11 year old goes w/ plan B

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tyro

Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
59
Location
Pennsylvania, USA
"I always make my plan before there's a robbery or a kidnap[ping]," Xochil said from her Midwood home. "I think of a plan, like, if anybody kidnaps me, kick them back or scratch them - I'm growing my nails out. I went with Plan B."
...
Xochil, who called for her attacker to get a stiff sentence, warned other kids to think safety first. "Try to figure out a plan before somebody tries to kidnap you. That way if somebody tries to touch you, you're ready to attack them back."

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime_file/2007/05/15/2007-05-15_captain_kid.html
 
Good For Her

and I must say, the 18 yr old brother showed alot more discipline than I might have had.....

No need for officers, just a sponge.
 
and I must say, the 18 yr old brother showed alot more discipline than I might have had.....

No need for officers, just a sponge

Evidently you missed the line stating they(the brother and co) pummeled him to prevent him from escaping. Ya think the cops would ask where the bruises came from? :evil:
 
I'm surprised he didn't "accidentally" fall off the roof.

This is why you tell your kids to never go with the bad guy. Fight like your life depends on it,because it does. This girl has more balls than most grown men.
 
the charges sound stupid. Why not aggravated assault?! Kidnapping?!

Burglary, unlawful imprisonment, endangering the welfare of a child.... - that's all he got!!?

what the??!!
 
I'm glad that this girl is getting some publicity through the NYDN and the internet.

My sister had worked in social services agencies for years, until she had the first of her kids. She's a great mom, but tends to have a 'therapeutic' perspective on social issues that I find a bit unrealistic. Even she was taken aback by the advice that her kids were getting in school. Basically, as she relates it, her kids' schools have gone overboard in trying to stop aggressive behavior among kids.

They've defined bullying and harrassment very broadly, and implemented their policies accordingly, such that they don't recognize self defense as being distinct from attacking someone. Apparently, when being attacked, the kid is supposed to try to get the attacker to empathize with them, and to then tell a teacher about the ordeal so that they can receive counseling. :scrutiny:

It concerns me that kids are being taught to expect that such an approach should work against someone seeking to do them harm.
 
Captain kid

Street-smart 4-foot-5 girl fights off
6-foot-2 kidnap suspect, helps in arrest

By NICOLE BODE
DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER

Tuesday, May 15th 2007, 4:00 AM

Xochil Garcia may only be in sixth grade but she's got the smarts of a quick-thinking adult. The 11-year-old escaped from an alleged kidnap suspect twice her size in Brooklyn yesterday.

Eleven-year-old Xochil Garcia kept herself ready for the worst, constantly rehearsing in her mind how she could escape an attacker or kidnapper.

Little did she know her hours of mental preparation would pay off - possibly saving the Brooklyn girl's life.

Last night, the 4-foot-5, 80-pound sixth-grader was hailed as a hero for fighting off an attacker twice her size - then having the wits about her to help capture the suspect.

"I always make my plan before there's a robbery or a kidnap[ping]," Xochil said from her Midwood home. "I think of a plan, like, if anybody kidnaps me, kick them back or scratch them - I'm growing my nails out. I went with Plan B."

Plan B meant yanking backward with all her might as Bernard Mutterperl, 19, allegedly grabbed her in her apartment stairwell Sunday, dragged her into the lobby and tried to take her to another set of stairs leading to the roof.

But Mutterperl, who stands 6-foot-2, had picked the wrong target.

"I always tell her, whatever happens, whatever these men do, don't go with them for anything," said mom Martha Hernandez. "Thank God she knows how to defend herself."

Xochil was heading home from the corner store with a new bottle of nail polish for her mom on Mother's Day.

The street-smart pixie spotted Mutterperl tailing her about a block from home and instinctively began to run for the door.

She recalled seeing him talking to her landlord before, she said, and wondered if she had misjudged him.

But after making it up two and a half flights of stairs in her building, Mutterperl grabbed her just short of her apartment, she said.

"He grabbed my mouth and told me to not scream. I thought he was going to take me up to the roof and rape me or something like that," Xochil said.

"When [we] went downstairs, he loosened my wrist a little bit. And I took advantage of that and I broke out of where he was holding me and I ran outside."

Mutterperl was arraigned last night in Brooklyn Criminal Court on charges of unlawful imprisonment, endangering the welfare of a child and burglary. Bail was set at $25,000 cash or $75,000 bond.

"I was really scared," Xochil said. "I never thought this would happen to me. But I calmed down so I could remember my plan."

She waited for Mutterperl's hand to go slack, then made a dash toward the building's front door. There, sobbing and shaking, she pressed all the buzzers in the building, summoning her 18-year-old brother, Angel Garcia, and several other concerned neighbors.

Meanwhile, Mutterperl scrambled to escape, trying the roof and the basement doors before stripping down to his white undershirt in an attempt to conceal his identity, witnesses said.

When he tried to sneak out the front door, the brave girl and her neighbors were waiting.

"My brother said, 'Is that him?' I said, 'Yes.' My brother said, 'Hold on a minute. You're not going anywhere.' Then that's when he took off," she recalled.

Neighbor Timothy Isaac, 25, Angel Garcia, and at least three others caught up to the suspect, bringing him down on the sidewalk across the street.

At first, Mutterperl, of Borough Park, Brooklyn, protested his innocence. But as they waited for cops to arrive, he changed his tune, saying, "I'm sorry, I won't do it again. I won't do it again," as the crowd pummeled him to keep him from escaping, Isaac said.

Xochil, who called for her attacker to get a stiff sentence, warned other kids to think safety first. "Try to figure out a plan before somebody tries to kidnap you. That way if somebody tries to touch you, you're ready to attack them back."
 
Obviously, by obsessing over possible self-defense scenarios she PERCEIVED she might need one day in "America's safest big city," this girl was clinically paranoid. :rolleyes: (yes, that was sarcasm based on anti-gun-owner comments I have heard/read)
 
as the crowd pummeled him to keep him from escaping

when it comes down to brass tacks.....ordinary people instinctively know how to handle this kind of scum.

to bad the libs have managed to infect so many with "brain damage" as a result of their idiotic rhetoric.

This story just made my day. :)

Would our society be better off if we allowed criminals to be "punished"?

How's stoning sound?
 
Too bad she had to use Plan "B". Perverts like this need help, help to keep this from happening again, like being neutered.
Good for this young lady.
 
Wow, she doesn't look "tacticool" to me. She didn't have guns, knives, pepper spray or any of that stuff.

Software, not hardware.


Good for her. Stories like this make me feel good.

attachment.jpg
 

Attachments

  • xochil garcia.jpg
    xochil garcia.jpg
    15.8 KB · Views: 400
She went to "Plan B" because Plan A--awareness and avoidance--was stymied by the fact that the attacker could run and climb stairs faster than she could.

I see no faults here. Too bad Plan A was not fully successful, BUT IT DID put her where "local village" help could be summoned. One smart kid.:cool:
 
It may not take a village to raise a child....

...but a village "educating" a child molester like this is a beautiful thing... :cool:


Tyro: Sorry to hear about your sister. I'm also in the social work field. However, the types I encounter there haven't given me the "therapeutic" view yet. If anything, I'm more protective and convinced to teach my children to fight back in every way. And to point out who tried to hurt them to me so I can administer my own "sex offender treatment" to the client... :fire:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top