14 year old killed in muzzle loading accident

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tuner,

You're right, and I know a gap in the load IS dangerous...my post was poorly worded.

I have loaded 2 full loads in a muzzle loader and fired it without even realizing it was loaded twice...not smart, I know...but it happened. That is...2 powder charges (200 grains total) and 2 bullets (PowerBelts), no gaps in the load though...it fired without incident, but kicked like a mad mule.

The firearm used in that mishap was a T/C Encore, maybe that makes a difference...I don't know.
 
yeah double loads suck! I accidently fired 100gr imr white hot pellets with a 300gr thor and then on top of that an additional 90gr american pioneer with another 300gr thor.

hhhhooooooweeee! my face hurt after that! I only recommend doing that with a scope is NOT mounted!
 
I accidently fired 100gr imr white hot pellets with a 300gr thor and then on top of that an additional 90gr american pioneer with another 300gr thor.
I'm glad your OK! What brand/caliber was the gun? It's a good thing that some muzzleloaders have enough of a safety margin to allow for improper loading.
 
Ridgerunner,

I was watching the movie GETTYSBURG, which they say is as close to accurate as they could make it.
One of the caracters said in the movie:"Some of these guys go home with 7 or 8 bullets in the barrell and never fired a shot."

I know, I know, Its a movie.

Now my question. HOW did they know there were 7 or 8 shots in there?
I can only assume, When they were cleaning the gun later, the ram rod didn't go down very far. And they used a bullet puller to empty it.

With that said, I am sure in a war enviroment, Stress can make you do dumb stuff, Like not check that your gun fired, before reloading.

AND with that said, What situation happened to you that you missed the fact that your ram rod didn't go down all the way?

(I am not trying to start a fight, Please dont take my comments the wrong way.) I am only trying to find out what happened in your case.
 
Well, I think 99.99% of the claims are a crock. I shoot 110 grains of Triple Seven 3fff in my .45 caliber CVA and Traditions and have never had a problem. And PLEASE don't try and feed me that line of s*** about how an inline won't shoot 150 grains of powder and will blow it out the barrel. I have an indian friend right here in Wyoming that wanted to shoot a full load in my CVA. I told him to go ahead. Hell, I had faith in the rifle plus I knew he would instantly replace it for me if the rifle blew up. I loaded it myself. 150 grains of Triple Seven 3fff (I know it's an overload) with a .45 caliber 300 grain sabot. That rifle kicked that redskin so damn hard the stock jumped off of his shoulder and the end of the Zeiss scope slammed into his forehead so hard it left a solid round reddish purplish bruise. (instantly)..He was holding the rifle good to. By God it burned that powder, every last little smidgen of it. He's a pretty hefty blocky fellow and it knocked his ass flat on the ground. ( He wasn't expecting it to kick that hard)..I still shoot that same CVA .45 caliber with my little ol' 110 grains of Triple Seven 3fff and have brought down many a moose, antelope, deer, buffalo and a couple of bear since he shot it and By God I have NEVER had a problem with that inline. NEVER NEVER NEVER....Some of ya'll are just plain full of s***....
 
Last edited:
and By God I have NEVER had a problem with that inline. NEVER NEVER NEVER....Some of ya'll are just plain full of s***....
Sorry, wasn't trying to shake you confidence; I'm sure many CVA's are just as strong as they should be.
 
Bellyup,

According to Smith & Smith Small Arms of the World earlier editions there were 37,574 "muskets" salvaged from the Gettysberg battle fields by the Union. One had 23 rounds in the barrel. 6,000 had from 3 to 10 round loaded and 12,000 had two loads. SO about half of the "dropped" muskets were found with two or more minnies or balls shoved into them.

All it took was for the first load to be loaded incorrectly, say bullet first, or the powder acciedently spilled on the ground during loading, or a plug of dirt from whatever being down the bore that prevents the first round from firing. If the troops are excited (last time folks were shooting at me I was fairly excited) and firing either in group volley or even at will in a large group it might be easy to not notice your musket did not go off. When you are thinking about a cannster ball, shell splinter or Minnie bullet trying to briefly occupy the space you are in I'll bet it was amazing what you might not notice.

Thissalvage operation was one of the main arguements for the addoption of a breech loader as they are MUCH more difficult to shove a second round in after one s not fired.

-kBob
 
Let's add to this, most of the CVA rifles in question were part of a recall and were "modern" in-lines ...not the traditional muzzleloaders most of us play with. I have several older CVA "Kentucky" rifles I have never had a problem with and they are much older than the rifles that blew out their bolts!!!!
Ask yourself this...when, in pyrotechnics, we can use paper tubes as mortars, to repeatedly launch shells with, using black powder, how do you blow up a properly made gun using proper charges and techniques??
Answer: You can't !!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Last edited:
Maybe what the Reporter gopt goofed up on, was the Kid un-did a round of .50 BMG, used the Powder from it, and loaded an otherwise usual projectile...


Who knows!
 
Ridgerunner,

I was watching the movie GETTYSBURG, which they say is as close to accurate as they could make it.
One of the caracters said in the movie:"Some of these guys go home with 7 or 8 bullets in the barrell and never fired a shot."

I know, I know, Its a movie.

Now my question. HOW did they know there were 7 or 8 shots in there?
I can only assume, When they were cleaning the gun later, the ram rod didn't go down very far. And they used a bullet puller to empty it.

With that said, I am sure in a war enviroment, Stress can make you do dumb stuff, Like not check that your gun fired, before reloading.

AND with that said, What situation happened to you that you missed the fact that your ram rod didn't go down all the way?

(I am not trying to start a fight, Please dont take my comments the wrong way.) I am only trying to find out what happened in your case.]

It was pretty simple...I left it loaded because I was planning on hunting the next day too, but I got called in to work...and didn't get back to hunting until 3 days later.

I forgot that I had left it loaded, which is something I don't normally do when its going to be a few days before I get it back out in the woods.

When my son and I did get back to hunting, I told him to load the guns while I was busy doing something else (getting ready to go)

He wasn't familiar with my Encore (I had only had the Encore a few weeks) and how much ramrod was supposed to be sticking up, he just did what I said and loaded it.

I killed a deer with that double load...a nice 6 pointer at about 30 feet away.
 
Last edited:
Slightly off the subject but still along the same general lines. I knew of a man when I was a child in Alabama that had buck fever real bad. When he finally got a shot at a nice deer (on a hunt down in South Alabama) he was so excited he worked the lever and jacked a Winchester .30.30 completely dry without ever actually firing a shot..All I can say is--He must not have been very hungry....
 
I did that too (mine was a Marlin though)...the very first time I ever went deer hunting, that damn safety was on and I was too excited to understand why it wouldn't shoot...LMAO.
 
We don't know any of the facts related to the death of this child...so why does this thread keep going on and on??
 
Why? Because we're discussing gun accidents and loading errors.
 
Why? Because we're discussing gun accidents and loading errors.
No, we're engaging in useless speculation. If we actually had credible information about the incident, then we could discuss facts and make reasonable statements about things we could all do to prevent such an accident in the future. This is no different than the media feeding frenzy that occurs after every airplane crash, in which the talking heads wax eloquently with no information at all.
 
Bluehawk said:
We don't know any of the facts related to the death of this child...so why does this thread keep going on and on??

mykeal said:
No, we're engaging in useless speculation. If we actually had credible information about the incident, then we could discuss facts and make reasonable statements about things we could all do to prevent such an accident in the future.

I disagree that we don't have any useful facts. I think that it's a fact that most gun accidents involving children are due to firearms and/or ammo that are improperly secured and not locked away for safekeeping from inquisitive youths.

If this gun and/or ammo was properly secured then in all probabilty
the minor child would have never been able to get his hands on it unsupervised in the first place.
Even if the gun was over the fireplace, the ammo and powder should have been locked away.
Even if the ammo and powder were locked away and the child obtained them somewhere else, then some other adult somewhere didn't properly lock them away from the child.
The child wasn't "effectively" trained to have a healthy respect for the
firearm. If the child was trained in the proper use of the firearm and to have the proper amount of respect for the firearm then he wouldn't have touched it without supervision or tried to load it with the wrong ammo.
The use of the wrong ammo in the gun is a fact.
No one wants to blame the parent, but in some states the improper storage of a firearm is negligence.
It's basic training that firearms and ammo shouldn't be stored together or to be left accessible to children. That's a fact.
Just because the accident involves a muzzle loader doesn't make it any more acceptable that the weapon, ammo and powder were made accessible to a child by some adult.
I doubt if the child overcame a gun trigger lock, or broke into a locked gun cabinet or a gun safe.
If the key was left for him to find that could be considered to be negligence.
No training is required to buy a muzzle loader, and I don't support prosecuting parents for the firearms accidents of their children. But there's more than just speculation here since a firearm, ammo and powder where in the hands of a child who died by blowing up a gun.
I don't know how the items got into his hands, but evidently it was due to some adult being negligent.
If that's not a fact, then at the very least it points toward enough of a trend that many states make it unlawful to improperly store a firearm. Even if a muzzle loader isn't considered to actually be a firearm, I don't think that it's useless speculation to ponder the consequences of where we all store our guns when children may be in our houses.
So there I said what no one ever wants to say, that a parent or an adult could be at fault for the accident. It doesn't really matter whether the child died because it was loaded right or wrong or not. The fact is that a child was allowed to touch it who was not properly trained or ready with enough knowledge to use it unsupervised in his own yard.
The gun, ammo and powder belonged to someone beside the child, but if it belonged to the child without adequate training then may God help us all. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I accidently loaded a Cap and ball .36 caliber revolver with a .50 caliber ball. It shaved alot off the ball but fired normally. I noticed no difference and I actually lost track of which chamber it was. This had to have been modern powder.
 
Sort of off topic but not really. Why are old percussion shotguns always found loaded. Between my uncle and his fried and you guys on here thats 4 bp shotguns baught loaded. And come to think of it my zouave was loaded to when I got it. People need to be much more careful with bp. Its not like you can pull a slide or bolt to check like a modern gun. ID tape my ramrod but being a reenactor it would not be period correct. I know my gun well enough to know when a ball is seated though. Next I shoot it live ima put a sharpie mark or something on the rammer.

Gambit
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top