CCW story headlined on CNN....UTAH!

Status
Not open for further replies.

98C5

Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2007
Messages
755
Location
SW Va
Utah students hide guns, head to class
Story Highlights
Utah is only state where students, professors can carry guns at all public colleges

One University of Utah student carries a firearm so he won't become a 'victim'

Another student says she feels less safe, knowing classmates might have guns

News from your campus? Send us an I-Report

By Joshua Molina
Special to CNN

CNNU campus correspondent Joshua Molina is a senior at Brigham Young University. CNNU is a feature that provides student perspectives on news and trends from colleges across the United States. The views expressed in this article are not necessarily those of CNN, its affiliates or the schools where the campus correspondents are based.

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah (CNN) -- The senior at the University of Utah gets dressed and then decides which gun is easiest to conceal under his clothes.

If he's wearing a T-shirt, he'll take a smaller, low-profile gun to class. If he's wearing a coat, he may carry a different weapon, he said.

He started carrying a gun to class after the massacre at Virginia Tech, but the student says he's not part of the problem of campus shootings and could instead be part of a solution.

Nick, who asked not to be fully identified so his fellow students wouldn't know he carried a gun, he says he has had a concealed weapons permit for more than three years. But it was Seung-Hui Cho's murderous campus rampage that made him take a gun to class.

"Last year, after Virginia Tech, I thought 'I'm not going to be a victim,' " Nick said.

"My first thought was 'how tragic.' But then I couldn't help but think it could've been different if they'd allowed the students the right to protect themselves."

Days after another campus shooting -- in which five students and the gunman died at Northern Illinois University -- students at colleges in Utah, the only state to allow weapons at all public universities, are attending classes. See which states have laws about hidden weapons on campus »

Nick says his gun doesn't make him feel immune from attack. "But I feel that I will be able to protect myself, and I'm confident in my training and my ability," he said.

His confidence is not shared by fellow student Griselda Espinoza, who recently transferred to the university. Some 28,000 students attend the school, as of the latest enrollment figures.

"I feel less safe knowing that a stranger sitting beside me in class may have a gun in his or her backpack," she said.

"The only people that should carry guns are trained officials."

The University of Utah had no comment and referred inquiries to the state Board of Regents. Amanda Covington, Utah State Board of Regents spokeswoman, also would not comment on the current gun laws on school campuses.

However, she said the regents are opposing a legislative proposal to allow people with concealed weapons permits to have the weapons visible in public.

"We are worried that it may affect their [students' and teachers'] willingness or desire to go to or teach a class on campus," she said.

The University of Utah, based in Salt Lake City, had prohibited firearms on its campus until that ban was struck down by the state's Supreme Court in late 2006. The institution, backed by all other universities in the state, is still fighting through federal courts to reinstate the ban.

But state legislators could be moving in the opposite direction, considering a bill to modify current law to allow people in Utah -- including students -- to carry loaded weapons openly.

Utah State Representative Curtis Oda said the bill, which he is sponsoring, is merely to clarify that people with weapons permits may carry a gun openly or -- with a concealed permit -- they may hide it for the sake of surprise.

He stressed that people with permits have gone through rigorous checks.

"When you see someone with a gun, you are looking at some of the most law-abiding people in the state," he said.

The issue goes beyond campus. Last year, a few miles from the University of Utah, a man walked into Trolley Square, a Salt Lake City shopping mall, and opened fire. Police were there in only three minutes, but the shooter had already killed five people and wounded four others.

"And not just shootings, but [serial killer] Ted Bundy did some of his crimes at the University of Utah campus," said David Seelly, a recent University of Utah graduate who says he carried a concealed gun on campus.

"If one of those ladies was a concealed-weapon holder, she could've stopped him before he did as much as he did."

To get a permit to carry a concealed weapon, people in Utah must, among other things:


Be 21 years old

Have no criminal record of violent, immoral or substance-related crime

Be mentally competent.
Student Kevin Rechtenbach of the University of Utah said he was open to carrying a gun, but not certain that would solve problems.

"If acts of terrorism continue on campus, then I will have no choice but to carry a concealed weapon," he said.

"But you see, that is where the problem lies: Everybody will end up carrying concealed weapons, and everyday problems will be solved with guns rather than words or even fists."

The only places on campus that have restrictions are the dormitories. Students can request a roommate who doesn't carry a gun.

Private colleges in Utah, like the Mormon Church-owned Brigham Young University in Provo, do have more power to ban weapons on campus, but that, too, causes disagreement among students.

"I own some guns, and I wish I was allowed to have them at school," said Collin Barker, a BYU student. "I would just keep [them] in my car for target shooting."

Casey Matheny, from Plano, Texas, now studying at BYU, appeared indifferent to the debate over students carrying guns.

"I don't mind if they have one, I just don't want to know about it," he said.

Rob Morrison, a BYU student from Ontario, Canada, doesn't think that having guns on campus would necessarily stop a potential killer.

"The people that do it want to commit suicide anyway," Morrison said. "But it would give students a chance to defend themselves, and at Virginia Tech, it could have ended sooner than it did."


Source: http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/02/20/cnnu.guns/index.html
 
His confidence is not shared by fellow student Griselda Espinoza, who recently transferred to the university. Some 28,000 students attend the school, as of the latest enrollment figures.

"I feel less safe knowing that a stranger sitting beside me in class may have a gun in his or her backpack," she said.

"The only people that should carry guns are trained officials."
Its depressing that college students aren't even interested in looking for any evidence to confirm or refute their opinions
 
That is just another "media-brainwashed" individual that think all guns are evil and may jump out of the holster by themselves and shoot you.
 
"I feel less safe knowing that a stranger sitting beside me in class may have a gun in his or her backpack," she said.

NewsFlash: There could be some stranger sitting beside you with a gun anyway!!

Hopefully if it is a GG though, they have it on their person and not in a backpack...
 
"I feel less safe knowing that a stranger sitting beside me in class may have a gun in his or her backpack," she said.

I wonder whether she'd feel safer knowing she and everyone else lives solely at the mercy of killers.

Actually, she probably would: some people trust killers more than law-abiding American citizens.

Never mind.
 
Okay, campers. I'm still here. And I can type 120wpm...

Are y'all gonna bitch? Or are y'all going to take advantage of some of this publicity? The piece, which didn't really seem all that negative, was on CNN, fahcrissake!

Call administrators and faculty, while their minds are at least semi-open, and ask if you are allowed to carry on campus. If not, ask why not. And keep after them until they can give you a logical answer. "That's not logical" is a good response. These guys pride themselves on being reasonable and logical educators, at least in theory. USE THAT.

Should I just ****?
 
Bogie, nice idea.

"I own some guns, and I wish I was allowed to have them at school," said Collin Barker, a BYU student. "I would just keep [them] in my car for target shooting."

Anyone think that's a bit weird? I guess/hope he means he would prefer to leave guns in his car before/after target shooting.

Wait...BYU is in Utah...unless they have some special exception there, he is allowed to have guns in his car.

What the heck? Did some journalist really mess up a quote that badly, or is that guy off mentally?
 
Last edited:
I think the CNN map is incorrect. AFAIK, the MI bills introduced in 2007 to allow CC for select groups or all CPL holders in school (and other places) are dead. I think the guy (Acciavatti) who sponsored the bill to eliminate pistol free zones for CPL holders got hammered.
 
"I feel less safe knowing that a stranger sitting beside me in class may have a gun in his or her backpack," she said.

"The only people that should carry guns are trained officials."


It seems to me that the Gestapo were “trained officials” at one time. Would we trust them implicitly as this woman seems to want to do simply because they are "officials"?

Making Griselda “feel safe” is not a requirement of the Constitution. Allowing her and all of us the ability to “be safe” by having the right to protect ourselves with a firearm is. How she “feels” is irrelevant.
 
"I feel less safe knowing that a stranger sitting beside me in class may have a gun in his or her backpack," she said.

"The only people that should carry guns are trained officials."

This person is an irrational, logic-lacking, sheep... I am happy that they are still a minority here.

Wait...BYU is in Utah...unless they have some special exception there, he is allowed to have guns in his car.

The special exception is that they are a private university and can set whatever rules they want. However, they have no legal power to arrest or sue you for breaking the rule. They can just ask you to leave/expel you from the property.
 
Havegunjoe
Making Griselda “feel safe” is not a requirement of the Constitution. Allowing her and all of us the ability to “be safe” by having the right to protect ourselves with a firearm is. How she “feels” is irrelevant.
True.
+a million
 
"I feel less safe knowing that a stranger sitting beside me in class may have a gun in his or her backpack," she said.

"The only people that should carry guns are trained officials."


It seems to me that the Gestapo were “trained officials” at one time. Would we trust them implicitly as this woman seems to want to do simply because they are "officials"?

Making Griselda “feel safe” is not a requirement of the Constitution. Allowing her and all of us the ability to “be safe” by having the right to protect ourselves with a firearm is. How she “feels” is irrelevant.

Thats some top notch logic there Joe.
 
bogie said:
Don't worry if the network's maps are correct or incorrect.

Worry about if you can get through to the administrations and faculty at the universities. That can CHANGE things.
I have no problem with people attempting that. I personally would rather just take a new person shooting, though. I fire out the occassional email, but I truly believe my elected representatives do not care what I have to say, with the possible exception of my US Congressman. College administrations, forget about it. I am not a college student anymore, nor do I have kids in school. If college students and/or parents want this, they need to demand it (VOTE ACCORDINGLY). Based on what I see, MI just is not ready to eliminate the pistol free zones. Most people I know in MI just do not care, or do not care enough to do anything about it. This includes CPL holders. I think much more work needs to be done at the grass roots level, taking new people shooting and beginning slow, possibly long-term dialogues on the role of firearms in personal protection with these people.

ETA
In summary, I do not believe the current crowd demanding CC be allowed in schools is large enough to make a difference in my state, so I will concentrate my efforts on the slow process of growing the size of that crowd one person at a time.
 
Last edited:
The thing is, the bad guys are less likely to target that school now that he knows he may have some armed resistance. How can anyone feel less safe?
 
Bogie: I don't have any idea who I would send a note to at the local University. Or are you suggesting we take aim at legislators with our keyboards, instead?
 
Last edited:
Check out the main web sites... You may not be able to locate a president's e-mail (or maybe that is available to students at some schools), but you can locate SOME folks...

For instance, here's departmental contacts for Eastern Kentucky...

http://www.eku.edu/futurestudents/contacts.php

http://www.president.eku.edu/administration/

No e-mails, but hey... Students should be able to figure that part out. And if you live near Richmond, give someone a call - "I'm planning on taking a class there next year, and I'm wondering if it's going to be safe? I've got a Kentucky concealed carry permit - is that good on campus?"

Aha! There _is_ a directory. If you're smart enough to be active, you're smart enough to find it. FYI, that school's president _is_ listed with e-mail.

Guys, it's not handed to you. But we've got an opportunity to help keep a VA Tech/NIU type situation from happening again. We need to communicate with the decision makers. And we need to do it in force.

We have 62,000+ members here. And I have a funny feeling that this crap I've been typing resonates with maybe six or so... Not sure why I'm bothering.

Go play video games or something. That's productive. I suppose.
 
"The only people that should carry guns are trained officials."

By that she is saying she favors CCW.

To get a CCW permit, one must partake in some form of prerequisite "training"...whereupon one becomes "official" because an "official" permit to carry concealed is issued.

Thus, "trained official".
 
I taught at two different Utah colleges when I lived there and routinely carried at both. The administrators of most Utah colleges have collective cows at the very idea. I guess maybe all Utah colleges since the article says all others are backing the U of U lawsuit (which they will lose since thew state leg specifically passed the current law in response to the U of U pres declaring it against policy to go armed on campus and promised to fire any employee caught packing).

Utah is the most gun friendly state I have experienced. The wife wants to move back there and I wouldn't mind as long as I can find a decent job.
 
"But you see, that is where the problem lies: Everybody will end up carrying concealed weapons, and everyday problems will be solved with guns rather than words or even fists."

What in the world is this jackass talking about? Does he think that every day problems ARE solved with fists? Does he think it's a good idea to solve "every day problems" with "fists"? Of course talking problems out is a good idea, but I would like to hear him try to explain how "using words or fists" was going to do jack squat to stop Cho.

Maybe HE should take a CCW class and realize that a gun is a last resort. No one that has gone through the process legally wants to use it. A gun is used to protect yourself from another gun. If some criminal wants to "resolve his everyday problems" with me using a gun, then dam right I am going to use mine to defend myself. It is his fault for starting it, don't blame me for ending it.
 
The ignorance and willingness of those who obviously have no experience with guns or armed self defense, to espouse such resolute opinions on this subject, simply astounds me.

Do you also try to tell heart surgeons and pro athletes how to do their jobs? Do you routinely try to change the thinking or methods of others who's hobby or profession requires a great deal of specialized knowledge and/or skill?

Unless you've been exposed to the philosophy and pragmatic issues involved in armed self defense, such as the law and exactly when deadly force is allowed to be used in self defense, or the requirements for getting a CCW, please stop making yourselves look like a bunch of irrational and uneducated simpletons.

The girl in the article that talks about being uncomfortable around someone who is armed is a naive, sheltered human being. Her inability to differentiate between criminal violence and the ability to protect oneself is frightening.

Perhaps even more frightening, is her complete denial of the fact that no matter what laws are on the books, no matter how stringently the university opposes this issue, if someone has criminal intent, they WILL bring a gun to class, and they WILL shoot her with it. She has the choice to either be a victim, or take steps to enable herself to avoid being helpless in the face of a violent attack.

Laws and rules only apply to those who choose to follow them. This is why 'gun free zones' are such a joke.

Anyone talking about how those carrying guns will lose control over petty arguments screams projection. You are projecting your own instability on those who are part of the most law abiding segment of the population. Just because you feel as though you can't be trusted with a gun, doesn't mean others who have passed background checks and jumped through other hoops can't.

If someone is licensed to carry off campus, it is ludicrous to limit that ability on campus.

If anything, the university should be encouraging those with CCW's to come to their campus. Who in their right mind WOULDN'T want the most law abiding segment of the population on their campus? Who in their right mind WOULDN'T want people around them who have passed background checks and are assured to be free of any violent history or criminal record?

Who, I ask? Only those who are willfully ignorant of the facts surrounding armed self defense, and the people who have the depth of character to not have to rely on someone else who is minutes away...when seconds count.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top