Couple Arrested For Asking For Directions

Status
Not open for further replies.

Michigander

Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2004
Messages
1,301
Location
Michigan
POSTED: 7:23 am EDT May 17, 2006
UPDATED: 10:52 am EDT May 17, 2006

BALTIMORE -- Baltimore City police arrested a Virginia couple over the weekend after they asked an officer for directions.

WBAL-TV 11 News I-Team reporter David Collins said Joshua Kelly and Llara Brook, of Chantilly, Va., got lost leaving an Orioles game on Saturday. Collins reported a city officer arrested them for trespassing on a public street while they were asking for directions .

"In jail for eight hours -- sleeping on a concrete floor next to a toilet," Kelly said.

"It was a nightmare," Brook said. "I was in there thinking I was just dreaming and waiting to wake up."


Collins reported it was a nightmare ending to a nearly perfect day. He said the couple went to a company picnic and watched the Orioles beat Kansas City. It was their first trip to Camden Yards and asked two people for directions to Interstate 95 South when they left.

Collins said somehow they ended up in the Cherry Hill section of south Baltimore. Hopelessly lost, relief melted away concerns after they spotted a police vehicle.

"I said, 'Thank goodness, could you please get us to 95?" Kelly said.

"The first thing that she said to us was no -- you just ran that stop sign, pull over," Brook said. "It wasn't a big deal. We'll pay the stop sign violation, but can we have directions?"

"What she said was 'You found your own way in here, you can find your own way out.'" Kelly said.

Collins said the couple spotted another police vehicle and flagged that officer down for directions. But Officer Natalie Preston, a six-year veteran of the force, intervened.

"That really threw us for a loop when she stepped in between our cars," Kelly said. "(She) said my partner is not going to step in front of me and tell you directions if I'm not."

Collins reported the circumstances got worse. Kelly pulled 40 feet forward parking next to a curb and put his flashers on while Brook was on the phone to her father hoping he could help her with directions. Both her parents are police officers in the Harrisburg, Pa., area.

"(Brook's father) was in the middle of giving us directions when the officer screeched up behind us and got out of the car and asked me to step out. I obeyed," Kelly said. "I obeyed everything -- stepped out of the car, put my hands behind my back, and the next thing I know, I was getting arrested for trespassing."

"By this time, I was completely in tears," Brook said. "I said, 'Ma'am, you know, we just need your help. We are not trying to cause you any trouble. I'm not leaving him here.' What she did was walk over to my side of the car and said, 'Ok, we are taking you downtown, too.'"

Collins said the couple was released from jail without being charged with anything. Brook is now concerned the arrest may complicate a criminal background check she's going through in her job as a child care worker.

Collins said police left Kelly's car unlocked and the windows down at the impound lot. He reported a cell phone charger, pair of sunglasses and 20 CDs were stolen.

Baltimore City police said they are looking into the incident.

http://www.thewbalchannel.com/news/9229472/detail.html
 
and LEO's wonder why they are so disliked by law abiding folks

edit: removed word hate
 
I cant belive that, the very idea is alien to me.

Also very scary, that my freedom can be taken arbitrarily by a LEO who is simply having a bad day.

Shame, our old Chief of Police in Charleston, Chief Greenberg, would have taken care of that officer.
 
:rolleyes: Yes, those are the solution to the problem presented here. Filing a lawsuit and trying to get things righted in a mature fashion should never be tried before other less civilized methods are employed.
 
I'm well known for defending my fellow officers, but IF that account is true those two officers should be fired and the one who made the arrest should be charged criminally with false arrest. Not to mention sued in civil court for harrassment and civil rights violations. That is just despicable. :fire:
 
It happened in Baltimore City, unfortunately I have to say I'm not all that surprised. My guess is that the officer was white and the couple black or vice versa. It doesn't seem to matter the race of the officer- racism on the Balt City police force is pretty rampant.

On a good note...

A few months ago I was lost in a part of Philidelphia where you don't want to be lost well after dark. I asked a cop for directions out and instead of directions he had me follow him as he took me right to the exit for the highway. Instead of taking 30-45 seconds out of his day to tell me how to get where I needed to go, he went 10 minutes out of his way to show me. Talk about service.
 
The actions of these officers taint every good man and woman who wears a badge (yet I'm sure at least one of these good officers will complain that even pointing out this malfeasances is somehow "LEO Bashing" :rolleyes: ).


And boofus ... calm down a bit ... a good lawyer would be more effective than an SS190 :rolleyes:
 
Some thoughts that come to mind...

  • I'll bet it says something like "To Protect and to Serve" on the sides of the patrol cars, too.:p
  • This news story would make a good commercial for Thomas Brothers Maps.
  • Did the cop car have a bumper sticker that said, "If it's tourist season, why can't we shoot 'em?"
 
Quote:
arrested them for trespassing on a public street


I'm confused -

Actually, that doesn't surprise me one bit either. The police have been using that tactic in Baltimore as part of their "zero tolerance" campaign against crime. They've been arresting the kids who hang out on street corners for trespassing, take them to jail for the night, then release them without charging them. The arrests add to the arrest stats (ie. the politicians in Balt use it to show that the police are making progress) but since they are released without charges it doesn't add to the crime rate (ie. giving the impression that the crime rate is lower than last year). Takes away police man hours from fighting real crime while harrassing citizens- sounds like a good idea to me. For that part we can't blame the police- it is coming from above. It is designed to help Mayor Martin O'Malley get to the Governor's Mansion.
 
They've been arresting the kids who hang out on street corners for trespassing, take them to jail for the night, then release them without charging them.

As much as this, at least the way you put it, offends my libertarian sensibilities, I think that there is a good likelihood that this practice DOES reduce crime.

This is a dilemma worth thinking about, if we want to live in a free nation.
 
Too Bad The "Officers" Were Not Placed Under Citizen's Arrest

We need a little old-fashioned justice in this world. Why do we have to set back and permit illegal acts upon our lives and our bodies, just because someone carries a badge and a gun?

Someone should have intervened and placed the police under citizen's arrest. To me, this sounds like felony conspiracy, and a felony is grounds for a citizen arrest. Put the shoe on the other foot for once.

Oh--wait! In Michigan, it's a felony to disarm even a corrupt, morally bankrupt cop.

And people wonder why there exits an "Us V. Them attitude". Where else in the world, do the people permit that their money be taken from them, to hire "protectors" and "representatives" who subsequently not only fail to represent, but moreover who systematically abuse society at a whim.

Rant button off.
Edited to add:

Armedbear: That was great!!! :)

Doc2005
 
As much as this, at least the way you put it, offends my libertarian sensibilities, I think that there is a good likelihood that this practice DOES reduce crime.

However I still can't justify falsly incarcerating someone to prevent a crime they might commit later in the day.
 
However I still can't justify falsly incarcerating someone to prevent a crime they might commit later in the day.

I agree. But this is a debate that we must be informed enough to have intelligently, because, as they say, you will see this material again.:)

...and we need to be willing to offer alternative answers to the problem of rampant urban crime, including gang crime...

...which, by the way, is one of the main drivers for gun control proposals, so it behooves us to look for effective answers to gang and other urban crime, which is generally committed by young men who hang out on corners after dark...

Libertarians do need to offer solutions, not just objections, if we want to be taken seriously.
 
I still think the problem revolves around kids not having anything better to do. They need constructive activities they enjoy that discourage getting into trouble. Locking them up for 8 hours only postpones the crime if they are going to commit it. They gotta have something else to do.

There is no easy solution though.
 
This sounds too outrageous to be true. Why do I get the feeling there's more to the story?
I agree. I get the feeling that there's a lot that is not being reported.

If the situation took place in the way this report states that it did, the arresting officers are way, way, way out of line and have no business being police officers.

Did the officer tell them to move their vehicle? If so, pulling ahead a few feet and turning on the flashers could have been disobeying the lawful order of a police officer. Even then ... I don't know, something seems very off here.
 
sounds lie the baltimore PD is gearing up to make the illegal aliens feel at home, I could fully imagine this incident happening in mexico.

ETA except a large bribe would have been involved as well at some point in the proceedings.
 
I guess the Baltimore theory of crime prevention is to put as mant warm bodies in jail as they can so that there are fewer people left to commit crimes. Perhaps they can institute a jail lottery to give all their citizens a chance to participate in crime fighting.
 
NO NO I won't say it...

but they asked two female officers, :confused: and in my expierence I have seen more female officers with a power complex than any other, :eek: they tend to wear their feelings on their sleve and abuse authority more often, :what: and if having a bad day pass it on to the first poor sucker they happen uppon. :fire: That is the issue and they need a good lawyer to take the town to task.:cuss:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top