Change of Interest/M1/M1 Carbine

Status
Not open for further replies.

eclancy

Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2002
Messages
1,114
Location
N. Catasauqua, Pa
Gentlemen,
Since CMP is almost out of M1 Garands, do you think that the interest will shift from the M1 Garand to the M1 Carbine? Do many of you think of buying just one Carbine or go for a group of them, as was done with the M1 Garand? I know the money problem will enter into this, but I would like to hear what you guys think.
Thanks again
Clancy
 
Re: Change of interest

Eclancy--There are a zillion Garand owners out there already. Many of them use and like their Garands for competition, as well as informal shooting. They aren't about to change their affiliation. Many of them just love to hear that "Pling!" as the clip is ejected.

CMP has 30,000 M1Carbines currently. That's a drop in the bucket compared to the number of Garand owners. (It is to be hoped that more will turn up, but don't bet on it, especially if Hillary gets elected president.)

Go to CMP's website and check out what they have to say about carbine sales. For the present, they are limiting sales to one (count 'em, 1) carbine per maker per year, and they are currently only selling the Inlands--the commonest maker by far.

Surely the collectors will want one of each maker as those become available, but at 500 bucks a pop, the casual shooters won't be buying a bunch of carbines, even if/when they can do so.

Another thought--The carbine won't replace the Garand in military rifle competition, either. At 100yd the carbine will be spot-on--with xlnt ammo, quite a bit of babying, and a careful shooter. But at further distances, well, the carbine just isn't a .30-'06. It runs out of steam pretty quickly.

Not knocking the carbine--it is what it is: An easier-to-aim-than-a-pistol, handy, short-range weapon designed for non-combat troops. And some combat troops found it suited them, too. For street fighting and building clearing, it worked great, I understand. But it isn't a Garand.

So, I don't think anyone will be throwing their Garand in the garbage and replacing it with a carbine, anytime soon. Just my opinion.
 
Although I have a sizable collection of WWII rifles, I only bought one Garand and one 1903. I'll likely buy only one carbine.

U.S. surplus rifles are just too expensive. My '03 was over $400 and I got lucky with a decent looker and shooter. My SA Garand was a $500 Service Grade and it needed more money invested into it to look and shoot decently. The Carbines are $500 and more for the more collectible manufactures (although, I feel that pricing is inline with the other CMP guns).

Too expensive for me to have a big collection of 'em.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top