CSI Miami makes a faux pas tonight

Status
Not open for further replies.

papercut

Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2003
Messages
199
Location
Cobb County, Georgia
In tonight's episode of CSI Miami, "The Oath," Horatio Caine (played by David Caruso), makes this statement: "A .22 is registered to Gary Nielsen's wife."

:rolleyes:

I see the show's producers went to a lot of trouble to check on Florida's gun laws regarding registration.
 
The original CSI would also have us believe that Nevada has firearms registration. It's handy for the sake of drama but every time I hear it I :rolleyes:
 
The nice thing about Hollywierd making these mistakes is that people believe it and there is less pressure to create a registration/database...at least from the average fence sitter/ sheeple.
 
I can't stand that show. Maybe that's why I watched it.

They also went the extra effort to show how a guy that tries to defend himself will only screw up and get a cop killed.
 
The original CSI would also have us believe that Nevada has firearms registration. It's handy for the sake of drama but every time I hear it I

The show was in Vegas, which is in Clark County, which does have handgun registration.

"Clark County

12.04.110 Registration of pistols within twenty-four hours. Any person receiving title to a pistol, whether by purchase, gift, or any other transfer, and whether from a dealer or from any other person, shall, within twenty-four hours of such receipt, personally appear at the county sheriff's office, together with the pistol, for the purpose of registering the same with the sheriff. It shall be the duty of the sheriff to register the pistol, and he may, and is hereby authorized to cooperate in any manner he sees fit with other law enforcement agencies, and with licensed dealers, relative to registration of pistols, so that efficient registration shall be secured at minimum cost and duplication."
 
Whats really crazy is that in states that DON'T have registration there seem to be ways that the Police still manage to find out who a gun belongs to based on its serial number. Makes you go hmmmmm.
 
In Michigan, we have a "safety inspection" which puts the pistol's serial number and the owner's name on a state police form.

But, we don't call it "registration". :)

Hmmmmmmm.

Does Florida / Nevada have anything like that?
 
Maybe the episode that is being referred to was made before the law restricting the creation of databases was codified by the FL legislature over the past few weeks.
 
SOS/DD. The talking heads on the local news routinely mention whether a gun was 'registered' or not, nevermind that neither VA or MD 'register' guns.

The gross ignorance of the public at large regarding gun laws is the biggest single impediment to RKBA. One thing that has been consistent in my modest efforts at converting anti's/fence-sitters is the sense of amazement displayed (often followed by anger at the stupidity of it all)when I explain the firearms laws involved in purchase, CWP, class III, etc., even in a relatively gun-friendly state like VA. They just don't get it and are too lazy to do the homewoprk/think it through.
 
I'm just glad that Mythbusters destroyed the meat bullet theory....take that, CSI...
CSI is sometimes good, but quite often interspersed with junk science and urban legend. I like trying to beat them to the punch and figure out the BG, but usually that's not hard....

:neener:
 
Mike In VA:
I believe the MD State Police call it 'voluntary registration' when filling out the "regulated weapon" paperwork in Maryland; it just so happens that if you dont volunteer to list the serial number of the weapon you're purchasing the police volunteer to not approve your purchase. :rolleyes:

Kharn
 
The Other One- IIRC, the issue was that the guy was a convicted felon that was in posession of a .22 revolver and that after the shooting was over, he had the option of using his cell phone or the injured cops radio to call for help and left the scene instead.
I don't recall anyone specifically saying that him defending himself caused to cop to die. I don't really think it was all that smart to start shooting when a cop was already there though.


Mino
 
HellllOOOooo!

CSI, in both flavors, is FANTASY. The producers’ only obligation is the consistent manufacture of audiences for the network’s sale to advertisers. The producers acknowledge routinely overriding their technical advisors. Threads like these rise only slightly above discussions of whether TV wrestling is real.

Check your brain with the attendant and enjoy!
 
Horatio came down on him about "Contagious Gunfire" since he shot first, which caused everybody else to start shooting, which led to the unfortunate hole in the officer's lung.
 
I hate that show. They can't be real detectives because they never say "Jinkies, a clue". :p My wife used to watch it every now and then and stopped when I started screaming about the propaganda and Horatio's cheezy hands on the hips stance:rolleyes:
 
Check your brain with the attendant and enjoy!


In think something must be wrong with me. If I have to check my brain at the door...

I can't. If the only way to enjoy something is to check my brain, I not only can't enjoy it, I can't understand how anyone can.


I know I'm deficient somewhere, but I can't quite put my finger on it...
 
I only watch for Emily Proctor, and the DNA girl. :neener:

Brain dutifully checked - remember to pick it up on your way out!

~W
 
I only watch for Emily Proctor, and the DNA girl.
******************************************

Ah, yes, "gun girl" as my wife calls her. She almost compensates for Caruso and his melodrama.:D
 
Some years ago, I had an encounter with a local cop, when she became aware that I was armed. (I was on my own property at the time.) One of her first questions was "is that registered?" I had to explain to her that there is no requirement or provision for registering firearms in this state. Her next question was "do you have a permit?" and I had to explain that there was no permit required to own a firearm in this state. She refused to believe me until another officer confirmed what I was saying. (I know how rediculous that statement sounds, but it's the truth.)

Someone had just tried to break into my place, and they (the PD) were in the process of setting up the perimeter around the area. As soon as she discovered I had a firearm sitting on a desk across the room from where we were standing, she called for assistance and had 5 other cops keeping her company instead of looking for the perp. Needless to say, they didn't find him. I received a lecture on how I didn't need a gun for defense and shouldn't have one, despite the fact that I'd just run off an intruder who knew someone was home when he decided to break in. (We strongly suspect that he thought my GF was home alone, as she had been sun bathing out back until just before he broke in, while I was working in the basement.)

A couple of weeks later, one of our dispatchers (Im a medic in a neighboring jurisdiction) let me know that my address had been flagged in the computer aided dispatch system with an officer safety warning, noting that the home owner was armed. That was evidently more important to them than someone trying to break into an occupied dewlling in the middle of the day.
 
The Other One- IIRC, the issue was that the guy was a convicted felon that was in posession of a .22 revolver and that after the shooting was over, he had the option of using his cell phone or the injured cops radio to call for help and left the scene instead.
I don't recall anyone specifically saying that him defending himself caused to cop to die. I don't really think it was all that smart to start shooting when a cop was already there though.
I don't remember the exact words but Horatio basically said that the cop had it all under control (under control being two bad guys pointing guns at him) and the guy had to screw it all up by trying to defend himself by shooting at one of the bad guys, thus causing the bad guys to shoot the cop.

Also, I loved how they proved the guy had shot the .22 after giving him hearing test. How the hell can you tell someone is deafer than they were a day before when you have no idea how much they could hear the day before?

I have to stop watching the thing because that show just really makes me mad everytime I see it. I must like punishing myself because I've seen it way too many times. I think the worst thing is the acting by David Caruso and that blonde lady. Acting rarely gets much worse!
 
I are currently a CSI - Never watch the CSI show.

Retired Navy - Never watched JAG or Pensacola Wings of Gold

Former Paramedic - Never watched Rescue 911 or any of the other "medical action shows"

Guess I'm just jaded.
 
Check your brain with the attendant and enjoy!

Even if I do, when watching CSI and other "anti gun propaganda disguised as entertainment" I still fell like a Jew watching a Leni Riefenstahl film :banghead:


Forgive my invocation of Godwin's Law
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top