Favorite Smith and Wesson .357 revolver?

Favorite .357 from this list?

  • Model 19/66

    Votes: 69 35.9%
  • Model 586/686

    Votes: 68 35.4%
  • Model 27

    Votes: 55 28.6%

  • Total voters
    192
Status
Not open for further replies.
I love that this poll is turning out so evenly, and take it as confirmation of what numerous posters have said; these are all terrific guns. The difference, I think, really boils down to what use you'd want to put a particular model to. Having handled all three, I'd say the ideal places for them would look something like this:

N-frame 357: Hunting and field carry; target and action competition

L-frame 357: Open carry for LE, security, or private citizen in appropriate situations

K-frame 357: Concealed (or concealable) carry for LE, security, or private citizen.

They can all obviously do any of the things on the list; but I'm just trying to think of how the particular strengths of each model/frame size suit it best to particular applications. E.g., a K-frame is obviously a fine gun for open LE carry as well (witness the grillions of them that have been carried just this way); but my notion is that the L represents a slightly better balance of bulk and strength for this application, since you don't have to worry about hiding those few extra ounces and millimeters.

Any other opinions on the best applications of these great varieties of 357?
 
My Model 27-2, on or about June 30th, when the gunsmith is done tuning it up for me!
 
I voted for the 27. I have a "Pre" 27 made a couple of years before S&W started using the model numbers. It has the 3.5 inch Bbl. My late mother called it "A sweet little pistol."
 
I owned a 65 for a little while and traded it (wish I didn't) but always figured I would buy another k frame if I bought another S&W .357. Then, I saw my 586 4" sitting in the used case at the local shop and it was love at first sight. Months later, I'm even more jazzed with it than I was the first day. But I still have to say once my birthday gets a little closer I'm going to see if I can't get that 2 3/4" 19 out of the dealer's used case...
 
Regarding ammo, I recently bought a Blackhawk Convertible so I could shoot cheap 9mm ammo. I've found that I still shoot mostly .357 anyway, just because I enjoy shooting stronger rounds. I shoot best with .357. Standing, offhand, I've been regularly putting six .357 rounds in two-inch patterns right around the 10 ring at 30 feet, which isn't bad for me (and I've only had the gun to the range twice--I'm hoping to improve). With 9mm or .38, it's more like 3-4 inches.

It seems like once I got used to the bark of the .357, the weaker ammo just didn't feel right. That holds true for both my Ruger and my brother's 686.
 
For looking at, cleaning or talking over etc... a 5" 19 with nice Combat grips.

For having on my hip and shooting at the range, probably a 4" 66 or 686 with Hogues.
 
I'll have to vote on the K frame , as it's small enough to CCW, but can easily take the full magnum.
 
I absolutely LOVE my 2.5" M66 for all occasions!
LOVE IT! LOVE IT! LOVE IT!
I'm gonna go kiss it now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top