Boy defends mom, good use of weapon

Status
Not open for further replies.

Calhoun

Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2004
Messages
506
Mods: If this is not in the right forum, please move to correct place. Thx.

Saw this story on the website of the Charlotte Observer, Charlotte NC. www.charlotte.com

I say good shoot, just too bad that the kid had to do it.

Man attacks wife; son shoots him, police say

KYTJA WEIR

Staff Writer


As a Mecklenburg County man attacked his wife by slamming her onto the hood of a car and choking her Monday night, police said, their 14-year-old son interrupted and told his father: "Leave my mother alone."

A moment later, police said, the boy shot his father in the neck.

On Tuesday, the father lay hospitalized in critical condition with a bullet lodged in his spine.

No one has been charged in the case. Charlotte-Mecklenburg police say they have multiple divisions investigating the events that took place at the eastern Mecklenburg County home.

Some answers won't be known, they say, as long as the man remains in critical condition, unable to tell them what happened.

At this time, the Observer is not identifying any of the family members because no criminal charges have been filed.

Domestic violence advocates say it's not unusual for children to be caught in the violence between their parents.

"A lot of people write off kids as not hearing, as not listening," said Sgt. Vicky Suarez, who heads Charlotte-Mecklenburg police's domestic violence unit. "A lot of times, people don't realize how much kids are involved."

According to Charlotte-Mecklenburg police, children are present in at least 32 percent of all their domestic violence cases.

Children as young as 4 try to stop the fights, Suarez said. Sometimes they plead, sometimes they try to literally step in between their fighting parents. She said it's unusual, though, for children to fight back with a gun.

A calm evening turns deadly

Monday evening began quietly at the three-bedroom home on Tiger Lily Lane near Harrisburg Road, according to three police reports. The reports are based on interviews with the wife, the teen and his two cousins.Here's what happened next, according to the reports:

The wife asked her son and two of his cousins to take out the garbage. The children took out the trash and returned upstairs. The husband came home, and headed upstairs, too. The wife began cooking dinner.

Around 7:20 p.m., someone punched either the teen or one of his cousins in the chest, then picked him up by his shirt and threw him on a bed.

The wife heard yelling from upstairs.

About five minutes later, the husband came downstairs, opened the refrigerator for a drink and confronted his wife.

"I heard you on the phone," he said. "How did she know I didn't have a job? She is your friend not mine."

The police reports continue:

He yelled into his wife's face, then grabbed her by the throat and began choking her.

He pushed her head into the sink, continuing to yell at her. She was blacking out, moving in and out of consciousness.

He ripped the phone out of the wall.

"If you're not going to leave me, you will leave me after I finished what I'm going to do you tonight," he said.

The reports then say:

He grabbed her, wrangled her to the garage and slammed her onto the hood of the car parked in the garage.

The wife blacked out for a few seconds, then heard her son demand that his father leave her alone.

She heard a bang. A second later, her husband fell to the garage floor.

At 7:46 p.m., authorities received a 911 call. The husband was rushed to Carolinas Medical Center.

By late Monday night, the home was deserted. A pickup was parked in the driveway in front of a basketball net on the dark street of the quiet subdivision.

On Tuesday, investigators said it remained unclear where the boy got the handgun.

The father faces a misdemeanor charge of assault and battery after an incident in November, court records show. His wife was not listed as the complainant. The case is pending.

Helping kids in violent homes

Charlotte-Mecklenburg police are trying to reach out to children who live in homes filled with domestic violence as a way to stop the problem.

Almost a year ago, police and other agencies began Operation Youth Awareness. Detectives have visited three middle schools and worked with seventh- and eighth-graders in five sessions, discussing safety, their rights and how to get help.

The teen involved in Monday's shooting is a ninth- grader in the Charlotte-Mecklenburg school district, according to CMS officials. It's unclear whether he went through Operation Youth Awareness last year as an eighth-grader.

Eventually, Suarez said, she hopes the department can visit all the county's middle schools. For now, though, she said they are limited because they have only five detectives.

She said the program has been powerful and has won an award from Police Chief Darrel Stephens.

The students' issues surprised even longtime detectives.

"We got some really heavy questions from these kids," Suarez said.

The Numbers

• Nearly three of every four women who are chronically mistreated by their partners have children.• An estimated 3 million or more children are exposed to acts of domestic violence nationwide each year.

• In one in five domestic violence homicides and attempted homicides, a child of the battered woman is also killed in the process.

SOURCE: N.C. Coalition of Against Domestic Violence

Tips for Kids

• If you witness violence between your parents, do not intervene.

• Find a safe place and call 911.

SOURCE: Charlotte-Mecklenburg police Sgt. Vicky Suarez
 
• In one in five domestic violence homicides and attempted homicides, a child of the battered woman is also killed in the process.

Hopefully not sidetracking here. Domestic violence is a terrible thing, and as this event shows, the results can scar everybody involved. But ignoring the fact that women occasionally attempt domestic homicides seems unnecessary.
 
Sounds like the kid did what he had to do to save his mother. I hope that he is mature enough psychologically that it doesn't mess up his mind.
The boy that fired the shot is a victim as well.
 
It still blows my mind how men (or women) can harm the ones that they love. The point that this article hits home is that no argument should have to resorty to violence, let alone a 14 year old being the one to stop it.

One final thing to note...it is another situation of an improperly secured gun resulting in someone being shot (although this time it appears to be for the better).
-1 point for the father attacking the mom.
-1 point for the father not keeping his firearms properly secured with kids in the house.
 
It does not say that the handgun was not properley secured, nor does it say that it was the father's. However, if this kid was not able to access the weapon the headline would probably have read something like "Woman Killed in Domestic Dispute". Honestly, I think it sounds better the way it is.

Cal
 
I'm so very sorry for this kid. Hopefully he can realize that what he did wasn't so much attacking his father, but saving his mother's life.
 
I think he should have used a bigger gun. I think he knows that he was saving his mother. 14 years old is old enough to know what is going on.

I love how the events have the abuser in the hospital, the abused are safe and it says not to intervene...just call 911 and the police may arrive in time to take a report of the 'accident'.
 
Sad story. I feel sorry for the kid who had to step in and attempt the unthinkable.

The story demonstrates the problem with this city. The police are far too interested in "reaching out and . . ." and not enforcing the law. I think a few good public slamming of domestic violence instigators will go a long way toward cutting down on the incidents. We're in a mode now where we're killing a kid about once a month. No prosecutions mind you, just killings.

Charlotte: where we don't have the money to enforce the law but we do have the money for all kind of blissninny project reaching out to the community. :barf:
 
The kid will probably be traumatized for a long time, which is very unfortunate.

The husband, on the other hand, deserves to die IMO. There is no excuse for beating women if you're a guy. Women can get into catfights, that's not such a big deal. Guys can smack guys around, not a big deal. Problem is, most men are more physically powerful than most women (yeah, there are exceptions), and it's just WRONG to beat up on a family member.

Maybe I'm just a little nutty, though...I still open doors for women.
 
I say good for the kid. I am sorry he had to be the one to shoot the father. I don't agree with just going to a safe place and calling 911. The mother could have died.
 
Way to go Kid!! It sounds to me like he did the right thing. I wonder if pops will ever walk again? He is probably paralyzed and will live off of Social Security the rest of his life.
 
As a victim of beatings and a witness to domestic violence as a child, I can say that not only did the kid do the right thing, but he should have shot the guy again for good measure.
 
Taking the story at face value, the teen did good.

I've heard of more than one instance where a wife-beater is pounding on his wife in public, an LEO intervenes, and they both turn on him. I hope the kid's mother is supportive of his actions, and doesn't lay a guilt trip on him for what he did.

It's hard for me to relate to stuff like this . . . over the years my folks had some mighty intense arguments, but my father never hit my mother. And my mother never threw stuff at him. When it came to disputes within one's own family, there were just some lines you didn't cross.

Ever.
 
Almost the same thing happend to a friend of mine in high school 40 years ago. His mother's boy friend had a history of violence. Came to the door to start up another fight and he shot him in the leg with a .22 rifle. Clearly not trying to do much harm, but the bullet hit an artery and the guy blead out in a matter of minuets. My friend was charged with 2nd degree murder, but was aquitted.
 
As most have commented, this young man was forced into an unfortunate incident. But that is exactly what a defensive shootings is. It's the reaction of a split second decision to take a life to preserve another.

No doubt he had feelings for both his parents but he evidently knew the violence his father was capable of. Mom probably should have sought help long before, for her sake as well as the young man's. I realize this is much easier said than done!

As a side note, I doubt he was aiming for his neck.
 
Am I the only person(and I know I'm not), who thinks that this whole thing could have been prevented if the parents would have divorced/separated? I highly doubt this was the first sign of trouble, and most likely not the first physical controntation. Really this is the real problem here. Women need to learn not to put up with this, and say,"Oh, he's changed." Now the kid will probably feel guilty for having to shoot his father. Anyway, It's sad to hear that the son was the only person in the house with some common sense.

• If you witness violence between your parents, do not intervene.
Humm... IMO The only thing worse than shooting your dad, is letting him kill your mom, and then you.

P.S. - Didn't think about that, FireSafty3, but he probably was aiming for the head.
 
I support the kid 100%, he did the right thing. Fortunately the father didn't die, that would have been an awful tough burden for the boy to bear.

The son is much more a man than his father will ever be.

jojo
 
Fortunately the father didn't die, that would have been an awful tough burden for the boy to bear.

I think either way there will be guilt, especially with the bullet lodged in his spine. It doesn't say if there is paralysis or not, but I think if the father sees his son there could be a great deal of guilt there.
 
I support the kid 100%, he did the right thing. Fortunately the father didn't die, that would have been an awful tough burden for the boy to bear.
Maybe?
Maybe NOT!

A lot depends on the family and the relationship the boy had with his father. There are some children who actually, really do hate one or both of their parents. In this case where a father is abusive to a mother it might very well be that there is no love between the son and father.

Killing someone you hate in the defense of someone you love IMO wouldn't be traumatic at all in fact it might very well be cathartic. It all depends on the attitude of the shooter. IF the attitude is "I killed an evil man hurting my mother" then that is a feeling that can be dealt with. IF the attitude is "I killed my father" then that would be a tougher thing to deal with. The fact that the boy is just 14 makes it even easier as most 14 year olds are more resilient than adults give them credit for.

The ole Texas saying that "sum folk just need killin'" is more than just a saying. Killing someone who needs to be killed is not as traumatic a thing as the bleeding hearts would like us to believe. As John Ross said in his novel "the 1st one's tough - all the rest are free".
 
Am I the only person(and I know I'm not), who thinks that this whole thing could have been prevented if the parents would have divorced/separated? I highly doubt this was the first sign of trouble, and most likely not the first physical controntation.

I agree, but sometimes people think the relationship can be salvaged or they are willing to put up with a lot for whatever reason. Besides, I know several women that left their abusers and were still attacked. There are some very determined nut cases out there.
 
There are some very determined nut cases out there.

And we know the best way to permanently halt their attacks;

_surecure.jpg

Again, Oleg has the answer! ;)

Too bad the walking (now not walking :evil: ) colostomy bag still is drawing precious oxygen that could be better used by real human beings....
 
Next time, double tap. Nobody, but NOBODY messes with mom and lives. I can't imagine what this did to the kids mind, but he obviously has his head in the game, so I think he will be alright in the long run. Good shootin'.
Fortunately the father didn't die, that would have been an awful tough burden for the boy to bear.
I can't claim to speak from experience, and I might feel differently were I to have to do something like this. I can, however, speak as the son of an abuser and say that I would, hypothetically speaking, feel better attending a funeral and being done with it than dealing with whatever s-storm is going to come of this. My parents divorced when I was 14. Just my $.02, and I suppose these sort of events affect each person differently. By that age, I was angry enough that I would have emptied the pistol and gone back inside for dinner.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top