Family Says Army Shortchanging Former POW

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jeff White

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Dec 24, 2002
Messages
37,926
Location
Alma Illinois
Family Says Army Shortchanging Former POW
1 hour, 15 minutes ago
Add U.S. National - AP to My Yahoo!

By CHRIS ROBERTS, Associated Press Writer

EL PASO, Texas - The father of former prisoner of war Shoshana Johnson on Friday accused the Army of shortchanging his daughter of disability benefits after she was offered a smaller paycheck than fellow POW Jessica Lynch.

"She is not getting what she deserves," Claude Johnson said.

Family members confirmed that Lynch, a private first class who was snatched from her Iraqi captors on April 1 in a rescue by Special Forces, is receiving an 80 percent disability. Johnson, a specialist who was released on April 13 with four other American POWs, has been offered 30 percent, Claude Johnson said.

The Rev. Jesse Jackson (news - web sites), who consulted the Johnson family, said race was playing a part in Army's decision. Lynch is white; Johnson is black.

"There's a long history of blacks not receiving fair and adequate recognition in the military," said Jackson. "The first black female POW who survived is about to be discharged and suffers the trauma, the emotional injury and has a 3-year-old daughter to raise. She deserves more."

Army spokesman Maj. Steve Stover said Shoshana Johnson's payment can be appealed.

Stover said the two cases are different and race is not an issue.

Stover disputed reports that Lynch had been medically discharged this summer, even though she has been allowed to reach a $1 million book deal.

He said Lynch is on the Temporary Disability Retired List and has not technically been discharged. She will be reevaluated periodically and if recovered sufficiently, she could go back on active duty or request an official discharge.

Shoshana Johnson will be discharged soon.

"The disability compensation is based on each individual soldier's condition," Stover said.

Military officials said Lynch was hurt after her Humvee utility vehicle was hit by a rocket-propelled grenade and crashed into another vehicle. She suffered multiple broken bones and other injuries and it was four months before she could walk again.

Shoshana Johnson was shot in both ankles and was held by Iraqi captors for 22 days. She still periodically uses a walking cast, has a hard time staying on her feet for any period of time and is not sleeping well, her father said.

She was shown in an Iraqi video fearfully watching her captors as they peppered her and the other POWs with questions.

The disability and discharge status of the other former POWs was not immediately known.

Claude Johnson said Lynch and his daughter, who were both stationed at Fort Bliss near El Paso, have become friends.

In a statement released Friday by her attorney, Lynch said she was "disappointed for Shoshana."



"When she visited me in West Virginia last month, we discussed the extent of our injuries and the long road back to health, including a lifetime commitment to physical therapy and rehabilitation," Lynch said. "I support her efforts 100 percent and wish her a continued ... recovery."
 
Johnson can appeal her disability rating.
I would imagine she has already done so.
I would also imagine that this publicity has brought her alleged shortchanging to the attention of the Military Order Of The Purple Heart.

Those folks are good at accelerating re-hearings and appeals.
Worked for me and many others.

I wish her luck.

Sam
 
Mike,
The Army infratructure has nothing to do with this. Disabilty benefits are set by a Medical Reveiw Board consisitng of medical professionals. Each case is handled individually. I'm sure SPC Johnson's injuries are not as severe as PFC Lynch's.

Soldiers are also entitled to have the Veterans Administration set their level of disability.

The system is fair, race, gender or circumstances have nothing to do with it.

Jeff
 
Bringing Jessie Jackson in is a mistake. It will polarize people and will make many think that the race issue is being brouhgt up as an attempted money grab. They should persue whatever needs to be done to revaluate her conditions and confirm that in face the two soldier's status is the same as far is duty and disability are concerned. I think using Jessie Jackson to draw attention to the situation only hurts their cause. Lynch drew massive amounts of attention with her rescue, I am sure the army is conscious of this fact when evaluating her case. johnson needs to make sure that she is being treated fairly, but if they are in different situations where duty clasification and disablilty are concerned then bringing race into the picture will only hurt her credability.
 
Investigation reveals Lynch suffered bone-crushing injuries in crash
By DANA PRIEST, WILLIAM BOOTH AND SUSAN SCHMIDT, THE WASHINGTON POST,
© June 18, 2003

I have include only the portions of
the article pertinent to PFC Lynch's injuries. The full story here

To repair the fractures, a spinal injury and other injuries suffered during her ordeal, the 20-year-old private first class undergoes a daily round of physical therapy.

Lynch has been in the hospital now for 67 days. Her physical condition remains severe. But she also appears to suffer from wounds that cannot be seen -- and the story of her capture and rescue remains only partly told.

Lynch was riding in a Humvee when it plowed into a jackknifed U.S. truck. She suffered major injuries, including multiple fractures and compression to her spine, that knocked her unconscious, military sources said. The collision killed or gravely injured the Humvee's four other passengers.

A U.S. tractor-trailer with a flatbed swerved around an Iraqi dump truck and jackknifed. As Dowdy's speeding Humvee approached the overturned tractor-trailer, it was hit on the driver's side by a rocket-propelled grenade. The driver, Piestewa, lost control of the Humvee, swerved right and struck the trailer.

The senior defense official described the collision as ``catastrophic.''

Dowdy, sitting in the passenger seat, was killed instantly. So, probably, were the two soldiers on either side of Lynch. Piestewa and Lynch were seriously injured, according the senior officer's account.

Lynch's arm and legs were crushed by the compression, U.S. military doctors would later conclude. Tiny bone fragments protruded through her skin.

At Walter Reed, Lynch's bones have been put back together with such a delicate and extensive network of rods and pins that it can take an hour for her to move from bed to wheelchair.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I would say Lynch suffered a heck of alot worse injuries than Miss Johnson. It is quite possible the extent of her disabilities might be much more severe.
It would appear that envy once again rears it's ugly head in Miss Johnson's (and Jesse Jerkson's) case, over the disability and probably more so over the book and movie deal (a whole different thing).
They should just shut their rascist pieholes and deal with it like any other service member has to. :fire:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top