Monkeybear
Member
- Joined
- Jan 27, 2006
- Messages
- 1,178
As far as modern double stack autos go is there any real difference in concealibility among them?
Considerations
FNP-9
Glock 19
Walther P99
Former Considerations
Beretta Px4 (bit on the large side)
Springfield XD (not sure if I can get used to the grip safety)
HK P2000 (too expensive and I didn't care for my last HK)
S&W M&P Compact (teething issues???)
Each of these compact/fullsized polymer autoloaders seems about the same size and weight to me. Dose anyone with experience carrying different guns that appear the same size have any input about actual differences while carrying?
These are all supposedly excellent guns. I tried to choose based upon ergos and as I am still a relatively new shooter I don't have a whole lot of preferences ingrained into me. Just about any gun I hold in my hand for a few minutes at the shop starts to feel just fine to me. I guess I just adjust to them. I tried the "hold-the-gun-up-without-looking-and-see-if-the-sights-line-up" trick someone told me about. It is supposed to check if the gun points naturally for a give person. They all line up the second time I try.
As far as triggers go, once again I can't really tell the difference between a good trigger and an ok one. The P22 trigger is awful. Everything else feels good to me.
Basically I am starting to think I might be able to adapt to whatever I buy and since I am having a hard time deciding on which gun to buy, typical, I figured maybe I would try to see if concealibility is a factor.
Just a very confused guy looking for a new poly double stack carry gun and looking for a bit of direction.
I will mention that I have a very nice new Beltman gunbelt and that I plan to order a Bladetech holster to hold me over until the Mitch Rosen holster I order comes in.
Thanks!
Considerations
FNP-9
Glock 19
Walther P99
Former Considerations
Beretta Px4 (bit on the large side)
Springfield XD (not sure if I can get used to the grip safety)
HK P2000 (too expensive and I didn't care for my last HK)
S&W M&P Compact (teething issues???)
Each of these compact/fullsized polymer autoloaders seems about the same size and weight to me. Dose anyone with experience carrying different guns that appear the same size have any input about actual differences while carrying?
These are all supposedly excellent guns. I tried to choose based upon ergos and as I am still a relatively new shooter I don't have a whole lot of preferences ingrained into me. Just about any gun I hold in my hand for a few minutes at the shop starts to feel just fine to me. I guess I just adjust to them. I tried the "hold-the-gun-up-without-looking-and-see-if-the-sights-line-up" trick someone told me about. It is supposed to check if the gun points naturally for a give person. They all line up the second time I try.
As far as triggers go, once again I can't really tell the difference between a good trigger and an ok one. The P22 trigger is awful. Everything else feels good to me.
Basically I am starting to think I might be able to adapt to whatever I buy and since I am having a hard time deciding on which gun to buy, typical, I figured maybe I would try to see if concealibility is a factor.
Just a very confused guy looking for a new poly double stack carry gun and looking for a bit of direction.
I will mention that I have a very nice new Beltman gunbelt and that I plan to order a Bladetech holster to hold me over until the Mitch Rosen holster I order comes in.
Thanks!
Last edited: