The 3 most underrated hunting calibers.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I can see where it might work for some. I even have one but where I hunt, a deer needs to be put down fast or it's going to go where it would be difficult or impossible to retrieve. I don't trust the 300 BLK enough to try it for deer under those circumstances.
The deer I shot with the Hornady sub-x was a classic broadside shot at about 40 yards. I got a complete pass-thru, with significant internal damage. The deer only ran about 20 yards and piled up. The rifle with that round is very accurate, and stacks rounds at 50 yards. The wife uses it on doe days on the smaller food plots that we use during bow season. So for that application, at those distances, I wouldn't hesitate to use it on any deer/hog or smaller critter.
 
I’ll agree with the .375’s (H&H, Ruger, Steyr) the awesome amount of misinformation by the unwashed around these calibers is huge. No they don’t blow critters into tiny little bitty parts and no the recoil will not spin you around like a top.

The .358 win is a highly underrated powerhouse. It hits like a heavy medium but recoils very timidly.

That in regards to that the .348 Win is one of the finest general purpose, tube fed, lever rounds to have ever been almost entirely forgotten.
 
Last edited:
1) 280 Remington has already mentioned, and I’ll second it. This will start a battle, but it seems superior to the 270 with better bullet options and ballistics. I have both and nearly always pick up the 270, probably out of habit. Go figure...
2) 25-06 or about any of the quarter bores. I’ve never fired a Roberts but have always wanted to try one. The 25-06 is a great flat shooting cartridge.
3) 6.5 Grendel. I took mine to the range last week and was reminded how good a cartridge this is. I usually limit my hunting with this to 200 yards or less but was easily shooting MOA groups off my soft case at 300 yards. Great bullet choices available thanks to the Creedmoor and it only uses about 28 grains of powder.
 
I just read an article that appeared on my Google homepage titled "The 3 Most Underrated Hunting Calibers". I don't how I get these ads (I assume my search history).

The article threw me off. I assume the author meant for deer hunting, but he never did specify in the title. Lol.

His mentions were for .300 Blackout, 338 Federal and 280 Ackley Improved as underrated "calibers". I love the Ackley. Is it underrated? Those in the know may disagree.

I think the current trend towards hunting cartridges may lean in the direction of old school cartridges as being "underrated". 30-30. 35 rem. Rimmed cartridges in general. But then again it has to do with distance and what your after.

What would you say are "The 3 Most Underrated Hunting Calibers". (Cartridges). Let's say for North American big game.

243
270
20 GA
 
1. 6.5x55. Lots of history, but it’s just not very popular among hunters in my neck of the woods.

2. 7mm-08. Extremely effective cartridge that is often relegated to women and children’s rifles.

3. 6.8 SPC. Popular among those whom hunt with an AR-15, but not nearly as popular as it deserves. Just about perfect for deer inside of 300 yards.
 
.35 rem kills deer and not your shoulder.
Under 150 yards ( timber ) its pretty darn good.

30 bucks for 20 rounds isnt the cheapest
way to go. Seen Hornady at some shops around 35 bucks a box.
 
Dont care about history. Just use stuff that works.

Sometimes a cartridge and platform work exceptionally well.

Everything has pluses and minuses.

Nothing is perfect.

But some stuff is pretty close ;)
 
Some folks want one rifle to do it all, or one shotgun or handgun.

Several threads of " if you only had one ( or two) ".

I prefer items for specific tasks. More is better ;)

Kinda boils down to life choices.....

One woman and lots of rifles.
Or one rifle and lotsa women.

Pick the bargain
 
I just read an article that appeared on my Google homepage titled "The 3 Most Underrated Hunting Calibers". I don't how I get these ads (I assume my search history).

The article threw me off. I assume the author meant for deer hunting, but he never did specify in the title. Lol.

His mentions were for .300 Blackout, 338 Federal and 280 Ackley Improved as underrated "calibers". I love the Ackley. Is it underrated? Those in the know may disagree.

I think the current trend towards hunting cartridges may lean in the direction of old school cartridges as being "underrated". 30-30. 35 rem. Rimmed cartridges in general. But then again it has to do with distance and what your after.

What would you say are "The 3 Most Underrated Hunting Calibers". (Cartridges). Let's say for North American big game.
 
For me personally, it would be The 220 Swift, the 280 Mt Rifle Ackley Improved, the 257 Roberts Ackley Improved, and last but not Least The 25-06. I own all 4 of them and the 220 Swift is the most impressive of all 4.
 
The very first post pretty well summed it up. Old school cartridges. If it’s been around for a hundred years then surely it’s antiquated, obsolete, weak, and inferior (per most folks). Reality is that the rounds would not have lasted this long if they didn’t work, and work pretty well. 30-06, and 30-30 are the first two that come to mind. They have been filling freezers for decade after decade and will do so for the foreseeable future until guns are no longer legal to own or use for hunting purposes.

The 3rd one I’m putting on this list is hugely controversial, but it is one wrestled with by almost every hunter at some point in life... 20ga. No it’s not a showstopper powerhouse, nothing truly is, but the 20ga can do everything a 12 can do, especially now that modern powders and modern chokes are doing what was impossible a few decades ago. From quail to turkey, squirrel to moose, a 20 will get the job done with proper ammunition selection. Slugs are arguably as good as a 12ga so it is at no disadvantage for big game unless your talking 3-1/2 magnum 12 or even 10ga slug, but those are very rare to see, and even rarer for them to actually exceed the 3” velocities and performance. Small game is small game and it can be nice on Turkey to have 200 pellets flying rather than 140 but realistically it will flat work... but we all struggle at some point in our teenage years with moving from a 20 to a 12. Ever ask why you needed a 12? Because it’s better than a 20 is the standard answer, but a 20 realistically is 99% as good as a 12.
 
Some of the older military cartridges that used to be so readily available are now under rated just by the fact that so many people have forgotten about them. I'm thinking of rounds like 7mm Mauser, and .303 British. I absolutely love my 7mm Mauser. Soft shooting, accurate, pretty flat trajectory. I have bullets from 139 gr to 175 gr.

My favorite under rated civilian round is the .243. Same reason. Soft, flat shooting, accurate, pretty wide range of bullet weights, and it's one people don't think of, so it's always in stock.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top