I know this is an old thread but oh well.....
The Heritage Rough Riders are ridiculously good value. I was blown away by the accuracy when I shot mine for the first time.
They are not made out of steel, but they make models that are. Basically, the frame is pot metal, and the barrels and cylinders are steel. Anyways, for $150 it is hard to go wrong.
If a Single Six is more accurate it would not make a difference for me because my RR is is accurate enough to hit squirrels at 25 yards. I have actually taken it hunting and killed tree rats. That was proof enough for me.
Wether it will stand the test of time is another question, but for now it is about the best deal going on a new handgun.
The only other brand new gun I have bought that competes in value is a Pietta 1851 Colt Confederate Navy Brass framed Black Powder revolver from Cabelas.... purchased in 2010 for less than $100.
Bottom line is if you are looking for a cheap, accurate, 22Lr/ 22MWR single action revolver, the Rough Rider is an insane deal. It also kind of has this "old feel" to it. Because it is not pristine out of the box it almost whispers to you that it was made in another time.... maybe forged over a campfire by druken idiots, but that is ok because it costs less than a month of marriage counseling and feels better to boot