Critique my targets: 3 slug types from 50 yards

Status
Not open for further replies.

Vex

Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2004
Messages
413
Location
Central Ohio
Went to the range a long while back. Took my Spas-12 for the first time. Sure is hell'a fun to fire.

Anyway, I shot five rounds of 3 different slug types from bench rest at 50 yards. I wasn't really expecting much, but in the end I was surprised.

Note: Targets have 8" diameter black circle with 1" orange bull's eye. Point of aim for all shots was the bottom of the black circle.

--------------------------------------------------

This is the Remington 7/8 ounce, High velocity slug, rated 1800fps per the box. Two out of five fired rounds landed in the black area, making a grouping of 2.75", grouping centered 2.2" above the point of aim. A third shot landed 3.5" below the point of aim. Two more shots didn't hit paper.

attachment.php


This is the Brenneke K.O. 1 ounce, standard velocity. Only one shot out of the five fired landed in the black area, approximately 2" above the point of aim. Three more hit just above or touching the top of the black area. A fifth shot hit half off the paper on the bottom edge. Approximate total grouping is 15.8".

Furthermore, I will note that the shells did not eject properly, as these rounds did not have enough power to cycle the gas system on the weapon. The neat thing, though, is that these rounds left nice, very clear punchouts of the riflings on the holes. What can we discern from this fact?

attachment.php


And finally, the clear winner, the Federal Premium Truball, 1 ounce, standard velocity. All five rounds hit the black area of the target. Total grouping between all 5 rounds measured 4.5", with the center of the grouping only 5" above the point of aim. The best four shots hit in a grouping measuring 1.8", with the center of the grouping measuring 6" above the point of aim.

If you look close enough, you can see my measurements I wrote on the target to show group sizes and measurements.

attachment.php


--------------------------------------------------

Overall, I am really impressed with the grouping of the Federal rounds. The Spas-12 really liked that round. It cycled correctly, it was fairly accurate out to 50 yards (enough to hit my intended target where I want to), and even though it kicks like a mule, it's extremely satisfying to shoot.

Anyway, whether you care or not about the platform I used (because it's quite exotic), I'm wondering a few things that more seasoned shotgunners will be more adept at answering....


Are my results consistent with poor ammunition choice for the weapon, or could it be operator error (flinch, for example, throwing nearly half the rounds off the paper)?

Are the results enough to warrant buying a half dozen boxes of the Federal for stock?

What does it mean to be able to see the riflings in the Brenneke slugs' holes?

Anyone else have good fortunes with the Federal rounds?



Thanks for the input.... also, I have images of these that are 4 times bigger if you really want to see the detail on the Brenneke slug holes. It's really very neat.
 

Attachments

  • remington-1800fps-50yard.jpg
    remington-1800fps-50yard.jpg
    58.9 KB · Views: 212
  • brenneke-ko-50yard.jpg
    brenneke-ko-50yard.jpg
    60.2 KB · Views: 218
  • federal-truball-50yard.jpg
    federal-truball-50yard.jpg
    60.9 KB · Views: 211
Operator error can be a factor, but I'd be more inclined to blame that if ALL groups were bad. That low shot on that Fed group could be a flinch.

The "Rifling" may mean your bore is oversize for the slugs. I've found Remington classic slugs to be on the small side for the bore. A friend liked them in his Deerslayer, which had a .690" bore, around full choke dimensions.

One group each is not a final test. Do try some more groups with the Fed load and see how it goes.

Your results are not unique. Many shotguns do much better with some slugs than others.

4" at 50 yards is not great. 3" is getting there....

Good luck and keep on....
 
Thanks for replying. I don't have much experience with slugs and accuracy, so any information helps. I just don't know quite what to expect, yet.
 
For comparison's sake, the lesser of my two slug shooters goes under 5" at 100 yards. The better around 4. These are peep sighted 870s using the best tested slug.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top