.380 VS .357 magnum!

.380 vs .357 mag

  • .380, 12 round

    Votes: 55 22.1%
  • .357 Magnum, 5 round

    Votes: 170 68.3%
  • Other (specify)

    Votes: 24 9.6%

  • Total voters
    249
Status
Not open for further replies.
I would recommend a 38 special as it is far easier to shoot in these little guns. I can't recommend the .380 as no bullets in this caliber can reliably penetrate 12 inches while expanding to at least 1.5 times their original diameter.
 
Confusion is being expressed about the origin of the thread, I thought it was pretty simple: Choose between a 12-round .380 or a 5-round .357.
Uh.... if you put it that way, I suppose it would be pretty simple.

It's that little extra checkbox stating "Other (specify)" in the poll that sorta threw that whole concept out the window.

Looks to me like folks have been taking that "Other" aspect literally and well... specifying other.

And they get berated for it, too. Can't win for losin'.

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I usually carry a Sig 225 (9mm). Sometimes though I'll also carry a S&W 640 (.357). Then there are times when I'll carry a Sig 230 (.380). THere is always my old trusted S&W Model 60 (.38 Special)... so it depends on the circumstances, what I'm wearing and the weather...
 
When I can't get away with a 1911, it's a Kahr PM9 in my pocket....about the smallest 9 out there.
 
Rent, rent, rent. . . and then rent some more to find what he is comfortable with carrying and competent with shooting. Take the largest group size shot at any given range and double it. That will be roughly the size of shot group fired by a moderately trained individual at that range when stress is being introduced. If he can physically and logistically do this, try setting the gun on the firing bench(pointing in a safe direction) with the magazine out and slide forward with all applicable safeties on. Now back off about 25-75 yards and sprint to the gun. Load, make ready and engage the target as rapidly and effectively(safely) as he can. To add a bit more stress have his RSO/observer calling out the time as he is are working. Whatever weapon/ammo combination he hits with consistently and quickly would more than likely be the one to pick. And then after the fun of testing and buying is over take a course or two on the basics of pistol craft(malfunctions, reloads, retention, flashlight employment, use of force, use of cover), invest in range time and ammo, and always look for practical ways to improve your survivability. If you read through all of this, thank you for your time and attention.
 
I personally go with the Bersa or Kel-Tek 9's if I was looking for something with HI-CAP and good ballistics. I've got a full size BT9 and they are great guns, I had a KT-P11 and traded it (DOH), I carry a KTP3AT and its a verry reliable gun. but I also carry a S&W 66-2 and it's a hand full. 13rds of 9mm will cover most bases. YMMV.
 
.38 special - J-frame 642 or X42. Good with CorBon DPX ammo. Good pocket carry with pocket holster.
 
a jframe with a pair of crimson trace grips, man they work great together.
 
A 3rd vote on the airweight J-frame .38 in a pocket holster. Gold Dots or DPX.

A good compromise on weight, control, concealability and effectiveness.
 
If I am carrying the weight/size of a 12 shot .380, I'd rather have the .357! Actually, I'd go for a .44 Special with handloads, like the Bulldog. The only advantage of a .380 is when it is in a much smaller, lighter package like a KelTec P3AT or similar.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top