birddog
Member
Hi folks.
Let me preface this by saying I DO plan on recruiting my brother-in-law and his chronograph in the future, but would like some opinions in the meantime.
A couple of questions for you experts:
A couple of months ago, I began handloading for .44 mag. I've met several loads that were pleasant to shoot -- most of them, in fact -- and worked my way up through a couple of manuals to the following load.
Bullet: Speer JSP 240 (with Lee Factory Crimp Die)
Primer: Federal 150
Powder 10.8 gr of Unique
Revolver: Taurus M-44, 6 inch, ported. (also shot this load in my 4" S&W 629 with same results, but I don't plan on hunting with it)
The recoil is moderate, notably less violent than WWB 240's, and the accuracy is superb. According to the cross-referencing I've done, this load should be running around 1200 fps.
Being fairly new to the re-loading scene, however, I am suspicious that this load -- since it's so much easier on the hand than the Winchester White Box stuff -- is not quite that fast. Could the variation in felt recoil be just because of the difference in powder burn-rates? Makes me wonder.
The bottom line is that I'd like to hunt deer with this load, but since it's not beating my shooting hand up, do you think it's powerful enough?
I bowhunt for deer, and know it doesn't take much to kill one as long as the shot is properly placed in the boiler room. However, I am wondering about neck shots (which I prefer when head-on) and shoulder shots. Would this load be up to the task of some serious bone-crunching?
I know, I know, get the chronograph, but I'd just like to hear some opinions in the meantime.
Thanks for bearing with the lengthy question and for any input you have.
Joel
Let me preface this by saying I DO plan on recruiting my brother-in-law and his chronograph in the future, but would like some opinions in the meantime.
A couple of questions for you experts:
A couple of months ago, I began handloading for .44 mag. I've met several loads that were pleasant to shoot -- most of them, in fact -- and worked my way up through a couple of manuals to the following load.
Bullet: Speer JSP 240 (with Lee Factory Crimp Die)
Primer: Federal 150
Powder 10.8 gr of Unique
Revolver: Taurus M-44, 6 inch, ported. (also shot this load in my 4" S&W 629 with same results, but I don't plan on hunting with it)
The recoil is moderate, notably less violent than WWB 240's, and the accuracy is superb. According to the cross-referencing I've done, this load should be running around 1200 fps.
Being fairly new to the re-loading scene, however, I am suspicious that this load -- since it's so much easier on the hand than the Winchester White Box stuff -- is not quite that fast. Could the variation in felt recoil be just because of the difference in powder burn-rates? Makes me wonder.
The bottom line is that I'd like to hunt deer with this load, but since it's not beating my shooting hand up, do you think it's powerful enough?
I bowhunt for deer, and know it doesn't take much to kill one as long as the shot is properly placed in the boiler room. However, I am wondering about neck shots (which I prefer when head-on) and shoulder shots. Would this load be up to the task of some serious bone-crunching?
I know, I know, get the chronograph, but I'd just like to hear some opinions in the meantime.
Thanks for bearing with the lengthy question and for any input you have.
Joel