First............DNS, that is one of the best treatises I have read on haggling. Do you mind if I incorporate some of your thoughts with mine in a blog post in the future?
Second, I have recorded my
pawn shopping secrets for all to read. Just click the link.
One of the common misconceptions in the used gun market is that there are absolute prices for used guns. The Blue Book creates this illusion. In reality though, published prices on used guns are the result of market anaysis of gun show and gun store prices across the country a year or so prior to publication of the book. They are a guide, nothing more.
Regional variances do not come into play in the Blue Book, and they are strong. Some gun show dealers simply make money buying guns in Louisiana and selling them in Arizona or vice versa. S&W revolvers are under priced in North Louisiana according to the Blue Book. Some prices are driven by a collector's market that you may not see. The Blue Book is not a negotiating tool. It will only help on guns that do not have volatile prices. This year Colt ceased making revolvers. Prices skyrocketed. The same has happened with Winchester, but not quite so dramatic. These price trends will not show up in a Blue Book for at least two or three years. To understand the price trends you have to understand the market as well as the gun. Buying a price guide will help somewhat. It will prevent you from paying to much for a gun if you are willing to walk away. Even then, you may miss a deal because you did not understand the market.
If you use the Blue Book as a negotiating tool, you will show yourself to be a neophyte. Prices are based on much more than the Blue Book, and in the end, the price is what each person decides it should be. If they agree, the item is sold. If they do not, the sale is not made. A gun is worth what a buyer will pay at the time of the sale. All else is speculation.
A seller can price his wares any way he pleases. Just because you do not buy his wares does not mean he doesn't sell them. Every day I see automobiles on the street that I know somebody paid more for than I pay for real estate. I think they are foolish and the cars are in no way worth that much. That does not mean the car did not sell and a seller did not make money. It just means I would spend the same money differently. Thus, I am not a potential customer. It does not mean the cars are not worth that amount. It just means that they are not worth that to me. If I walked into a Lexus dealership, I will be wasting the salesman's time. That doesn't mean I can't buy one. It just means we will never arrive at an agreement on price.
It is true that there are some pawn shops that may have a hard time selling guns on their shelves. Have you ever thought the owner may be hiding his personal collection from his wife by keeping it in his shop? I know of at least one pawn shop where the owner does that. I suspect there are more. Some areas will have pawn shops that are not fertile ground for deals. This is just a fact. If there are no good pawn shops in your area, try another area. Heck, I found a strip outside of Barksdale AFB that has over ten pawn shops. Some have good prices, others are way above the mark on the same gun. They are all within a mile of each other too!
Judging pawn shops as a gun buying resource based on one or two shops is like judging the used car market based on one or two dealers. You simply don't have enough data to make an informed conclusion. There are some good shops out there where good deals can be found.
Even after all that, I have not mentioned that pawn shops do not
need to sell their guns to you. They make money off loans, not guns. If they tossed the guns in a box and then sold them for pennies on the dollar to a wholeseller, they would come out ahead. Some simply place the gun in the case with a high price and then list it on Gun Broker or Auction Arms. Why shouldn't they? As a financial institution, guns are simply not a pawn shop's income.
Here are a few of the deals I have found.
None of the prices were negotiated.
S&W Model of 1899---$69
S&W post-war M&P---$89
S&W Victory M&P-----$150
S&W 1911------------$489
S&W1911 with laser---$659 (I sold the laser grips for $200 later
)
Colt Python-----------$600
S&W Model 67-1------$179
S&W Model 60--------$179
S&W MOdel 60-9------$250
S&W Model 10-5------$179
S&W Model 10-5------$159
Colt Woodsman, 1st Series $250
S&W Model 28-------$239
S&W Model 10-5 nickel snub $179
S&W Model 17-2------$199
Colt Diamondback------$249
S&W Model 15-3-------$199
S&W Model 19-4 nickel---$279
There have been other guns that I have passed up because they were in calibers I rarely shoot, or their condition was not what I would expect at the price asked. You can see pics of these guns as well as many I left behind at my
Pawn Shop Circuit blog. You will note a Colt/S&W revolver trend in my buying. That is not by happenstance. Glocks are out there for fair prices too. I just don't look at them. If you are wanting a Walther P99 I know where one has been sitting for $450 or so. I see very few 1911s in pawn shops. If I do, they are usually gussied up, overpriced bubba nightmares.
The deals may or may not be available in your area. If they are not, that is not a reflection on pawn shops everywhere. I am looking at a S&W Model 10-5 Round butt right now that I am loath to buy at $225, because it is over $200. I'm probably nuts for that......