Best Low Price Semi-Auto?

Which Semi-Automatic Shotgun is Best?

  • Stoeger 2000/3500

    Votes: 6 7.7%

  • Weatherby SA-08

    Votes: 2 2.6%

  • Remington 11-87

    Votes: 22 28.2%

  • Mossberg 930/935

    Votes: 36 46.2%

  • Other (Post Below)

    Votes: 12 15.4%
  • Total voters
    78
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Rhyno37

Member
Joined
May 29, 2010
Messages
95
Location
Central Illinois
I want to get a mid-range semi-automatic shotgun. As much as I'd like a Benelli or Winchester, I can't afford once since I am buying an AR at the same time. I'm looking to send at tops $700, but would like to keep it around $500 if possible.

I will use this shotgun for mainly clays, and some dove hunting. For deer I used a muzzle loader, so I don't necessarily need something where a rifled barrel is available, but it'd be a nice option. I only listed the shotguns I could think of in my range, so feel free to post any others you would recommend.

I'm leaning towards a Stoeger just because my buddy has had a M2000 for a while, and loves it. He's had no problems. Also, I've heard they are made by Benelli, so I figure they must be good, but I may be wrong.
 
I voted Stoeger because that and the 11-87 are the ones I have personal experience with. I've heard good things about the Mossberg, but my bad experiences with other Mossberg products keeps me away.

The 11-87 isn't a bad gun, I just like the inertia action of the Stoeger and Benelli better. I had a Stoeger for a while until I ran across a great deal on a Benelli (which the Stoeger is a close copy). I was also able to sell the Stoeger for more than I paid, which basically offset the price of the Benelli. Had I not found the Benelli at a good price I'd likely still have the Stoeger and be happy with it.

The Stoeger isn't made by Benelli. Beretta owns Benelli, Stoeger and Franchi. They are all part of the same company. The Stoeger uses the same principles to operate the gun. They are very similar in function, but are very different in other ways.
 
jmr40 said:
I voted Stoeger because that and the 11-87 are the ones I have personal experience with. I've heard good things about the Mossberg, but my bad experiences with other Mossberg products keeps me away.

The 11-87 isn't a bad gun, I just like the inertia action of the Stoeger and Benelli better. I had a Stoeger for a while until I ran across a great deal on a Benelli (which the Stoeger is a close copy). I was also able to sell the Stoeger for more than I paid, which basically offset the price of the Benelli. Had I not found the Benelli at a good price I'd likely still have the Stoeger and be happy with it.

The Stoeger isn't made by Benelli. Beretta owns Benelli, Stoeger and Franchi. They are all part of the same company. The Stoeger uses the same principles to operate the gun. They are very similar in function, but are very different in other ways.
Click to expand...
Did you have the Stoeger 2000 or 3500? I can't seem to find much input on the 3500.
 
Mossberg 930 all the way. If you feel you need a 3.5" gun, the Baikal that PJR mentioned is the best out there for the money.
 
Closes by itself.All of my Mossberg shotguns have done extrememly well and shot as good as many costing more.
 
tough to beat the Mossberg 930. Excellent gun for the money. Can be a little heavy in the field though...
 
I voted 11-87 but you should get an 1100. Nothing you really can't do with a 2 3/4" shell that you can with a 3"
 
Another option is the Akdal MKA 1919. I like mine quite a bit. Although its $700 plus $50 for shipping and FFL fees.
 
For your stated uses you would be very well served by a used 1100 in excellent condition, but any of them will work. I wouldn't want a magnum inertia action for clay targets at all. I do not prefer the ergonomics on the Mossbergs, but they do seem to work okay.
 
Berreta 3901

Sanrlingiron is correct. Sorry for what you want to do with the gun Stoeger isnt answer. A current model Remington 11-87 has crappy GC and reliability issues.
930 would be my second pick. Third a used Browning Gold or Silver.
 
Last edited:
I voted 930. I have an SPX and it will function like nobodys business and cycles as fast as I can pull the trigger. Runs like a clock, points good, swings fast and is lightweight in my opinion. But what do I know? YMMV
 
well I voted for the weatherby havent really put enough rounds through mine to test durability but so far I like it, nice and light weight shotgun, probably cant go wrong with the mossberg or a berretta either and would probably be more apt to find a rifled barrel for the mossberg and beretta also.
 
The Remington 1100 is still at the top of the list and still one of the most popular shotguns for multiple gun matches because they work. 1100's are reliable and soft shooting, they work well with a wide range of loads and have a ton of aftermarket support. You can pick from tactical to some set up with really nice wood. A 28 inch vent rib with Rem Chokes would do all you want in the OP and can always add a slug barrel later.
 
1100 Low Price

Dont think so. Its about the same price as the MAxus and other B guns. Reliable? Try a current production model. I dont think they sell new for $700.
3901 is far superior to 1100
 
I voted for the Mossberg 930, not the 935....

The 930 is a much more versitile gun, IMO, there isn't any game that can't be taken with modern non-tox 3", or even 2-3/4" loads, there's no need to beat yourself up shooting 3-1/2" shells...

The Mossberg 935 will cycle 1-1/8 oz 2-3/4" shell if you need it to, but the 930 will cycle all the way down to my 3/4 oz reloads without a hiccup..
 
Better to buy a used Beretta or Benelli that you would want instead f a cheap gun that you won't like and as a cheap gun, will give you issues
Click to expand...

My Mossberg 930 has given me no issues. It has functioned as well or better than some of my more expensive shotguns.
 
Virginian said:
For your stated uses you would be very well served by a used 1100 in excellent condition, but any of them will work. I wouldn't want a magnum inertia action for clay targets at all. I do not prefer the ergonomics on the Mossbergs, but they do seem to work okay.
Click to expand...
Yep. Paid $400 for mine used. Love it.
 
I'm not qualified to vote on this poll. The only semi auto shotgun I've ever fired is the old Rem. 1947 Mod. 11. That thing was really heavy and kicked like a mule. I didn't find it that enjoyable except for the idea of getting to shoot something I'd never seen before that day.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

K
  • Locked
Tactical Semi-auto HELP?
Replies
13
Views
1K
Dean1818
D
B
  • Locked
Need opinions on the Benelli M3
Replies
11
Views
1K
1KPerDay
1KPerDay
L
  • Locked
Taking suggestions
Replies
7
Views
316
RugerMcMarlin
R
S
  • Locked
New 11-87 VS New M2000
Replies
0
Views
389
Snarlingiron
S
twofewscrews
  • Locked
  • Poll
Are cheap semi auto shotguns worth the cash?
Replies
8
Views
2K
cdb1
cdb1
Back
Top