Well, as the Cheshire Cat said to Alice, "We're
all mad here."
But otherwise, no, of course not.
I just think we're each blaming the other for this silly thread which is about to get locked.
But to recap our profound investigation into the Science of ballistics, we were discussing MOA guns. For those who came in late, this thread is the ugly-bastard-stepson of another thread, in which someone wondered what was meant by "MOA", and presumably "MOA guns".
This led naturally to the question, "What caliber for Moa?"
RancidSumo then started this thread, to pursue that burning question, (and blaming me!), which led to some spirited discussion of Moa-hunting.
I think
John828 made some VERY good points. I suspect the brain is too small a target. I'd go for the vitals.
Woerm correctly points out that those thick feathers will be hard to punch through, and
no one wants to have to deal with an enraged Moa.
While the .308 or .270 would no doubt do the job, I want something fat and heavy that'll slam through those feathers and dump a lot of energy where it counts. Something like one of those heavy black powder cartridges from the Golden Age of the British Empire.
So that's why I vote for the .577-450 Martini. It's got the power, it's got the punch, and it's got the
style I look for on my Cryptozoological Hunts.
By the way, I suspect they're mainly dark meat. Think big drumsticks. Probably taste a lot like Dodo.