Anyone have mags unseat from their guns?

Status
Not open for further replies.

357smallbore

Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2015
Messages
911
Location
Leavenworth KS
I have a Shield 9mm. Carry in a Don Hume 715 IWB holster. Every now and then my magazine will unseat (pop loose) and I have to lock it back in.
It's usually when I am getting out of my car.
Obviously my body is pushing against the mag release. I make sure I'm always checking it is locked in when I carry it
 
I had a similar issue with a Vektor CP1, but in that case the mag was being unseated during firing. I was unseating it, with my right thumb. I changed the mag release from left side to right and didn't have that problem again.
Your case seems to be different though.
If you don't have issues with the mag coming out at any other time, I think you need to get a different holster, rather than trying to alter the gun.
 
It's never happened to me. We've had quite a few reports of this happening on the forum from several members.

I think it is most common with large sweat shields typically found on hybrid holsters. Usually, the lack of a sweat shield that would contact a mag release, provides enough offset to keep the mag release from being pressed. However, you are not the only one who has had the issue on a holster without a sweat shield.
 
Regardless of holster this happens to me a couple times per year. It's annoying but I haven't found a solution. I thought about shaving the button down to just barely above flush but that makes mag changes tough. No, it's not always a holster problem. No, it's not always a gun issue either. I'm hard on everything and my gear shows it, if I'm scooting around on my back on concrete it's almost a sure thing my mag will be released, I check now and then.
 
Not me, at least not from the holster.

Small 9mms, like the Kimber Micro or Sig 938, I'll have them drop out as my hand hits the release under recoil.
 
Regardless of holster this happens to me a couple times per year.

No, it's not always a holster problem.

No, it's not always a gun issue either.
Does it happen with both your polymer framed and metal framed guns?

I always get the feeling in these threads it is predominately an issue with polymer guns unless the metal framed gun is using an extended mag release.
 
Does it happen with both your polymer framed and metal framed guns?

I always get the feeling in these threads it is predominately an issue with polymer guns unless the metal framed gun is using an extended mag release.
Yes. 100% a polymer gun thing for me. Never had it for the short time I carried a 1911. After that I've only carried polymer framed pistols.
 
Yes- this can be a significant problem.

I would argue that this occuring unnoticed before a defensive encounter is more probable that needing a rapid reload.

The solution on carry guns are well fenced release buttons or a preference for paddles or good heel systems.
 
It happens occasionally with my P365. I attributed it to carrying on the left side and the mag release being pressed against my side. Never carried on the right side but I think it would be less likely to happen.
 
It happens occasionally with my P365. I attributed it to carrying on the left side and the mag release being pressed against my side. Never carried on the right side but I think it would be less likely to happen.
Isn't the mag release on the left side of the gun (assuming you didn't switch it to the other side - I don't know if you can do that with the P365)?
 
Isn't the mag release on the left side of the gun (assuming you didn't switch it to the other side - I don't know if you can do that with the P365)?
I guess I did switch it, don't even remember doing it. Maybe I will switch it back and see if it helps.
 
Probably not the direction this thread going but the tab that holds the mag release on my 1911 broke during a USPSA match. Holding the mag in place during a match with your off hand or pinky wrecks "style points!! :)

Never had issues with EDC!

Smiles,
 
It happened with my Glock G42, until I scored the edges of the mag release, removed it, and filed all the excess away. Now it sits flush and doesn't drop mags accidentally.
 
Ruger LCP a fair amount to the point that I reflexively push the mag base with my pinky when I draw it.

Todd.
 
I've gotten in the habit of giving the base of the mag a little tug to make sure it's still clicked in whenever I stand up from sitting. I have left a magazine laying on my buddy's couch after sitting for a long time before. That's embarrassing . it shouldn't be this way but like I said, a couple times a year I will find my mag not clicked in.
 
A kydex holster that covers the release may prevent this in most cases. I’ve tried to get the mag to release by pushing hard on the release but the kydex won’t budge enough to do so.
 
Yes, I have experienced this problem with several pistols. Usually, it has been a holster, pressing against the magazine release button. In those cases, a better holster was the remedy. A well-thought-out holster design is important, especially for pistols with push-button controls.

One problematic situation was with an original-design SIG P220, with a heel-clip magazine system. When carrying the pistol in my duty holster, the heel area of the weapon would make contact with the seat back, while I was seated in the patrol car. The external portion of the heel clip tended to snag on the seat fabric, occasionally causing a partial release of the magazine. IIRC, I discovered this had happened, about three or four times, during a two-tear period, 1991-1993. I learned that a colleague had been backed into a chain-link fence, during a struggle with a criminal, at which time the heel-clip of his SIG P220 had snagged the fence, causing a partial release of the magazine.

My remedy for the snagging heel clip was to sell the pistol, with a plan to acquire an “American-style” P220, only to discover that the newer P220 pistols were substantially redesigned in the grip frame area, and just did not work as well in my hand. I had intended to use my GP100 as a short-term interim duty handgun, but, instead, used that GP100, and then a K-Frame revolver, as duty handguns for four years, before returning to using autoloading duty pistols, in 1997.
 
I had a Remington RM380 that I carried in a OWB holster. I cannot remember the maker of the holster. The gun and holster are long gone. Occasionally the Mag release would get pressed. Usually when getting on or off my motorcycle. I cut a hole in the holster where the mag release rubbed in the holster to keep that from happening. The hole didn’t snag the release when unholstering the pistol.

A friend of mine was making his own Kydex holsters. He was planning on making them to sell. He and I were looking over his prototypes and he commented that his mag release was accidentally pressed on either his Shield or his LCP. His fix was to use heat to mold a magazine release indent in his holsters to keep this from happening. He made some nifty holsters but his business idea never came to fruition.
Maybe molding a mag release indent in your holster might help?
 
Happened quite a bit when I started carrying my LC9s. I assumed the mag release stood too proud (I use quality holsters). Since it has the magazine disconnect and renders the gun inoperable when this happened, I called Ruger to tell them it kinda stinks as a carry gun. Ruger said send it back on their dime. Got my gun back in less than a week and it hasn't happened since.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top