Favorite gun cleaning solution

Status
Not open for further replies.
i'm very happy with kroil. it's way better than hoppes.
much faster.

if you run a wet patch thru the barrel n let it sit while you have a cuppa, the dirt comes out fast. i need a lot less patches to get it nice. i often use it in combo with jb.
the kroil cleans, the jb polishes.
you can buy these as a set.
 
All I can say is that hasn't been my experience. In my experience, even soaking a barrel in Kroil for days/weeks doesn't make it significantly easier/faster to clean than if I simply start out with a decent nitro solvent.

What I think is happening is that people find that they start getting clean patches faster when they use Kroil and that makes them think that Kroil is cleaning faster. What's really happening is that Kroil just isn't nearly as good at getting stuff out of the bore so the patches start coming out clean much faster.

Try this test.

Clean a barrel using only Kroil and another one using only a typical bore cleaner like Hoppes.

When you're done and believe the barrels are clean, wet each bore with BreakFree CLP, let it set for half an hour or so and then push another patch down the barrels. Save the patches. Then patch out the bores until they're completely dry and wet the bores with a dedicated copper solvent like Hoppes Benchrest #9. Wait however long the copper solvent instructions state and push dry patches down each barrel. Save those patches.

Now compare the patches and you can see whether Kroil or the bore cleaner works best. The cleaner which provides the cleanest patches did the best job.
...the kroil cleans, the jb polishes...
Ok, another issue here. If you're mixing Kroil and JB, then that's an entirely different issue. JB is an abrasive bore cleaner and, in my experience, abrasive bore cleaners are VERY effective at removing all types of bore fouling and are generally very fast. The only issue is that they are more aggressive than some people like.

If you're using a mixture of Kroil and JB, you will get the bore very clean very fast. However, in my experience, you'll get it just as clean, just as fast using only the JB.
 
i haven't tried jb alone yet but i will.
i'm realhappy with the combo tho.
i clean my guns often n i like doing it fast.
 
I like M-Pro 7 because it is odorless and nonflammable. It works well enough on my guns for general use. I have some conventional petroleum based solvents and specialty copper solvents for tough cases.

I have a tall skinny olive jar full of the old "benchrest blend" of Kroil and Shooter's Choice. A three day soak will loosen hard fouling in a pistol barrel. Quickie treatments are not so effective.
 
I have a tall skinny olive jar full of the old "benchrest blend" of Kroil and Shooter's Choice. A three day soak will loosen hard fouling in a pistol barrel. Quickie treatments are not so effective.
Have you tried it with just Shooter's Choice?

I've tried soaking pistol barrels for weeks in a Kroil/Acetone/ATF mixture without seeing any significant benefit over just using typical solvents.

I would love for Kroil to work better than (or even as well as) the typical gun solvents, I just haven't found that to be the case.

By the way, the best "conventional" nitro solvent I have run across was the old BreakFree bore solvent. It came in a glass jar and was clear, like water. I can't find it anymore. That stuff cut carbon amazingly well. I wish I still had some to use as a pre-soak or as an ingredient in a pre-soak mixture.
 
Guys just read the MSDS sheets for most of your favorite gun cleaners. A lot of them are the same stuff sold under different labels. This is incredibly common in the solvent industry.
 
Ed's Red is still the best thing I've used, especially for clean up after firing a lot of cast bullets and cleaning carbon rings off the front of a cylinder. The price has gone up though since the last batch, the 4 ingredients (no lanolin) came out to just under $30 yesterday for enough to make a gallon batch. Anyone that hasn't tried this should. I seldom mix a gallon at one time, rather, I measure out equal quantities and fill one of my wifes empty fingernail polish remover containers which originally had acetone in it so the plastic bottle holds up with no issues.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top