Vulcan may be guilty of a lot of things, but this isn't one of them.
At first I thought the same, for the reasons you mention. HOWEVER, Ruger, Glock and many other companies that don't have any written warranty also don't impose a whole bunch of difficult conditions on their not-a-warranty, which Vulcan does as below:
"All returns MUST have a return authorization number on the OUTSIDE of the package. All returns are subject to a 12% restocking fee. Please email Vulcan Group Inc. at
[email protected] to obtain a return authorization number BEFORE shipping. Please observe the following procedure to ensure efficient service:
All returns for service MUST be sent to Vulcan Group Inc., NOT to the dealer. Each return MUST include a DATED RECEIPT.
Immediately upon purchase fill out and mail the REPAIR POLICY card found in this manual. This card must be on file at Vulcan Group Inc. before any service is performed and BE SENT NO LATER THAN 10 DAYS FROM THE DATE OF PURCHASE. Failure to submit the card within 10 days voids the warranty, DO NOT WAIT TO SEND IT!! Ignorance of these conditions is no excuse!
Should you require service, email Vulcan Group Inc. at
[email protected] explaining the problem and request a Return Authorization number.
The Return Authorization number must appear on the OUTSIDE of the package, without the RA number on the outside of the package, the package will be refused. Enclose a letter explaining the problem, include the name and address of where you would like the item returned, and include your phone number in case of questions. Pack the item securely to avoid damage and insure it for the proper amount."
You can be the 8th owner of a Ruger that has been worked on by several smiths and usually Ruger will still repair a gun and send it back to you without charge (although their written policy allows them to charge in such cases). Likewise, Glock gives no warranty, but usually sends your pistol back fixed and without charge, without requiring proof that you sent them some dumb card within 10 days of purchase. When I see a policy like the one above I assume the company is trying to prevent people from using their service.