I really like the marlin 1894, I've had several and want to recommend one to anybody and everybody, but my new one made by remington was garbage. I sent it back to the factory and they scrapped the whole gun. (supposedly sending a new one, but it's not here yet) Over on marlinowners they don't have anything good to say about the remington made guns of the past year or so.
If you can find a used one, buy it. If you can look one over before you buy, go for it. If you're buying sight unseen off the internet, look into rossi or somebody else.
I really preferred my 357 to my 44mag, but I wasn't hunting with wither of them.