44 mag hunting revolver and why?

Status
Not open for further replies.
.44 magnum for deer or black bear?
Should work. Any idea what loads you are going to use? Heavy bullets, light bullets? Your load design can help determine your barrel length.

Work backwards. What am I going to hunt? What loads are commonly, or my choice, in that caliber, for that game animal?
Am I really shooting at 100 yards? Go look at ballistic tables to determine bullet drop at that range from 185 to 340 grain bullets, and see what recoil, bullet drop, and power range you can live with. Depending on what you decide it may influence barrel length, powder choice, gun weight.
 
Iron sights, 25 yards or so I feel pretty comfy with a Vaquero in 44 Magnum.

My pistol is ONLY a back up to my rifle, not a primary. Scoped handguns take a LOT of practice to get 'right' in the woods. Throwing a few rounds down range isn't like trying to 'find' a deer in the cross hairs in the woods on a handgun.. its tricky to get the scope in the right place everytime for your perfect sight picture.
 
Good point. Bunch of guys I know use those reddot setups, and swear by them.
Works in dim light, and for bad eyes. Ugly as sin.
 
I have a super blackhawk with a 7.5" barrel. I have killed several deer with it. It never was my primary weapon on any of these hunts. I just saw a deer while I had wandered off from my rifle/shotgun.

I would get a 4.5" barrel if I had to do it again. I have a 6.5" blackhawk convertible. I can carry it if the threat is high enough but it's not an every day carry weapon. It is easy to conceal - any IWB holster that has an opening for the barrel will work. Even the small holsters made for the P-3AT and P-32 work for the Blackhawk, get one with a metal clip.
 
lobo9er what are your limits with your DE as a hunter. Is it undependable , not accurate or to big? I would still make sense to use it . Then buy what ever you want that you can cc. Placeing a reflex or dot on a handgun does tend to make a great hunter out of it and 100 yards from a bench atleast makes for some impressive groups. 3 to 4" at 100 yards is practical even for old eyes is practcal.
 
Look at Single Action

There is a lot of good information being offered here. My question for you is even though you like the Redhawk (own a 7.5 in) and Super Redhawk, do you need the double action capabilities of them for your intended purpose? Because cost is an issue($500 I believe) make sure you dont dismiss the Blackhawk and Super Blackhawk options. They will handle every possible load and leave you with some change towards that carry gun you want as well. I realized quickly that out in the field, I didn't need double action. If you did have a scenario where you knew you were looking at quick multiple shots(hogs), you have the Desert Eagle to cover you there.

Good Luck
 
All good info and insights
what are your limits with your DE as a hunter. Is it undependable , not accurate or to big?

The limitations is ammo versatility. only jacketed bullets 240 grain and up and No hard cast. Not to big of a deal. But it does take away from how versatile the 44 mag cartridge can be.
 
DA doesn't bother me if I was hunting maybe I would change my game up I dunno cuz I have never hunted with a revolver
One should never take the first, standing shot at game in DA mode.
 
One should never take the first, standing shot at game in DA mode.
Hmmm...I'm a whole lot more comfortable shooting DA than SA. I might have to practice up a lot if I'm going to take an SA shot. I'm just not used to it.
 
Hmmm...I'm a whole lot more comfortable shooting DA than SA. I might have to practice up a lot if I'm going to take an SA shot. I'm just not used to it.

I would have to agree. I have been up front with my hunting experience but as far as target shooting with revolvers its always been DA I prefer it also. As long I have a feel for the gun and no how to "setup the hammer" with my trigger finger its more comfortable for me.
 
One shot is generally all you will need hunting with a handgun. If you need a second, it will likely only be a shot after they are down and trying to get up as opposed to hauling butt for the next county because you missed them with your first shot. So, makes no difference between single action or double action revolver choice.

My thoughts on the subject.... 44 mag is a good choice. It is not too big and not too small for the intended quarry. I would be somewhat selective with my shots with a black bear with a 44 mag, but for me, shots at Black Bear are not common and you take what nature serves you. Hence, I would use the 44 mag as a backup to a rifle unless you really don't care if you are successful.

Distance.... Practice. If you can hit a 6" paper plate pretty consistantly out to 100 yds, then you are good to go with the gun and caliber. If not, keep practicing or shorten your distance to where you can pretty consistantly make hits where you point them. A scope helps with consistancy and a red dot is quicker to be on target than a scope unless you practice a lot with the scoped handgun. With scope, assume you will need a rest to take anything other than a very quick shot. Hence, I carry a monopod with me when hunting deer with a scoped revolver.

I use a scoped Super Redhawk in 480 Ruger for deer hunting and would use it for bear if I was bear hunting. It is so darn large that it is very hard to carry a rifle too and actually use the handgun unless you are sitting in a stand.

My general barrel length for hunting is 5.5 -6" minimum, but longer would be better. IF I carry my 4" 41 mag revolver, it is strictly as backup and not the primary gun and shots would always be under 50 yds. I learned that the big revolvers make carrying a rifle rather uncomfortable, so for my woods hunting, I decide before I go whether I will be carrying a rifle or revolver and only take one with me unless it is a shorter barreled revolver which you can pretty easily carry on a belt holster. If you hunt with the revolver exclusively, then you accept that you can not take really long shots and hunt accordingly.

357 mag for deer... it works, but I would keep my distances well below 50 yds and choose your bullets carefully. I generally favor 41 mag or larger for whitetail hunting. Throw in bear hunting possibilites and I would go larger as my choice.

You are going to have to be honest with yourself about your true capabilities with a handgun for hunting. Only you will know at what ranges are are predicatably capable.
 
Check local regulations as well, here if you are hinting with a revolver it has to be at least 6" in length and net 600 ftlb of energy. I plan to use my 6.5" 629 for hunting this year.
 
22-rimfire thanx that was a good post, sounds like you have some hunting under your belt.

And as far as laws go Hunting in NY has really relaxed believe it or not. any center fire pistol any barrel length. Lets you be responsible for your choices. Also no mag restriction on semi autos 6 inch barrel and under and only restrictions on semi-auto shotguns of 5 rounds.
 
It is the same here in TN which I disagree with... any centerfire caliber and no barrel length requirements. So I guess I can carry a 25 ACP pocket pistol and go deer hunting! Oh yeah! It used to be 357 or larger.
 
I'll go for personal responsibility and no stringent regulations any day of the week. Plenty of good deer guns that don't meet the stupid energy and barrel length requirements of some states and that is a shame. If I want to hunt with a 4 5/8" .44Spl, there shouldn't be a law prohibiting it.
 
I have burned a lot of ammo trying to master long shots with a pistol. 50 yards is about max for me. At 100 yards I might hit a paper plate 3 of 5 times. It's not I can't see 100 yards I am not that good. Hitting a paper plate at 100 yards is about the same as hitting inside the 6 ring on a 25 foot air rifle target at 25 yards.
 
Last edited:
I'll go for personal responsibility and no stringent regulations any day of the week.

same here. Before they changed things NY had a grey area about being able to carry your CCW gun while hunting if it didn't fall into the proper caliber and barrel length for hunting, another story though.....
 
I think that is exactly why they changed the rules in TN. I just wish that there was a suggested minimum practical caliber for whitetails in the state hunting guidelines. There are too many idiots who simply don't know and have no experience to make a judgement on caliber choices. LEO's have trouble puting road injured deer down with their 9mm's.
 
If you are looking for a hunting handgun I would stick with something in the 6-8 inch range if you plan on using open sights. 4's are OK but the longer barrels are sooo much easier for most people to shoot well, especially at the longer ranges. I think the "red dot" type sight is the easiest sight to shoot a hangun well with and I usually use one for hunting. By the time the distance gets far enough away that the size of the dot becomes an issue you're already at about the limit of "practical" revolver/handgun hunting ranges. The S&W 29/629, Ruger RH, SRH and BH/SBH all make good hunting handguns. My favorite hunting hanguns are the Ruger SRH and the S&W model 29/629, both with red dot sights mounted on them. My Smith is smoother, has a better trigger and is a little bit more accurate. The Ruger is much stronger and has a better scope/sight mounting system. The Super Black Hawk is another great hunting hangun but for whatever reason I just never shot mine as well as the other 44's that I've had. I think it might have had something to do with the style grip on the Blackhawk.
 
Mine is a Ruger SBH with 7.5 inch barrel. Have hunted deer for years with it and have open sights. Most of the deer harvested were less than 75 yards. I use a monopod or a bipod rest. It does the job, and I dont see the need for a scope at those distances if you are careful and pick your shots. I also enjoy smaller game using .44 Specials with 200gr. LRN cowboy type bullets...its a gas to shoot! Whatever you get, enjoy!
 
I'm picking up a 7.5" Super Blackhawk .44 mag in about two hours. When firearm season opens, this will not be away from my side.
 
I have used a scoped 7.5 inch Redhawk at 100 yards. Paper plate is doable at that range but I could only go 5 for 5 with the scope and a good rest. If you want to shoot 100 yards perhaps start thinking scope, they do come off when not using it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top