Confederate Bowie!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Panzerschwein

member
Joined
Nov 19, 2011
Messages
8,122
Location
Desert
Hello all!

A couple months ago, I posted on this section of our fine message board about how I was in the market for a Confederate D-guard Bowie knife. I've always wanted a Bowie of some kind, and being a history buff focusing on the 19th century, the traditional Civil War era Confederate Bowies always fascinated me. Usually, the Confederate soldier about to go to war would have his town blacksmith forge him a big 'ol Bowie knife. :)

So, I decided I wanted one to! :D

After searching around, I didn't find what I was looking for in any production knives. This lead me to create a thread asking for some help, and someone mentioned Plowshare Forge.

The man who runs the forge is blacksmith Dan Brock, and through a number of emails he and I figured out what knife he would make me. This man uses traditional methods to craft his blades, and that was very appealing to me. The opportunity to have my own, one of a kind custom knife was just awesome, and is just like what Johnny Reb would have gotten back in the 1860s!

Well, he began work on the knife around October 20, and today (December 7) the knife arrived in the mail! I took it out, and to say I was pleased is an understatement:

bowie1.jpg

It is just like I wanted! It's got a rugged, very businesslike appearance. A very traditional design for the type, double-edged with D-guard and plain wood scales. Feels fantastic in the hand, balances well, and came pretty sharp though I'll sharpen it to a razor's edge. The D-guard protects the hand against other blades and can be used as a striking implement as well. The knife also came with a handmade leather sheath that is extremely stout and well constructed.

Here it is in the hand:

bowie2.jpg

It's got a 14" blade, construction is of 5160 steel which I hear is very good for this type of knife. The handle fits my hand very nicely.

Here is the knife next to my Harpers Ferry percussion conversion horse pistol, a gun that a Southern trooper might have been armed with at the start of the Civil War:

bowie3.jpg

It sure makes a great companion to my pistol, and will look great next to my '51 Navy revolver once I get it back from forum member and gunsmith 45 Dragoon. :)

All in all, this knife is just flat out awesome. The fact that it is my knife is just so cool. Made in America by a real American blacksmith the old fashioned way, for a very modest sum of money. I cannot recommend this man's work enough. I plan to use this knife for light camp chores, such as cutting woods for fires and also for emergency personal defense in the field from either man or beast. I look forward to using this knife for many years to come, and passing it down to my children some day.

Thanks for reading guys!
 
I approve!!! Lol! Fantastic! The pic of you holding it really show just how big that thing is. Looks like Frodo found his Sting :)
 
Very cool.

It screams "Arkansas Toothpick" to me rather than Bowie though. When I think of a Bowie, I think of a clip point with both edges sharpened near the point.
 
Here's the thing: everyone here wants you to love your knife. Every. Damn. One. We're also very glad you like it so far.

This
I cannot recommend this man's work enough
is premature UNTIL YOU USE IT. You cannot actually "recommend" a tool you have never used with any credence or responsibility. It's ethical to say you love it so far, and get back to us once you know that it won't, for instance, break off at the handle, like an attractive kukuri a member owned did very recently.

Not trying to single you out, by any means. Other members have done the exact same thing...and we tell them the exact same thing.

John
 
I'll second John's advice.

It is best to wait to put a new knife through it's paces before staking your reputation on the appearance and feel of someone else's work. We LOVE our knives...until they fail us. ;)
 
Doubt it will fail, but yeah go cut some stuff. I recommend you cut a couple 4"x4" in two. That is a good work out and will shut up the disbelievers of that attractive knife. I like it very much and it is my kinda blade.
 
Thanks guys, I'll be going home for xmas and their will be plenty of opportunities to put this knife through its paces in the woods. I'll get back to you.
 
Excellent! And please, don't take this to mean any of us think it's going to fail. We want it to work well for you.
Also, I will say that the man appears to offer good stuff at very fair prices. I'm eager to hear your thoughts after you use it some.
 
I recommend you cut a couple 4"x4" in two.

That's kinda unrealistic. The knife in a camp role wouldn't be called on to do anything that extreme.

Just use it like you would and let us know how it cuts and chops and the edge holds up and how it feels doing those tasks.
 
hso. you don't think my test is realistic ? :) I think that if a blade is gonna fail that will show it and if it hurts your hand that will show it and with a 14" blade with the kind of heft that blade appears to have I think about 15 minutes per 4x4 would do the trick . Better than hacking on cement blocks like someone we know likes to test blades and then criticize them :)
 
Thanks guys! Anybody have any recommendations for sharpening a knife this large? It came sharp, but not as sharp as I'd like. Does not take hair of the arm.
 
If it's what I think it is, you should be able to put a nice finish edge on it with a fine cut file.

Followed by a fine stone or a pickle crock hone.

Just like a civil war solder would have done.

rc
 
Last edited:
Put a mouse pad on a 2x4 with 600 grit abrasive paper on it and strop the blade on it (assuming it has a convex edge).

***

Better than hacking on cement blocks like someone we know

<shudder>

A 2x4 softwood is about all the test chopping I'd do to test or in real life.
 
Cooldill

Very authentic looking Confederate Bowie knife you've got there. Here's hoping it cuts as well as it looks.
 
How sharp is it? You requested something you could use as a camp knife and it could be sharpened for heavy chopping instead of shaving.
 
I second the file or sandpaper either would work. Sand paper may take a while depending how dull it is. A file would fix you up quick and give you a nice secondary bevel to maintain. either way.... WHAT ARE YOU WAITING FOR ? :) J/K Merry Christmas get out in the woods!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top