Are there any 'good' reloading kits?

Status
Not open for further replies.

dcktp37

Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2010
Messages
33
Location
Ironton Ohio (about as far south as you can go)
I know there are a few kits out there but are any of them worth buying?
I know they all have there goods and bads but what one would would be your pick? Something good for starting out. Not too expensive but still has most of the tools you'll need. And works well enough for most people.
 
One more vote for the RCBS Rockchucker kit. I loaded for years on a Rockchucker (over 25 years) and it is still in great shape. RCBS also has a lifetime warrenty.
 
+3 on the Rockchucker kit. Excellent press to learn on and will last a lifetime. Even if you move on to a progressive later on, it will still be invaluable for accurate rifle loads and working up new loads.
 
Depends on your budget.
The Rockchucker kit is gonna run you a little over $300.

If that's too much for you the Lee Challenger Breech Lock Single Stage Press Anniversary Kit is less than a hundred at MidwayUSA. This is the kit I started with. I've since replaced the scale & powder measure. But it's a whole lot easier for me to lay out $100 at a time than $300+.
 
You might want call RCBS customer service line and ask them if they have any seconds in the kit format... The second I purchased was a turret deluxe kit for only $241.00... The
seconds are generally from gun shows.. Mine is in perfect condition and works great.
 
It depends on what calibers you plan on reloading. If it's rifle then I would start with a single stage. If it's pistol then I would start with the Lee classic turret from www.kempfgunshop.com and buy the Dillon beam scale. If you are like 95% of the people I know you will want a different press after a couple of weeks if you start loading pistol on a single stage press, it's very slow.
 
Have to say I think Rusty is spot on, except for the beam scale, but that is a preference thing, I prefer digital, but I don't even use mine much since I only use it to check my thrown charges.
 
i went with the rcbs rockchucker kit and put a hornady lock n load conversion bushing in it. I plan on buying a hornady lock n load for pistol in the near future. It was good to spend the last year and a half learning on a single stage.

I went with the rcbs b/c of the scale that was included (ive heard that other brands can be hard to use) and the rock hard press. I looked a the demo's of the lee presses when i was at cabelas and they all appeared to be missing parts (like the knob on the handle) and were wobby...not the case with the rockchucker. The rockchucker just felt smoother when pulling the handle. As far as lee goes, i have been more than satisfied with their dies, it could just be that the presses in the store had been abused.
 
Last edited:
I bought, and learned on, a Rockchucker Supreme kit. That was several years and many thousands of rds. ago. Still works awsome. Oh, the scale that comes with it is made by Ohaus. They seem to be a significant name in the quality scale industry.
 
I don't care to put out the money if I know I'm not going to have to put it out again. How good are the scale and powder measure in the Rockchucker kit??

I bought a similar Rock Chucker Kit 40 years ago. It is still is in perfect condition, and though I bought a progressive (RCBS Pro 2000) 2 years ago, I still use the Rockchucker in each and every rifle reloading session.

That kit, 40 years ago, wasn't much different than the one you buy today. Except that it lacked the hand primer found in today's kit. I bought an old Lee single-load primer tool soon after, upgraded to the primer tray loading Lee as soon as they made it available, and finally upgraded to the super RCBS APS universal hand primer. (a perfect companion to my Pro 2000.) The hand primer in the kit is a tray loading tool that uses the same shell holders as the press does..not the APS tool with universal shell holder, but its still a quality tool. You'll like it fine.

RCBS scales are highest quality as is their powder measures. My old 40 year-old Uniflow is identical to the new one that came with my progressive...that ought to say something. Good enough that RCBS still hasn't felt the need to improve on it.

Keep in mind that if you intend on loading rifle you need a way to trim cases. My choice 40 years ago was a Forster trimmer...another design that has never died nor changed. (except that they added a 3-way cutter this year!)

You won't have to "put out" again with these tools...except to add to them.
 
IMO a turret will only help you if you're loading a lot of pistol. If you're going to load rifle, do it in batches so that you don't have to change dies all that often. Resize and decap a bunch of cases at one time. Then check your case length and trim when necessary. Then prime that batch. You will then have fifty or a hundred cases ready to charge and seat. When you're ready to charge and seat, that's when you can measure different weights of powder and different bullets as you work up a load. Batch your cases when you prep them and you will understand that a turret press really has no advantage over a single stage when you are loading for a rifle. BTW, I too started with a Rockchucker Supreme kit and I am still using the scale and powder measure that came with it after four years. Good luck and good shooting.

Historian
____________
"A general dissolution of principles and manners will more surely undo the liberties of America than the whole force of a common enemy."

Samuel Adams
 
if you want to split the difference in price I started with the Lyman pro kit. Currently $185 at Midway. It has served me well for a long time.
 
I'd give a plug to the Lyman kit, either the Crusher or T-mag. The kit is well set up with accessories including a trimmer. The T-mag is the kit I have and the only real drawback is the cost of the turrets, but it works well for pistol and rifle

You can buy the kit with or without the electronic scale, I have the beam scale and although I have since purchased a RCBS 1500 auto dispenser, I still use the beam to check my 1500. As far as the powder dispenser in the kit goes, it's one of the best manually operated powder throwers available, IMHO.
 
When it comes to the press i didnt skimp out, I went with the RCBS rockchucker, i just recently bought some lee dies and I think they work great, they dont fit as snug as my RCBS dies do, but for the price im saving they still produce exceptional ammo.
I would recomend a rockchucker kit or make your own and get a older model rockchucker from the 80s off ebay. For dies lee works great, and the RCBS uniflow measure is superior to work with as well.
 
I guess I should have added that I was wanting to load mostly rifle. But I like the idea of the turret. And I love how easy it looks to change out dies in the LNL systems.

You can get the LNL bushings separately, and they screw nicely into the Rock Chucker if you think you want that feature. Most people don't think losing 5 seconds every time they need to change a die is that big a deal.

You also have to find a new home for your dies so embellished...they won't fit the die cases they came in with the bushings mounted.;)

You do have that option though. Hornady has a kit to do it.

Can't comment on the turrets. Never used one. Went straight to a progressive.
 
I would recomment the Lee Classic Turret to any new reloader over ANY single stage press.

List of other stuff you need:

A manual (Lyman's would be the first one on my list)
Scale
Powder measure
Case trimmer (if reloading for rifle)
Calipers
Primer pocket cleaner
Priming tool (you can prime on the press, but it's nice to have for the times you don't want to prime on the press)
Priming tool shell holders
Case lube (Lee case lube or Imperial sizing wax)

After that the first two things I would buy are:

Brass tumbler
Chronograph
 
"I know there are a few kits out there ... know they all have there goods and bads"

You're correct, they are all "good", none of them are really bad. Perhaps the worst of the bad is the most often touted kits are greatly overpriced for many beginners and limit you to having everything the same brand. In spite of what some seem to think, no single brand has a lock on the best choices of any reloading tool but with a kit you get what they sell.

You see some great comments on the Rock Chucker press but little about any others. I have an RC myself. Fact is it's about as good as any of its type but certainly no better. You really don't hear of anyone "wearing out" a press that's been properly used and maintained with a little oil from time to time! No press that's abused will last very long.

My suggestion is to avoid any kit, get the press you want and get the other parts from the best, most effective designs.

Lee's auto-indexing Classic Turret press is excellant for faster production. It has a cast iron body, a fully adjustable lever for maximum user flexibility. For a turret it's unique in that it supports the head without springing. The turrets are as inexpensive as a set of "quick change" bushings; a head set up with dies can be exchanged in seconds without tools.

I prefer single stage presses, I seek precision rather than quanity. If I had to replace my RC tomorrow it would be a Lee Classic Cast single stage. It's the best of its type currently available, at any price.

Lee's inexpensive little "Perfect" powder measure isn't perfect but appears to be the most consistant measure available, especially so for the commonly hard to consistantly dispense coarse rifle powders. It does require a bit of breaking in and adjustment, that seems to throw some folks.

The RCBS 505 is the best scale value currently available. Get a Redding or Hornady powder trickler to go with it.

Dies are dies. Forget the externals. Ammo is made inside and there really is no average effective difference in internal tolerances and finish between brands. Lee's Pacesetter and Delux die sets include a $7-8 shell holder for "free." The Pace setters include a seperate crimping die, the Delux sets include a neck sizer die for bottle neck cartridges. Bottom line, pay whatever it takes to make yourself comfortable and know you have bought as good dies as any.

Case lubes: I'd get Hornady Unique or Redding Imperial and apply it with my finget tips, no sprays or lube pads for me!

Lee's case length trimmers are simple, consistant and a great value. If you REALLY want an adjustable trimmer the Lyman Universal is perhaps the best value. The Wilson is perhaps the most precise trimmer, but there are some valid questions of the value of truly great precision when case trimming anyway.

A good beginners reloading manual is a must for noobs. I used to suggest Lyman but the lastest edition, #49, is greatly reduced from previous editions. The current Hornady is much better and Lee's is also good, both have lots of clear illustrations and explainations for noobs as well as some really good data tables.

Other gadgets such as loading blocks, powder funnels, deburr/chamfer tools, etc, really won't much matter, they are all quite good for their purpose.

Case tumbers are popular but only fluff, that's why they aren't included in anyone's kit. They are nice but certainly not needed.
 
Last edited:
I have the Hornady manual and have read through it and learned A LOT it really is a great manual. And I have a sonic cleaner just because I liked the idea of how it cleans them and I found one for cheap so I bought it. I've yet to find a good cleaning solution though I've not bought any that is actually for cleaning cases.
 
Amen to that! ranger335v is right on the money, in my honest opinion. I've been reloading for more years than I care to admit, and have accumulated buku equipment, and the one "extra" that has been the most adventageous to me is a chronograph...hands down. It really gives a true picture of what your loading and what your trying to accomplish.

For what it's worth, I almost always use my Lee classic cast turret. Pleanty big for almost every rifle, but excellent on pistols as well. And... you can disable to auto index in about 30 seconds and have a single stage press as well.

I would almost guarantee you'll be more than happy with a Lee turret press kit. Reload for a while and take time to decide what you really want for extras and accumulate those extras slowly. This will allow you to avoid impulse buying and ending up with stuff you really don't need, as I have found out.

One other super cheap item that I would not be without is a set or two of Lee dippers. Once you weigh what each dipper is throwing, you can get damn near as close as a powder measure with each charge in much less time.

Whatever you decide, welcome to the club and have fun with this hobby!
 
Last edited:
For rifle get a single stage or a turret press. If you insist on kits then that pretty much limits you to....

• Hornady LNL Classic Kit (uses the LNL bush you like) HERE
• Rock Chucker Kit (which is adaptable to LNL bush) HERE
• Lyman T-Mag Turret Kit (which is the only kit with a trimmer) HERE
• One of the many Lee kits (none of which adapt to LNL bush)


- The Lyman kit also comes with the Lyman Manual which is pretty much the hobby's standard manual for loading anything.
- The Hornady, RCBS & Lyman all have equivalent powder measures and scales, Lee is the 'odd man out' there
- All 4 kits use standard dies you can buy from any of the others
- With the Hornady press and/or dies you get a free bullet offer
- Remember "low price" is a feature. You get what you pay for.

;)
 
Last edited:
i bought a lyman crusher press and lee dies for my RUM300..it was junk. The primer tube had burs in it and the primers did not feed. The shell holder had a lot of play at the top of case +-5/8". The priming arm flew apart after about 20 primers after i got the bur out. Good luck on finding the springs..The scale is a piece of ****. I had to re zero it several times after an hour of fooling with it with both AC & DC power sources I gave up. It was drifting .8 gr on the same powder tray just by taking it off the scale and then replacing it. I though it may be my phone or a magnet so I moved it to a table free of metal (no luck).

I gave up and boxed it up took it back to BassPro shope and bought the RCBS Supreme Chucker Kit ($319).

You can feel the diference. There is not slop in the movement and the 5-0-5 scale is still metal not plastic. The kit came with a hand priming tool (worth it). The only drawback is it does not have a case trimer. I have been using the RCBS neck dies and growth so far is not an issue. The lube pad is messy (go with spray). The only other issue if you are loading BIG cases the powder througher only can through 100gr at a time (I need to see if I can get a bigger cam). In short you get what you pay for.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top