Beam Scales??

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tusker10mm

Member
Joined
May 12, 2003
Messages
140
Location
Winchester,VA
SOLD-------Beam Scales??

Anyone still use one of these?? I have a RCBS 5*10, like new in the box with the cover and was wondering about selling it?? Just don't know if there is a need. Was going to ask $65.00 SHIPPED but whether or not there is any need is a mystery around here?? Just wondering?? :)
 
Last edited:
Just got a 'new' lyman d5 scale. I really like it. You can tell at a glance if you're so much as a hair over or under. The scale body has .1 grains marks on it so it's easy to see resolution much finer than .1 grain.

I don't know that you need the level of precision, but it's nice to have.
 
I have a small Franklin electronic scale and a RCBS Chargemaster. I inherited a beam scale that I never use. I have check weights.

The only use I have for the beam scale is as backup for the next EMP induced national power outage.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
I have 10-10 and RCBS 1500 scale.

1500 scale it's great for checking H20 case capacity,case/bullet weight and I even use it to weight my hunting/match arrows from bare shaft to finish.

I could weight powder with 1500 but been using 10-10 long time at it's pretty accurate.
 
I use my LEE Safety Scale to double check my Frankford electronic scales.

Do not trust any electronic scale.
 
Does anyone STILL use a beam scale? Well, YEAH - it is the ONLY scale I will use for reloading. If I ever found a stupid ridiculous electronic scale wandering round in my reloading room, I'd shoot it faster than a rabid rat.
 
Yeah, I use electronic toys to weigh my jerky after it has been smoked and dried, NOT to weigh things that go boom.
 
Good grief, the old mechanical beam scale versus the newER digital electronic scale debate.

Of course BOTH have applications in today's handloading hobby. Back in '98 I bought a RCBS powder pro digital scale. It still works just great. Never has failed, always shows the check weights to weigh what they're supposed to. Accuracy to one tenth grain is all anybody needs. That scale was made by PACT for the guys in green.

About 3 years after I bought the powder pro, I added a PACT dispenser to it to automatically measure each powder charge, to the tenth grain. It too has continued to work as designed.

You devotees of balance beam scales try this trick. Place an empty case that's ready to be charged on the scale pan. Zero the scale to show no weight with the case on the scale pan. OOPS, you can't!!:uhoh:

Alright do the same on a digital scale, tare the case to show zero. Now charge the case, place it back on the scale, the readout is ONLY the powder that you just dumped in the case. Easy way to see how much powder is actually in the case, also see any variation in each dump of whatever measure you're using.

Weighing odd weights is as simple as placing the item on the scale. No guessing what you think it may weigh. Like two H xtp bullets, both magnum but one is a 300 grainer, the other is a 350, but both look alike.

Sorting my cast boolits. Unseen voids are hard to detect. But placing a casting run of boolits one at a time on the digital scale is as quick as you can pick one up and place it on the scale platen. Beam scales would require moving weights around on the beam to see the actual weight.

As for not trusting electronics, what are you doing on your computer? Or your cell phone? Most cars today are controlled by several computers. There's no adjustments to control spark advance or dwell, like on my 66 chevell 327.
 
I still have my old Lyman M5 scale but do not use it much. I have setup and been using a RCBS Chargemaster Combo which I have come to really like using. With scales it is pretty much to each their own. I also have an ole Lee scale and RCBS digital. Anyway, if the Chargemaster fails I still have my Lyman M5 to fall back on. All one needs is a good, accurate reliable scale.

Ron
 
All of my rifle loads are weighed on a beam scale. I throw charge a bit light out of the powder measure into the pan, pan onto scale, a couple of blips on the electric powder trickler button and into the case.
This system has worked fine for me.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
It's a simple ROI for me. I don't see that the extra cost of an electronic scale outweighs the cheaper beam scale. You use check weights to calibrate both. Not sure wind will affect an electronic scale as much. I use a digital caliper to measure my COL.
 
Ok - I own up. I'm 1066 and I'm a beam scale user. :) Sure, I have an Ohaus lab scale with numbers, but I weigh all my powder on a beam scale.

The last RCBS 5-10 left the factory more than fifteen years ago but these are great scales, in fact, one of the best. They have all the attributes of the 10/10, they use the same beam as the 10/10 with the rotating barrel poise and also have the same approach to weight system used in the 10/10. The other bonus is that they stopped making them before the quality started to decline.

Here's a 5-10 I added a camera to a while ago.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bVtYglAd9Dc
 
I used a beam scale until around age 45 when it got harder to read. Nothing like the speed, ease & accuracy of a digital scale. Been using the RCBS 1500 for 12 years now.
 
It's a simple ROI for me. I don't see that the extra cost of an electronic scale outweighs the cheaper beam scale. You use check weights to calibrate both. Not sure wind will affect an electronic scale as much. I use a digital caliper to measure my COL.
Actually we are seeing electronic digital scales with a lower price tag than a decent beam scale. :)

Ron
 
I went to a Dillon D-Terminator a while ago, I always use check weights when I move it around, and it's always on. I still have a beam scale around somewhere, but my electronic scale is faster and works just as well.
 
I just purchased a RCBS 1010 beam scale for under 70 bucks. Needs some work, but with the help of the good folks at RCBS, it will be as good as new when the parts arrive. Furnished at no charge, by the way.

Have a blessed day,
 
Hehe - I use a beam (RCBS 505) to verify the electronic RCBS Chargemaster. And, will on occasion, use my "cheapo" Lee safety scale (beam) - they all read the same.

I think we all need to be able to verify weights - especially powder - on more than one instrument.
 
I use to have a 5-10 years ago, something went wrong with it (too long ago, don't remember!!) Talked to rcbs about it and they said send it back and they will check it out.
About a month or so later, they send me a new 10-10 scale and said it was a replacement for the no longer made 5-10...Like I said it was a long time ago...

Been using the 10-10 for many years now also, no issues, but decided to buy a RCBS 1500 scale ans dispenser about 6 years ago...It has worked great.
BUT...Still use the 10-10 a lot..!!!

YEP...I Still use one and always will. :D

TxD
 
I use both. My favorite scale was my original RCBS beam scale, that I received as a present in 1970. I used it for all my heavy rifle load development. Plus I have lived in a few places that did not have constant electricity.
A few years ago my wife bought me a Charge Master. I use it for medium pressure loads. I also have a Lyman beam scale and an old Herters scale.

BUT tragically during our last earthquake my RCBS scale went flying and a big piece of solder-tin mix fell on top of it. It broke the frame of the scale.
I tried making some home repairs but it is not working.
I still have it on display on my guest-hand-loader table. ( I have a table for guest hand-loaders a few feet away from my bench. )

Bench 1 is the guest bench and bench 2 is my usual bench. I screwed the radio on the wall since then and have added a couple old kitchen cabinets on the walls above for powder and die set storage.
attachment.php


attachment.php


[IMG]http://www.thehighroad.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=178122&d=1358889713[/IMG]

[IMG]http://www.thehighroad.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=178123&d=1358889775[/IMG]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top