45acp revolver

Only stuff you'll find that works for Auto Rim is extremely old Smiths and Colts...
The two Model 625 Model of 1989s (one 3" and one 5") I had worked just fine with .45 AR (and half moon clips). I don't consider them "extremely old"'.
But then, I don't consider myself extremely old either but other's opinions may differ. :D
 
I like Smith 625's(and 325's), but the prices have gotten a bit crazy on them lately.
I love moonclips and pretty much use them exclusively, but auto rim works in the smith's as well.
index.php
Iterations of your 3 are in my safe as well. The 3" was never especially common. I've slicked the actions on mine, and they roll through wonderfully.
There's a 1917 as well, likely like the gun issued my maternal Pap in France.
The moonclips aren't that big a deal, providing the mooning/demooning tools are used. With .45ACP, it is usually possible to pop the rounds in by hand, but you're apt to spring the moon getting them out that way.
They are due for a range run. I do use light-loaded ARs for the 325. It's not much fun with full house ball.
Moon
ETA- bummed that Smith has quit making them. They really are a dandy revo.
M
 
Only stuff you'll find that works for Auto Rim is extremely old Smiths and Colts and, actually, those are probably the ones worth going for as modern .45 ACP DA revolvers leave a lot to be desired. Charter is rife with poor QC, the S&W Governor shoots a .45 ACP down a .410 chamber and kills velocity, and most Smiths and Colts will be running $900 or more.

My solution is I'm buying a Webley and reloading the ammo down to safe pressures.
Not so.......My 2 ea 625's and my 22-4 all woth well with auto rim.
 

Attachments

  • 100_0569.JPG
    100_0569.JPG
    145.3 KB · Views: 6
My brother in law is in law enforcement. Back when he was on patrol him and his partner bought brand new matching 5 inch 625’s. My brother in law loved his and the other guy was 50/50 on it. Partner traded in on a nice 1911 and my brother in law kept it when he left the dept. traded it off stupidly years later and kicks himself in the butt whenever the story comes up…
 
Iterations of your 3 are in my safe as well. The 3" was never especially common. I've slicked the actions on mine, and they roll through wonderfully.
There's a 1917 as well, likely like the gun issued my maternal Pap in France.
The moonclips aren't that big a deal, providing the mooning/demooning tools are used. With .45ACP, it is usually possible to pop the rounds in by hand, but you're apt to spring the moon getting them out that way.
They are due for a range run. I do use light-loaded ARs for the 325. It's not much fun with full house ball.
Moon
ETA- bummed that Smith has quit making them. They really are a dandy revo.
M
Yep, I usually load mine by hand, but I have a few tools for unloading.
The BMT tool is awesome for unloading, a quick twist pops out all the empties.
The "original" style steel de-mooner is a bit cumbersome to use, but it works.
I also use a 3D printed loader/unloader set that I made and it works pretty good as well.

I'll also concur that stout 45acp in the light 325 can be "snappy" - more than I was initially expecting to be honest.

1000009266.jpg
 
Last edited:
I'll also concur that stout 45acp in the light 325 can be "snappy" - more than I was initially expecting to be honest.
A late buddy had one, and always wanted one myself, since I really like .45ACP revos. But yeah, carry it a lot, shoot it a little.
Remind yourself that there is a 329 also....!
But I've got a 340SC, not that an 11oz .357 makes sense.
Moon
ETA-your loading/unloading tools look similar to mine.
M
 
A late buddy had one, and always wanted one myself, since I really like .45ACP revos. But yeah, carry it a lot, shoot it a little.
Remind yourself that there is a 329 also....!
But I've got a 340SC, not that an 11oz .357 makes sense.
Moon
ETA-your loading/unloading tools look similar to mine.
M
The 329 scares me.... My M69 with full 44 mag is plenty for me and it's several ounces heavier than the 329
A buddy has a scandium 360, one full power 357mag out of that was enough for me. 38+P was just right.
 
The 329 scares me.... My M69 with full 44 mag is plenty for me and it's several ounces heavier than the 329
A buddy has a scandium 360, one full power 357mag out of that was enough for me. 38+P was just right.
The 329 isn't so bad, but full power 44 mags are definitely not something you wanna fire a lot of.

I have fired 400gr thru it though
 
The 625 is the 45 ACP revolver against which all other are to be judged! It is the modern evolution of the original 45 ACP revolver the S&W 1917 (not to be confused with the poor imitation from Colt of the same name)

Moonclips rule! And the 45 ACP cartridge is by far the best cartridge to utilize them. Short, fat, rimless cartridges are the best for moonclips. The moonclips are thicker for rimless cartridges and more robust and the short fat cartridges make loading and unloading fast and fumble free.

The most fun revolver you will ever own! Go shoot a USPSA or IDPA match with it. Nothings better than beating the bottom feeders with the noble round gun!

20161230_144536.jpg

As good at TK Custom moonclip are (for rimmed cartridges there are no better) the 45 ACP does not need that level of precision or associated expense. Go to Ranch Products (the modern inventor of the full moonclip) and buy their 625 moonclips in bulk at a huge cost savings.
 
I say there, Mr Ranch, old chap...

View attachment 1212083
I didn't say Ranch Products invented the full moonclip (as you point out) there are full moonclip patents over 100 years old but they did invent the modern version many are using today. Until in the 1980's moonclips in general were pretty rare with the the full moonclip supper rare compared to the far more common two and three round clips. Ranch Products with Jerry Miculek's influence made the full moonclip with modern materials and manufacturing process a viable product reality. The revolver division in USPSA and IDPA were almost single handedly brought into existance by Miculek's influence. The popularity of the modern revolver loaded with full moonclips owes a lot of its (niche) popular to Ranch Products and jerry Miculek.
 
Oh, yeah I have a good supply of Ranch Products clips, and some Wilsons.
My application has been for 6 and 2; I don't have any 1917 half moons at all.

I wish I could find my picture of some of the alternate designs by Smith. There was one that looked like it was competing with the revolver for the number of parts.
 
Take a look at the cylinder wall thickness vs chamber thickness of a 1911.
The 25 series will certainly take more pressure but anything over ACP +P is more than I care to experiment with.
I doubt brass is going to reinforce steel much. I read of the notion a long time ago in a gunzine article featuring overloading the .45 Auto Rim. I mean that big thick rim just HAS to be stronger, doesn't it?
 
A buddy has a scandium 360, one full power 357mag out of that was enough for me. 38+P was just right.
A friend has a similar revolver; it sits a little higher in the hand than a Centennial, and even +p .38s are rappy.
The steel, mag-frame 640 handles magnums better, though it's still not a shoot all afternoon proposition with mags.
Moonclips rule! And the 45 ACP cartridge is by far the best cartridge to utilize them. Short, fat, rimless cartridges are the best for moonclips. The moonclips are thicker for rimless cartridges and more robust and the short fat cartridges make loading and unloading fast and fumble free.
This is certainly true, 9mms work well also. Longer cartridges (.38SPL, for instance) don't work nearly as well. They're handy for administrative stuff, clearing and reloading. The longer rounds are harder to throw into a cylinder, and more likely to escape, or spring, their moon.
The popularity of the modern revolver loaded with full moonclips owes a lot of its (niche) popular to Ranch Products and jerry Miculek.
Not sure I'd even heard of Miculek when I got my first moonclip gun, but Jerry has really helped spread the notion. We always got our moons at gunshows; no idea of a mfg. They always worked just fine, and were amazingly cheap (4 @ $1?). The same vendor always peddled the stamped steel demooning tool.
Moon
 
Anyone shooting .45 SUPER brass in their 625's?

Thicker web in the .45 SUPER brass.

Gotta think the N-fram can easily take a little more pressure than the 45 ACP makes.

Little extra BLAMMO?

Good idea?... Bad idea?
Have used Starline 45 super in the past to load 45 plus p velocity for 1911's. Sierra has a separate loading section for 45 acp revolvers, and it is indeed warmer than the plus p loads listed. Within reason, you would get a round with more umph and more reliable extraction.
 
This one is my favorite. A S&W Model 1917 that shipped in 1918. It came with an almost full box of cartridges on half moon clips, that shipped the same year.


fx88VE.jpg





A couple of Brazilians.

0joeMX.jpg





A model 1955 Target that shipped in 1955.

j8AZmx.jpg





Since I am not Mr Miculek, and don't take part in that type of competition, I much prefer shooting 45 Auto Rim ammo in my 45ACP revolvers. Left to right in this photo, 45 Colt, 45 Schofield, 45 ACP, and 45 Auto rim.

2TYOj0.jpg
 
Last edited:
Anyone shooting .45 SUPER brass in their 625's?

Thicker web in the .45 SUPER brass.

Gotta think the N-fram can easily take a little more pressure than the 45 ACP makes.

Little extra BLAMMO?

Good idea?... Bad idea?
I've loaded mild 45 super for use in my 625's (and glock 21 that's setup for it)
I don't go crazy though.
I use power pistol to push a 230xtp to ~1000fps and a 215wfn to ~1100 fps
I know some people go a lot harder/faster with 45 super but data for it is a lot harder to verify than 45acp or other cartridges, so I tend to err on the side of caution.
 
I have a 4 inch 625 model 1989 and a new 22-4 4 inch model 1950. These two pistols along with the K frames are my favorite pistols period.
Years ago I sold a 625 model 1989 with a 5” barrel and I have kicked myself ever since. If I run across another 5” at the same time that I have the jingle, well…

IMG_4651.jpeg

IMG_0808.jpeg
I’ve been playing with a heavy weight for reasons that would be considered crazy in the lower 48, but here I Alaska every firearm other than plinkers have a heavy bullet loading. This is for woods carry or most of the time around the homestead.
I’m playing with the 304 grain NOE in the ACP revolver can be loaded long. I load this one to 1.385 which is 1/10 longer than the standard COL of the 45ACP.
This loading is for special purposes and the standard fair is 160 grain on the light side, but I have 5 molds from 200 to 260 grain that are for every day use.
I do have a new 290 grain mold that is probably going to be a better choice than the 304.
I have picked up 500 new Remington AR cases that will be used instead of the ACP cases.
 
Since I am not Mr Miculek, and don't take part in that type of competition, I much prefer shooting 45 Auto Rim ammo in my 45ACP revolvers. Right to left in this photo, 45 Colt, 45 Schofield, 45 ACP, and 45 Auto rim.

2TYOj0.jpg
Can I guess, you meant to say "left to right"?
 
Back
Top