DL Knives' "Fighter" review

Status
Not open for further replies.

PTK

Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2007
Messages
3,712
Location
Montana
First impressions of my Fighter knife by DL Knives (our own Valkman here on THR) were overall quite positive. The model I purchased is fitted with brown Micarta scales, and is made from CPMD2 steel .225" thick, HT by Paul Bos, with the usual "false edge" actually sharpened on my example. The polish, as received, was matchless (mirror finish), and displayed a stamp from both Bos and Mr. Llewellyn. As received, it wasn't razor sharp, but took a phenomenal edge with very little persuasion from a black Arkansas oilstone.

Minor problems were encountered, but all were just that - minor problems. The lanyard tube protrudes slightly from one side of the scales, epoxy resin (or similar adhesive-like residue) seeped out of the joint between the scales and the blade in the first few hours of use, and the forward finger groove has a sharp edge where it hits the flat of the blade. The last issue is the most significant, as it managed to give very minor cuts to my finger during testing outdoors - this is something I can probably clean up in a matter of minutes with a file, though I haven't done so as I've just got back from testing out in Harris Park. :)

Now, the great parts - this knife is a crowbar with a blade, friends. Batoning through wood is a cinch, whether green wood, standing dead wood, or processed lumber. Digging with the wide blade is fast and efficient, far surpassing my previous favorite (a USMC Ka-Bar) at the task. Prying can be easily accomplished with the tip of the blade - I managed to pry a lock off a trunk (think old-time footlocker) without any scratches or damage to the blade.

Unlike a crowbar, however, this knife also excels at other tasks such as food preparation. Slicing through thinner vegetables didn't work as well as a paring knife, but for a blade .225" thick at the spine it worked incredibly well. Tomatoes did prove problematic, however. ;) Harder vegetables such as potatoes, carrots, and onions didn't give rise to any issues whatsoever. Meat was also cubed without too much effort - about on par with my less expensive non-serrated kitchen knives (which is MUCH more than can be said about similar "fighter" knives from other producers!) I'd rate it a touch less useful for food prep than a Henkel chef's knife, but not by much.

All in all, this knife seems to be a do-it-all knife that is so well built as to outlast me by generations. What is most surprising of all is that this versatile knife was only $225 and the patience to wait for Don to work his magic.

attachment.php


Folks, if you're looking for a great custom made knife for not too much money, get a DL Knives "Fighter". You will not be disappointed. :D
 

Attachments

  • fighter_used.jpg
    fighter_used.jpg
    27.5 KB · Views: 264
Drool. Nice review. I am not to knowledgeable about custom blades. How do you know which one's you can pry with?
 
I figure, properly heat treated .225" thick 6" blade full tang knife.... D2 steel... PLENTY strong enough. If I break it, I'll be very surprised.
 
The lanyard tube protrudes slightly from one side of the scales, epoxy resin (or similar adhesive-like residue) seeped out of the joint between the scales and the blade in the first few hours of use, and the forward finger groove has a sharp edge where it hits the flat of the blade.

None of those should be present and I'm sorry that they were. I don't know if I've gotten in too much of a hurry or what. It should have been sharp enough to shave the hair off your arm and there should not be any epoxy coming out - I don't know what is causing that. The lanyard tube thing bothers me as well - should not move like that. The sharpness of the finger groove is a mistake I keep making. Overall it sound like I did a "D" job on this knife and I apologize for that. I will fix it up if you ever want to send it back.

As for strength, yep these have tons of it and I doubt if you'll break it. Use it like you stole it!
 
Don.


DON. PLEASE let me restate - this is the best knife I have ever owned, bar none.

Read that again. The minor problems I listed are just that - minor problems.

Folks - read his response... "I will fix it up if you ever want to send it back." This is the response of a proper businessman. :)

As for sending it back, though that is a very generous offer.... good luck getting me to part with it for more time than it takes to sleep each night. ;)
 
These knives look amazing. I'd love to order five of Don's various knives...

if I had the money, that is.
 
Update - minor problems have been entirely resolved. I've been quite impressed at how well this knife is keeping an edge. It's been my go-to for literally any prying, cutting, or digging task since I got it. No damage thus far, and it's razor-sharp, STILL. :D
 
Yes, it's a CPMD2 blade. INCREDIBLE steel, it seems. Better than my ATS34 knives, so far...
 
Should be better than D2 because the grain structure is much more uniform. It's a supersteel so it'd better act like one! :)
 
Time will tell - it's the best knife I own (don't own any D2 blades) so I can't really tell compare it to anything else fairly. :)
 
Really really - compared to my AG Russel "one hand opener" in ATS-34 and my Gerber something-or-other in ATS-34, this CPMD2 steel is actually better. :)
 
Another month or so of hard use, and it's still sharp and looking new.

Don, once again, thank you for the fantastic piece of functional art. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top