Comparing Four Different 44 Revolvers

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tallball

Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2014
Messages
7,814
This is from a few weeks ago:


I like 44 specials. I was going to the range today to compare a few 32acp's that I have acquired in the past year or so. I figured that while I was at it I might as well compare some 44 specials, too. I brought all of the ones I have right now: A Rossi 720 3", a Taurus ultra-light snub (2", I believe), a Charter Arms Bulldog snub with shrouded hammer (also 2", I think), and my old-fashioned JP Sauer and Sohn single-action (6" or so). All of them were fun to shoot.

I shot about 25 rounds through each of them. It was all Magtech Cowboy Action Loads. The recoil was fairly gentle with all four revolvers. There were zero malfunctions. Some shots were standing, some kneeling, some rapid fire, some slow. I usually shot in groups of five and tried to adjust POA in between groups. Usually the very first round or two was way off as I adjusted my extra-large hands and middle-aged eyes to the pistol. Let's please pretend that I shot these from farther away than seven yards. As you can see, I am a poor shot.

The Rossi's grips are a little small for me, but I managed. The sights are good. The trigger is great. It is very easy to shoot double action. This is only the second time I have shot it, and I was adjusting the sights as I went along. By the end the results were improving. This little revolver is a lot of fun to shoot! It took me months to track one down at a decent price, but it was worth the wait.

The Taurus has excellent grips - the rubbery feel and the shape are very good for my hand. It is very light-weight, but that didn't seem to affect the felt recoil, which was inconsequential. The sights are tiny. It feels good to shoot. I like the way it points and balances. The trigger is heavier than I prefer, and the sights are very small, but I had fun shooting it. With more practice I could adjust my POA and be fairly accurate... accurate for me, anyway.

The Charter Arms is okay. I don't like the feel of it in my hand as much as the other three. There is something about the action that feels kind of cheap to me. The recoil wasn't much, but I felt it more than the other three. I like the hammer shroud. The single-action trigger is average and the double-action a bit heavier than average, but they are both acceptable. I don't love it, but I have carried it a few times. The shrouded hammer keeps it from getting tangled up with a shirt or a pocket.

The Sauer and Sohn has the lightest single-action trigger I have ever felt. I had forgotten how light it is... as you can see from the first shot. The sights aren't great, but I adjusted after a while. It is easy to shoot. It's really a 44 magnum revolver, so it's a pussycat when loaded with 44 special. I wanted a 44 magnum for less than $300, and this seemed like a pretty good deal for $299. My Ruger Blackhawk fits my hand a little better, but the JP Sauer is a quality weapon that I enjoy shooting.

I enjoyed shooting my little 44 collection. It is a fun and underrated caliber, IMHO. I enjoy target shooting and plinking with it, and definitely don't feel under-gunned when I am holding one. And I think I have almost convinced my FiL to start hand-loading it (fingers crossed)!
 
Last edited:
I know that some people have had trouble with Taurus revolvers. I have eleven good ones and one that needs to go back to the factory for the second time. This little 44 is one of the good ones. The size, shape, and angle of the grip are excellent. It is a pleasure to shoot.


Taurus%20target_zps7uqg22yd.gif
 
Here is the Charter Arms Bulldog. I don't love it, but it works fine. It took me a while to adjust my aim. After I aimed high enough I got a few near the bullseye towards the end. It doesn't have a great trigger, but I definitely like the hammer shroud.


Charter%20target_zpsuu1xie0t.jpg
 
I am guessing that someone shot a LOT of rounds through this old German SAA piece back in the day. It still locks up very tight. Since I shoot 95% 44 special Cowboy Action Loads through it, it should hold up to quite a bit more shooting. I love the way a single-action revolver fits my hand. Be careful, it has a hair trigger!


Saeur%20target_zpsatayngsh.jpg
 
I had a Taurus 431, liked it, but wanted to trade for something else. Now my fixed sighted Rossi 720. It isn't going anywhere. My main ccw weapon
 
I have the same Taurus, the 445UL, and think it is pretty awesome. I would like slightly smaller wood grips or less sticky rubber grips though.
 
My favorite .44 is my 6.5" magna-ported S&W M29. It's just a fun take-it-to-the-range gun, but I pretty much only shoot .44 Specials in it now. VERY tame and accurate. Never had a Taurus .44 but used to have a Taurus .38 spl 2" revolver clone of the S&W M36, can't remember what that model of the Taurus was called. It was my airline checked luggage gun, didn't much care if they lost it in transit because it was really inexpensive when I bought it used in about 1990-ish. Taurus revolvers always seemed rock solid and reliable - as was my Taurus 2" .38 - wish I'd never sold it.
 
Here is the Charter Arms Bulldog. I don't love it, but it works fine. It took me a while to adjust my aim. After I aimed high enough I got a few near the bullseye towards the end. It doesn't have a great trigger, but I definitely like the hammer shroud.
]
Where you using light bullets? The gun was probably designed to shoot 240 grains, and lighter bullets would shoot low.

44 is a good round. I like my S&W 696. Be nice to see some compact 44s come out. When the 696 came out, it didn't do well, but concealed carry wasn't as big as it is now. It is a little big though.

A CA is on my list to get a compact 44.
 
I was shooting cowboy loads... I think 240 grain.

My perception of the Charter Arms may be a bit biased - the trigger (perhaps unfairly) always feels kind of like a cap gun to me. This is true of my CA 32 magnum also.

Yeah, the Rossi 720 is an awesome revolver! :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top