American classic "commander"

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 3, 2011
Messages
90
Location
Cottage Grove Minnesota
Any one else familiar with this pistol? I looked at the full size one 2 years ago, when compared with the rest of the glut of Phillipines made 1911s now on the market, it seemed well made, I was looking for a new carry gun and ended up trading towards one at a gunshow this weekend.

It looks O.K. the sights are dovetailed 3 dot, the rear is drift adjustable and has a set screw, it has a skeletonized commander style hammer, extended beavertail with bumppad, adjustable trigger, low quality laquered wood grips with standard screws, flat mainspring housing, extended thumb safety and extended slide release.

The frame is undercut beneath the trigger guard allowing for a higher grip, the finish is flat/nonreflective on the top of the slide and on the frame, and high gloss blued on the sides of the slide.

The gun has features I like in a 1911, but I prefer a full size over a Commander size, the reason I ended up with this one is the dealer is a guy I trust that always treats me well and was more than fair to me in regards to what I traded towards the American Classic.

When I got home I realized the rear sight needed to be adjusted before I did any live fire with it, I then noticed a small burr on the sight that I had to file off, there was another one on the front sight that I left alone, for the time being. Also the slide had a tendency to hang on the take down notch when racked with no mag inserted, with a loaded mag inserted the gun failed to feed when racked about half the time.

When I broke down the gun there were other small burrs in pin holes that I had to file out. I also noticed there was some wiggle room with the ACT mag that came with the gun, there was a little less wiggle the 2 Mecgar mags that I tried, and very little wiggle with the Wilson Combat Elite mag I tried.

I cleaned up the gun, installed a recoil buffer, attempted to rub some liquid gold into the grips, which is when I realized they were sealed by the laquer, and installed some hex head grip screws, upon reassembly, I noticed several nicks/marred areas in the finish, its a low quality bluing job, that I know wont stand up to daily carry very long.

We took the gun out to shoot at "targets of opportunity" in this case, oranges rotting on the ground at ranges between 7 and 10 yards, in 50 rounds we experienced zero malfunction and a 25% hit ratio with misses closes enough to launch the oranges into the air. Yesterday we took it to the range and put it on paper, in 50 rounds we experienced zero malfunctions, we used the factory mag, the Wilson Combat and both Mecgars during both the function and accuracy tests. The pistol put 8 rounds in one ragged hole using A-Merc 230 grn ammo, and 8 rounds in a 4 inch spread using CCI Blazer aluminum cased 230 grain ammo, range was 8 yards on both targets.

I have decided the gun is adequate, accurate and reliable enough for its intended purpose, I dont give a damn if the bluing gets worn off, the sooner the better, then I can go ahead and have it Parkerized.

I looked at a LOT of Philipino 1911s, the American Classic was BY FAR the best of them, and had far more of the features I require in a carry gun. All I need to do now is decide between Pearce, Hogue or Pachmyer grips, still carrying in my well broken in Desantis Gunhide iwb holster or Desantis Gunhide belt holster.

Any feedback from anyone else familiar with these pistols is greatly appreciated.
 
I did not have to do anything with mine; no burrs, no problems. A few squirts of Breakfree CLP and mine has never given me problems with the ammo chosen for the day of shooting. I wonder if yours is a newer model and they are not bluing the things like they once did? Dunno hope that is not the case. Good luck with yours and hope it gives you many years of service.
 
The commander came out last year But really just now getting on the market. It like the 5" is 1911 compatible. They are well made and like majority of the AC line trouble free.
I have a section for American Classic and 1911 in general at http://bersachat.com and looking to give them their own board in couple months.
 
There is quite a bit of information about them over at the dedicated 1911 forums. From what I'm seeing so far, they're catching on quickly and becoming very popular.
 
I love my 5" American Classic II and have been waiting to find a hard chrome commander at one of my local shops/gun shows. That is on my to buy list as well as their "Trophy"

JOe
 
How did you come to the conclusion that the front sight needed moved before you shot it? And, just curious, but didn't you have the option to decline the purchase when you noticed so many deficiencies?
 
Clarification

I had to reread my own post to make sure I got this right, and now that I am sure that I did, allow me to answer your questions and address issues in no particular order.
I came to the conclusion that I needed to adjust the REAR sight, not the front as stated in your post, I must assume you got confused when I mentioned the burr on the front sight, when I looked at the top of the slide while examining the guns finish, I noticed that that sight was dovetailed in further to the left, a dovetailed sight drifted further over in either direction is oftentimes a good indicator that it will need to be drifted in order to shoot accurately, afterall this was not a "proshop" pistol dialed in at the factory (at the added expense of thier time and ammo).

The conclusions I made regarding the finish and grips, I had no way of knowing until I got the gun home and took it apart, the issues with the bluing came to my attention as a result of parts of the pistol, including the slide, coming into contact with tools while on the work bench, it is indeed an inferior bluing job, and experience has taught me that not every gun that ships out of a factory is a shining example of thier quality, workmanship or potential, same goes in regards to the grips, some people would have been satisfied with them, I expect better. That being said, neither of those "shortcomings" in my opinion, had any affect whatsoever on the performance of the gun when I started shooting it.

In regards to the burrs, this was a totally new experience to me, but it wasnt anything major to me, I dealt with it rather than just giving up on the gun, I have done enough installation/modification that I felt comfortable handling it myself rather than paying a "gunsmith" to do it. As far as the wiggle room in the mags goes, the gun went "bang" every time the trigger was pulled, so obviously there is no problem there.

As far as me going back on the deal after it was made, why would I want to do that? The gun went bang every time the trigger was pulled, the bullets landed where I wanted them to, and the only "deficiencies" I really had any kind of problem with were the grips, easily corrected by the last statement in my post regarding "Pearce, Hogue or Pachmyer" and the finish/bluing, also addressed with the statement of my intention to have the pistol parkerized.

Did I forget anything or leave anything out? If there are still any questions, feel free to p.m. me.
 
Clarification

I had to reread my own post to make sure I got this right, and now that I am sure that I did, allow me to answer your questions and address issues in no particular order.
I came to the conclusion that I needed to adjust the REAR sight, not the front as stated in your post, I must assume you got confused when I mentioned the burr on the front sight, when I looked at the top of the slide while examining the guns finish, I noticed that that sight was dovetailed in further to the left, a dovetailed sight drifted further over in either direction is oftentimes a good indicator that it will need to be drifted in order to shoot accurately, afterall this was not a "proshop" pistol dialed in at the factory (at the added expense of thier time and ammo).

The conclusions I made regarding the finish and grips, I had no way of knowing until I got the gun home and took it apart, the issues with the bluing came to my attention as a result of parts of the pistol, including the slide, coming into contact with tools while on the work bench, it is indeed an inferior bluing job, and experience has taught me that not every gun that ships out of a factory is a shining example of thier quality, workmanship or potential, same goes in regards to the grips, some people would have been satisfied with them, I expect better. That being said, neither of those "shortcomings" in my opinion, had any affect whatsoever on the performance of the gun when I started shooting it.

In regards to the burrs, this was a totally new experience to me, but it wasnt anything major to me, I dealt with it rather than just giving up on the gun, I have done enough installation/modification that I felt comfortable handling it myself rather than paying a "gunsmith" to do it. As far as the wiggle room in the mags goes, the gun went "bang" every time the trigger was pulled, so obviously there is no problem there.

As far as me going back on the deal after it was made, why would I want to do that? The gun went bang every time the trigger was pulled, the bullets landed where I wanted them to, and the only "deficiencies" I really had any kind of problem with were the grips, easily corrected by the last statement in my post regarding "Pearce, Hogue or Pachmyer" and the finish/bluing, also addressed with the statement of my intention to have the pistol parkerized.

Did I forget anything or leave anything out? If there are still any questions, feel free to p.m. me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top