Manco,
Making a head shot at 25yards with a little tiny pistol is no easy task when the subject is moving and looking left to right.
Well, it looked like he held still enough at times to make an easy enough target. I'm not talking about typical defensive handgun shooting but a very carefully aimed shot taken only when the conditions are just right (and maybe 15 yards would be more reasonable as long as there is some concealment).
There is way too much risk to the hostage than a shot taken at 3-5yards as it happened.
I could swear that the first shot was deliberately missed so as not to endanger the hostage.
Also, they knew the guy had a pair of scissors which made the "rambo charge" more reasonable.
Sure, if the perp had a gun or at least a big knife or sword, then it would have been a better justification for taking a head shot from concealment. As it was, the "Rambo charge" was a better tactic, at least in this case.
That guy was aleast a foot taller and offered a large target.
I know, that's why it's so tempting to call for a head shot (if the perp were truly more dangerous than he apparently was in this case), even with a handgun. With a rifle, it should be no problem. There seems to be a lot of similar hostage situations in that part of the world, so you'd think they'd have a few sharpshooters on the job by now.
"I don't recall having ever missed a head-sized target with a pistol (and with a rifle, it would be an easy shot)."
But did you ever have to do it when someone's life was at stake?
Would that somehow make me miss so badly that I'd hit the hostage, who in this case is nowhere near that guy's head?
I can make that shot all day long on paper (slow-fire only, of course), and sometimes that target is swinging from side-to-side, too. What's the difference in real life, aside from the dire circumstances required in order to take such a chance with somebody's life? If I can hit a paper head consistently, then I should be able to hit a real one just as well (as long as he holds still for a second, like when he's chugging water). Now, if his head were right next to hers or I had to take a quick shot, then I would say forget about it due to extremely high risk (unless there were absolutely no alternatives).