Bear shot with 444 Marlin, attacks hunter.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rob96

Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2002
Messages
1,546
Location
Allentown, PA
Shot four times, bear bites, claws Pa. hunter
By Mark Scolforo
Of The Morning Call

HARRISBURG, Pa. | -- In what Pennsylvania game authorities said was an apparent first, a black bear bit and clawed a hunter who had just shot it four times.

Samuel H. Beauchamp, 47, said he was approaching the downed 320-pound bear in Rothrock State Forest in Huntingdon County on Monday, the first day of bear-hunting season, when it came after him.

Beauchamp, of Newville, had just shot the bear four times with a high-powered .444-caliber rifle and was within 15 feet when the bear attacked.

He turned to run, but the bear put a claw around his hip and bit him twice, once in each thigh, before dying.

"The bear wasn't attacking 100 percent. I mean really, it was dead on its feet when it came up. If it would have been 100 percent I wouldn't have been standing there," Beauchamp said Friday.

Other hunters nearby heard a growl and came to Beauchamp's aid.

"It was shock at first. It's like he came alive, like 'boom.' I guess he growled, like the other people heard. That motivated me to turn around and start running away. It just reminded me of a gigantic black dog," he said.

Game commission bear biologist Mark Ternent said the attack was the first case known to state officials in which a bear in Pennsylvania has attacked a hunter who had just shot it and was attempting to recover it.

"Any downed game must be approached with caution. Hunters should stay back and monitor whether the bear is moving, or breathing, with the aid of binoculars or the scope on their rifle, before closing in," Ternent said.

Beauchamp, who missed two days of work from his job inspecting radar systems for the federal government, was released from the hospital after about two hours of treatment. The wounds -- one bite went down to the bone -- were left open to help combat possible infection, and he expects he will have some scarring.

"I didn't feel any pain after it happened. I'm a little sore now," he said Friday.

He retrieved the carcass, took it to a game-checking station and gave the skull to the Game Commission to have it checked for rabies.

The butchered bear meat is now stored in Beauchamp's freezer, and the hide is being tanned and mounted by a taxidermist.

As a Boy Scouts scoutmaster, Beauchamp figures he will be recounting the attack for the rest of his life.

"I like telling stories. This one will keep the boys interested," he said.

Copyright © 2005, The Morning Call
 
Not really a suprise. I have seen animals dead on their feet before.
I do wonder where the 4 shots went though. Why didn't one of them go into the head?
 
harumph

see! maybe those game wardens weren't pulling my leg up in ak when they told me that a 30-06 deflected off the skull of a grizzly.
 
Shot a Bobcat at 7ft with a .44 Magnum Redhawk, the thing jumped strait up 6ft and was blown backward 6ft. He hit the ground and ran for 50 yards before he folded. He was hit right behind the front shoulder, right where you would hit a deer. He had an exit wound that was huge. They don't call animals wild for no reason.
 
I spell it SatCong. The board assigned the name "SATKONG" as my second choice, because when I first registered I was informed "SatCong" was already in use. I CHOOSE to spell it the way I do because that is how I spell it on several other boards to which I belong.:neener::neener:
SatCong
 
dang....4x290...I am guessing he was using factory...jeez...I think if I were him I would be going to the graduated model...the 450 Marlin GG loaded down with sledgehammers or some such...


Could it have been a Sow with cubs in the area?


D
 
I have always been told that you can't shoot a bear driectly between the eyes because their skull is angled and may deflect a bullet.
 
I once read the 444 had a problem when first introduced with bullets not being made for its velocity level. The bullets of the day including the factory load stuff was designed with handgun velocity in mind and they had a tendency to come apart on heavier game such as bear and elk. As I recall the Remington stuff had the same 240 gr slug as their 44 mag handgun ammo. The fact the hunter shot 4 times and sill found a live animal when he went up to it makes me wonder if he might have used a poor bullet choice if reloading or factory ammo is still useing handgun bullets.
I`ve no experiance with this round, just relaying what I remember reading a few years ago.
 
444

IIRC, the 240gr load is suitable for the handgun whilst
the 300gr is preferred for the rifle. Guess buck fever
goes both ways huh?-funny what adrenaline can do.
Stories -nah Id say keep this to hisself.
 
My bet is:

1. Poor shot placement
2. Problems with the cartridge itself (reloads not matching bullet and powder charge well, or a suboptimal factory load).
3. Really really bad luck.

In that order. Or, most likely, a combination of at least 2 of the 3 above.

Mike
 
Anyone who has ever been around bears knows just how tough they are. They are also extremely fast and can be on you in seconds if you are under 25 yards distance from them if they have their heart set on attacking, especially when wounded seriously. Almost any animal will fight to some degree, including whitetail deer.

The Marlin 444 round is typical of what a PA hunter who has more guns (than his 30-30) might choose for bear, especially if they like lever guns. I believe it was poor bullet performance with some shot placement tossed in for good measure. Bears are tough animals!! It is also just one of those things that happens periodically with bears. You have to respect your quarry.

Did any of you see the estimated bear kill numbers for PA this year? I believe it was something like 2,800. Record breaking bear kill. There are too many black bears in PA. Great game animal and good for PA sportsmen.
 
We don't know what load he was using. That could be a factor. In reality though, I think it was simply a matter of approaching the bear too quickly. Adrenalin can do amazing things, especially if you don't know you're supposed to be dead.
 
No bullet is going to deflect or bounce off a bear. However, it's well known that at rifle velocities the lighter .444 bullets tend to fail on impact because they are in effect .44 Magnum bullets and have no business being driven to rifle velocities. The larger hardcast bullets should be used for bear. I don't know what this fellow was using or where he hit, of course, but it wouldn't be the first time a .444 with light bullets failed in the field.

Also, I remember reading a few years ago reading in the ADN about an Alaska black bear that did something very similar to this, latching onto the leg of a hunter after being shot at close range. The bear was essentially dead when it bit him, but nothing is as dangerous as a dead bear. That's why you keep pumping bullets into them as you approach.
 
22-rimfire said:
Anyone who has ever been around bears knows just how tough they are. They are also extremely fast and can be on you in seconds if you are under 25 yards distance from them if they have their heart set on attacking, especially when wounded seriously. Almost any animal will fight to some degree, including whitetail deer.

The Marlin 444 round is typical of what a PA hunter who has more guns (than his 30-30) might choose for bear, especially if they like lever guns. I believe it was poor bullet performance with some shot placement tossed in for good measure. Bears are tough animals!! It is also just one of those things that happens periodically with bears. You have to respect your quarry.

Did any of you see the estimated bear kill numbers for PA this year? I believe it was something like 2,800. Record breaking bear kill. There are too many black bears in PA. Great game animal and good for PA sportsmen.

And despite record breaking bear harvests, the population continues to rise. Something like 15,000 + bears in PA. I think every county but one has bears. This guy was lucky it wans't one of the 1,000+ pound black bears that we have.:eek:
 
When he approached the bear, the rifle should have been pointed at the bear with a live round in the chamber. He wrongfully assumed that the bear was already a goner. Never be too sure. When the bear stirred he should have fired that round into the bear first before running away.
 
Alaska F&G recommends that you continue to empty your rifle into the bruin as you approach, then wait awhile keeping the animal covered before you move in to check the eyeball. This is frankly a lot more important than what particular cartridge you use.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top