Synthetic stock 30-06 hunting rifles in the $1k range

Which model is going to be the best bet for an accurate and durable big game rifle?

  • Remington 700 XPS II

    Votes: 3 11.1%
  • Browning X Bolt Composite Stalker

    Votes: 6 22.2%
  • Weatherby Vanguard Series 2 Back Country

    Votes: 9 33.3%
  • Other (please post with model)

    Votes: 9 33.3%

  • Total voters
    27
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

jbauch357

Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2007
Messages
437
Location
7th layer of hell (Seattle), Washington
I've always hunted with hand me down rifles, for the most part they've performed as expected and I've had no complaints. Now I'm getting older and bringing others into hunting, who are in need of hand me down rifles, so I'm using that as an excuse to get myself a new rifle while continuing to pass others down.

The weather in Western Washington is generally foul during hunting season, very wet and not cold enough for snow - so I'm going synthetic stock and some sort of coated metal setup. I'll be using the rifle for up close thick forest hunting as well as long range desert canyon type shots when I head over to the east side. Once the rifle is picked I'll probably be topping with a Vortex 4-16 scope.

Below are the three best options that I could come up with based on a weekend or so of research, and now I'm at the point that I can't really land on any one as the best option. Of course I am going to see/feel them in person before ordering, but like to get as much information as possible before hand since my LGS will not have these, and I'll be looking at about an hour drive or more to get my hands on anything.

If you have feedback on the good/bad of any of these specific models I would love to hear it, also if there is an obvious choice which I've left out please do let me know.

Also adding poll just for fun.


Remington – 700 XPS II - http://www.remington.com/products/firearms/centerfire/model-700/model-700-xcr-ii.aspx
- Gold standard action/barrel
- TriNyte finish
- X-Mark Pro trigger
- 22” stainless steel barrel
- 7.375 lbs
- $795


Browning – X Bolt Composite Stalker - http://www.browning.com/products/catalog/firearms/detail.asp?fid=023B&cid=035&tid=201
- New design (not sure if that is good or bad)
- Dura Touch finish
- Feather trigger
- 22” barrel (steel type?)
- 6.563 lbs
- $711


Weatherby – Vanguard Series 2 Back Country - http://www.weatherby.com/product/rifles/vanguard_2/backcountry
- MOA guarantee
- Cerakote grey finish
- Adjustable 2-stage match trigger
- 24” fluted chrome molly barrel
- 6.750 lbs
- $1,091


No Winchester – my current rifle is an old Winchester Ranger which is a cheap furniture version of the model 70.

I remember something about no linking to or copying copyrighted material, hopefully the above links are not in conflict with that rule.
 
Last edited:
Of those three I'd pick the Weatherby. Usually I shy away from them due to the weight alone in any type of hunting that involves a lot of walking, but it seems that model is lighter than the 700, and close to the Browning. You could also take a look at the Howa 1500 stainless, it is the same rifle as the Weatherby, but stainless instead of coated regular steel.
 
You're selling the Winchesters short. The old Rangers were a cheap version of a rifle that has been upgraded twice since that gun was made. Current Winchesters are the best USA made rifle in current production.

An EW will be right at $1,000, you can find the SS Ultimate Shadow for around $800

http://www.winchesterguns.com/products/catalog/detail.asp?family=001C&mid=535206
http://www.winchesterguns.com/products/catalog/detail.asp?family=001C&mid=535211

Under $1,000, a Ruger Hawkeye All Weather would be my 2nd choice. If you can scrape up a bit more the Kimber 84L would be a fine rifle as well

http://ruger.com/products/HawkeyeAllWeather/models.html
http://www.kimberamerica.com/rifles/model-84l/montana

A Tikka would be an option if you want a lightweight accurate rifle.

http://www.berettausa.com/products/tikka-t3-lite-stainless/

Wouldn't be interested in the Ruger or Browning

Weatherby makes a good rifle, but not in the same league as the Winchester or Kimber. The Ruger isn't fancy, they just work.
 
The ranger is like the Remington SPS, which is a far cry from their premium models.

Take another look at the 70's, while they are now assembled in Portugal, they are nice rifles. (Mine was an 08' and fully USA produced)
 
The current Controlled Round Feed Model 70s they are making now are really really nice, and can be found for under 1000 bucks.

Do that.

Just my .02,
LeonCarr
 
Another vote to looking at new production Winchester, specifically the extreme weather.

And if for some reason you still don't like the new Winchesters, I would go Ruger. They're one of the most if not the most rugged rifles out there.
 
Tikka t3 Superlite stainless. Picked mine up at Sportsmans warehouse for $799. Tikka's have the smoothest bolt I have ever felt and it is super accurate.
 
Thanks for the suggestions everybody.

After looking at all the offerings you've brought up, plus a bunch that work friends have suggested I've got it narrowed down a bit further to:
- Howa 1500 stainless
- Savage 116 Weather Warrior

Luckily I even found a friend that has both of these and has offered up some range time. A few months down the road I'll try to come back and post up some pictures of the final package and provide a range report.
 
The Savage 116/16 "weather warrior" series is a great rifle. Love the Accustock as it's more rigid than the normal Tupperware stocks that you get. My .308 16 FCSS is a straight up tack driver, like most savages.
 
I have a Kimber Select Grade stainless .308 and a Winchester Super Grade .30-06, both new. No expert but based on that very small sample the Winchester is rifle is nicer, better, and less expensive. IMO the Kimber is overpriced. ETA, sorry, looks like OP has decided.
 
Thanks for the suggestions everybody.

After looking at all the offerings you've brought up, plus a bunch that work friends have suggested I've got it narrowed down a bit further to:
- Howa 1500 stainless
- Savage 116 Weather Warrior

Luckily I even found a friend that has both of these and has offered up some range time. A few months down the road I'll try to come back and post up some pictures of the final package and provide a range report.
Those are the two I was going to suggest although all the above rifles are good choices.

I own two Howa 1500 rifles, one in 30-06 and the other in .223. They are my main bolt action hunting battery.

The Savage rifles are also great and the Weather Warrior is among the best of the Savage hunting rifles. The AccuTrigger is a huge plus! The detachable box magazine is also a plus.
 
Basically I wanted a bit more punch for high desert long range shots, and knew that I could toss a brake on it to get recoil down to acceptable levels. If I'd have known it was going to shoot this nice though I'd have bought this package years ago.
 
How far can you shoot (do you routinely? )?
My previous rifle was only good to ~2-3MOA so most of my practice was on an 8" gong at 200 yards, which also used to be the furthest and smallest target available at my range.

With this rifle I can consistently put rounds on a 4"x8" popper at 400 yards (the first cross hatch down on my scope), confirmed that during our last shoot in the woods. We just put up a 4" popper at 200 yards at our range so I'll be practicing on that primarily, with practice at longer ranges when the opportunity arises again.

Just for fun I was taking pot shots at a 775 yard half profile in the wind, and managed to land 3/15 shots which I realize isn't good enough for any practical use but is light years beyond anything else I'd have been able to manage in the past.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top