I have a lot of holsters, and some from the top makers.
However, I often wear a regular Fobus paddle, and like it. It is much tighter against my body than the Uncle Mikes, or the Galco paddle.
The biggest problem that I have encountered is that some are too tight, and require some work to get them loose enough to draw, and I have one that is too loose.
I have them for 1911, Glock, and S&W J frame handguns. I have had no problems with breakage or other than the above. Others have not had good experiences, and so each must make up his mind.
Jerry