chinese prison labor. Regardless, Norincos have some pretty good steel in them. I would imagine it is sourced from a lot of different places. Heck, our own Navy has commisioned ships built from the wreckage of the WTC towers. I guess they had to do something with all stuff (evidence that no one was allowed to examine) as quickly as they could.
 
Yes I know - and they are made by Chinese prison labor. Regardless, Norincos have some pretty good steel in them. I would imagine it is sourced from a lot of different places. Heck, our own Navy has commisioned ships built from the wreckage of the WTC towers. I guess they had to do something with all stuff (evidence that no one was allowed to examine) as quickly as they could.
What is a WTC tower?
 
Holes that are not aligned and off center, not the correct size, rails of differing size, etc. And therein lies the reason that your top 1911-smiths across the country won’t do work on such frames.

Spend your money wisely. Call a few of them and ask them what frames they work on and most importantly why.
That was the reason that many top tier 1911 smiths originally wouldn't work in Springfield Armory 1911s and why many prefer not to work on Caspian frames (that was the problem with early SIG GSR pistols).

I was once talking to a top tier smith who would only work on Colt frames. I asked if it was because they were inherently more "in-spec." He laughed and answered, "No"...it was because he already knew all the things he'd have to correct on the Colt. He now produces his own slides and frames
 
Yup. I have worked on plenty of Colt frames that had hammer and sear pin holes mislocated or not parallel to each other. Colts are like Harley motorcycles. You get a set of parts that can be made into a nice machine with some hard work and better parts.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top