Rasputin:
What's the pistol to be used for?
There really are quite a few options that don't break your budget, and many others that woudn't break it if you're willing to include a bonus like "that jar of coins on the nightstand" or similar
Used guns aside (I'm sure a lot of people are thinking that you should get a police trade-in J-frame, just because that's IMO one of the cliche answers this question always gets, whether or not it's a great idea
), I think that $350 is the MSRP of the Stoeger Cougar, which feels like a great gun. I haven't shot it, but a) at heart it's a Beretta, and I'd be surprised if the quality was other than completely acceptable and b) if the maker's hype is even partly credible, the rotating barrel system should make it a soft-recoiling gun. (Plus, it's not small, which would help on that count.)
If you're looking for a CCW autopistol (which I'm guessing from the option of Makarov), you might also consider a P11 from Kel-Tec.
There's also the sig (226, IIRC?) that Gander Mountain stores have been selling lately used (some great condition, some so-so) for exactly your price limit; I wouldn't complain if someone handed me a Sig
I don't know if Gander Mt. is in Indiana, but markets are markets, so that seems like a price you could at least aim for in that type of gun. Ammo cheaper than 9mm Makarov, too.
timothy