Flattop blackhawks

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have a pile of good revolvers, but my gently worked-over Flattop .44 Special is the one that usually ends up in my hands. I firelapped it, had an action job done, and installed a Rough Country rear sight from Bowen. It's probably the most all-around useful, accurate, and enjoyable gun I own. If I didn't have it, getting one would be my top priority.

Regarding loads, I use two. The first is a fun plinking load consisting of Lee's 240 grain RN at 750 FPS or so. Lots of different powders work. I generally go with 6 grains of Unique. With a pair of Lee gang molds, it's easy to crank out hundreds of bullets, and as the gun likes them, they make for great plinking and woods loafing loads.

The second is the classic Skeeter load. I use a custom mold to produce a true Keith bullet with square grooves, equal size bands, and lots of space for lube. 7.5 grains of Unique, of course. It is supremely accurate, cuts perfect holes in paper, and has accounted for several head of big game for me.

I have played around with very heavy loads just a bit. After reading Ross Seyfried's article on the guns, I tried his H110 load with the Keith bullet. It worked, went about 1100 FPS in my 5 1/2" gun, and though it wasn't quite as accurate as the Skeeter load, it was still more accurate than I can hold offhand. It also kicked pretty much like a .44 Magnum. Though I have no doubt it was safe in my gun - fired cases fell out of the chambers and primers looked essentially the same as they did in the Skeeter loads - I finally decided that as I have plenty of Magnums in various bore diameters, there was no need for me to force the Bisley to be another one.

The short version is that these are fantastic guns and I would definitely get one if I was you. The .357 is a fantastic cartridge and the obvious choice for a fellow who does not handload. The .44 Special, though, is just about ideal as a revolver cartridge - as long as you handload and, hopefully, cast your own - and also brands you as a truly knowledgeable pistolero! :D
 
Last edited:
I would go with the 44 special if only because you don't see them offered as often as 357s. Also, I have so many guns for 357 magnum (it's a wonderfully diverse cartridge) the 50th Ann. BH wouldn't add versatility. I also like the 44 special cartridge, it appeals the same way 32 long and 41 magnum ammo appeals. They all have a satisfying feel to them for comfort and accuracy and are simple and economic to reload.

Having said all that, I would get both if possible. :D As someone said on a recent thread, you can't have too many 357s.

Jeff
 
I got one of the .357's when they first came out with the intent of converting it to .44Spl. When they came out with a factory .44Spl, I traded it away and don't miss it. Really too heavy for a .357. For a .357, I like the lighter Old Models.

IMG_0095b.jpg

Which still make fantastic .44Spl's!

IMG_7120e.jpg

If I'm gonna deal with the weight of an all steel New Model, I'll make it a Bisley.

IMG_7535b.jpg
 
Where are you guys buying these beautiful grips from? My 41 mag NM Blackhawk needs a new set, I’ll need two sets if I get one of these revolvers I’m looking at they both have plastic factory grips.
 
Well, you guys and your beautiful revolver photos have gotten me into trouble once again. Just got back from doing the paperwork for the .44 now I’ve just got wait for the terrible new background check system in Washington to do it’s thing and I’ll be living large with my new revolver. The 357 is still there if anyone wants it I’ll be happy to tell you where it’s at. 0F42B4C1-ECF9-4D85-A940-6156B4A81F85.jpeg
 
I think you made the right decision.
Since you cast and load, .44 Special was the way to go.

If you were stuck using factory ammo, I may say differently.
I have a 4 5/8" Super Blackhawk that sees more specials than it does magnums.
Ii want one on the smaller frame.
 
One major reason I went with the 44 over the .357 is component availability now and into the future. I have far more large pistol primers than I do small, I’m a brasshound so I already have 100 pieces of 44 special starline brass from scrounging around a gravel pit, 250 Barry’s plated 240gn flatpoints that my neighbor gave me last year to melt down as he didn’t like them. Just need to pick up some dies and a mold and I’m set for ages.
For the 357 I’d have to use small pistol primers ( harder to find right now) and buy brass as I have plenty of 38 only have a handful of 357. In addition to dies and a mold.

The other reason is the cool factor that has been discussed.
 
I think you made the right decision.
Since you cast and load, .44 Special was the way to go.

If you were stuck using factory ammo, I may say differently.
I have a 4 5/8" Super Blackhawk that sees more specials than it does magnums.
Ii want one on the smaller frame.
Yes I understand the want for a smaller frame. I shoot a lot of loads in my 41 that are right around 240gn at 1000-1100fps and now I can do that in a smaller framed more packable gun.
 
Where are you guys buying these beautiful grips from? My 41 mag NM Blackhawk needs a new set, I’ll need two sets if I get one of these revolvers I’m looking at they both have plastic factory grips.
I bought a set of walnut burl blanks from ChiggsGrips.com.
Chad polished them up, in about two weeks they were here at the house and on the Blackhawk.

DEB7C65F-351D-4973-B5D3-608A5B11E489.jpeg

Stay safe.
 
Very true, but there is something special about shooting 44 Special from a gun chambered in 44 Special. :)
Yup. I've got a 44spl blackhawk on my radar that isn't for sale.. But if it ever is i've got $650 that says it'll be mine.:D
 
Probably should have asked before I bought it but what are the 44s usually running these days?
 
I bought a set of walnut burl blanks from ChiggsGrips.com.
Chad polished them up, in about two weeks they were here at the house and on the Blackhawk.

View attachment 936963

Stay safe.
I’m going to have to keep an eye on his inventory! He’s got some great looking stuff, love that he sells the blanks and then makes them to order

I just stumbled onto a hidden ( at least to me) treasure of old 44special info.

http://www.goodrichfamilyassoc.org/44_Special_Articles/
 
Last edited:
I bought a Flattop .44 spl last year with the narrower, all steel XR-3 grip frame and steel ERH. The 4-5/8" gun is nice! I weighed it empty, and it is just under 42oz. I have a Bisley trigger installed.

I love this gun! But think it would be handier if it was lighter. I bought a XR-3 RED alloy grip frame and ERH. I modified the frame to accept the Bisley trigger and it now weighs 34.75oz. The balance is great! I plan on hard chroming the gun and then trying to wear it out!
 
Last edited:
Some nice flat tops in this thread. Glad the OP went 44.

Mine is a 45C. The BH just exudes that old west feel. I feel ol Doc Holiday would've thoroughly enjoyed carrying mine

View attachment 937331
Yes I think I’ve made the right choice for me choosing the .44 over the 357. Nice .45! Blackhawk would be my first choice as Id wanna crank the speed up a little on them.

I tend to be interested in some of the less main stream rounds, 41 magnum topping that list as a current favorite but I have a feeling it will have a bit of competition with the .44 getting out of lockup in 9 more business days (hopefully less, thanks a lot Washington)

Just picked up a set of dies and a shell holder this morning. Probably end up putting together some test loads and have them ready when i get it home. Archery deer season opens on Sept 1st here, hope I don’t get my deer before I can carry my new revolver with me.

I’m looking at getting the simply rugged sourdough pancake holster, anyone have experience with them or any others they could recommend?
 
7F219353-F16F-4B58-BF5E-A42E5043B177.jpeg 86CEFE5F-8EE9-4DD9-87C0-2E82EBEA627E.jpeg
I bought a Flattop .44 spl last year with the narrower, all steel XR-3 grip frame and steel ERH. The 4-5/8" gun is nice! I weighed it empty, and it is just under 42oz. I have a Bisley trigger installed.

I love this gun! But think it would be handier if it was lighter. I bought a XR-3 RED alloy grip frame and ERH. I modified the frame to accept the Bisley trigger and it now weighs 35.75oz. The balance is great! I plan on hard chroming the gun and then trying to wear it out!

I modified the grip and grip frame. Feels great! Here is a picture of how much was removed as compared to the unmodified XR3-RED frame.
 
Last edited:
Only took 4 days! I got my .44!
Holy cow! What a sweetheart of cartridge.
Just got done shooting it and it was a pleasure. Even up through the hottest load I tested, 240gn plated flat point over 16.5gn of 2400 i found it was very easy to manage he recoil.The lighter loads I could shoot all day, 7gn of Universal was a very pleasant load. The most accurate that I found was the skeeter load of 7.5gn unique and the 16.5gn of 2400, nearly the same as a Keith load, I don’t think there is a reason to try and push it any faster that what 16.5gn gives me.
Now to slug the barrel, find a mold and get casting.this thing it’s going to get a workout.
A82C8B82-8E17-450C-A7CF-6DD44C62FE15.jpeg
Now for some wood grips and some leather to carry it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top