folder recommendation needed

Status
Not open for further replies.

somoss

Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2005
Messages
173
can you recommend a folder with about a 4 inch blade that can be opended one handed? either with open assist or something similar. i am not knife knowledgeable so this might be a simple question. i have a few non folders that i have gotten for hunting over the years but i would like something i can carry in my pocket but can open one handed for every day use and light outdoor/hunting, price under $100
THANKS
 
You need to tell us what you currently use a knife for and what you intend to use this knife for.

Also, we need to know what state you live in.
 
i live in Maryland. I use my knife for dressing deer and general light duty camping use. i would like to use the folder for general use, EDC around the house
 
MTekopengroup1.gif

MTekreargroup1.gif

This is my collection of MTech knives. Those are model numbers you see illustrated on nthe right. They're imports but well built and hold an edge well. I paid about $7.50 each. No kidding!

TR
 
I don't think I'd want to use an assisted opener for hunting since it could be difficult to clean the mechanism well.

A one hand opener with an open frame design would be good.
 
I use a Buck 4" lock back and a small, 2 1/2" pocket Gerber lock back one handed. Only have one usable hand to use 'em with anyway.

Secure smaller knife w/ thumb and forefinger on back of blade

Push body away with middle and ring finger

Realign for use.

To close - flip around and press lock with thumb and use any immobile object to press against back of blade.

4" blade is almost the same except for opening.

Grasp black w/ thumb and forefinger firmly and "snap" body of foldback outward to bring to a straight position. Or grasp and snap to a +-90 degree then push boy outward with an immobile object such as a leg, knee, table, sheath, or holster. This is done carefully for obvious reasons.
 
Benchmade griptilian is what I carry. Meets your criteria and is great quality.

x2
I edc a mini-griptillian and have zero complaints. Almost bought the full size version on saturday to keep in my fall harness in case I ever had to cut myself loose. I really like the tip up carry as it's more natural to draw and open with one hand. I trust the Axis lock more than any others as well.


Brought to you by TapaTalk.
 
I also carry a mini griptillian daily and am very pleased with it.The full sized griptillian would be a good folder for skinning a deer.Around $85.00 where I live.
 
An EDC knife is a general utility knife. Rather than launch into Brand recommendations, I'll suggest knife features that work for doing a large list of diverse tasks cutting a broad variety of materials.

The blade shape that best accommodates everything is the drop point. It gives a fine enough point to dig out a splinter, but its obtuse enough to resist breaking off. That shape can vary some, but generally the blade in 3-4" class is somewhat a long triangle, with most of the taper out at the tip. Tantos don't allow much use of the blade near the tip, clip points are traditional, but don't allow letting the blade back coast against a underlying side and the blade cutting what's above, like box strapping, seat belts, or dressing a deer.

The blade grind is the profile from edge to back, the most visible part of the blade. Flat ground blades are more useful, and the #1 in food prep. Considering that the #1 experts in knife use - cooks and chefs - prefer it says something about the way it handles the wide variety of things we prepare, from rubbery liver or tough tomatoes, corn cobs, and chops, to spreading peanut butter on crackers. It takes more time, and is more expensive, to grind a full flat profile on a knife properly. When you see a grind line less than 3/4 of blade width, cutting becomes more difficult, as the swedge exerts high presssure at that transistion, creating friction and drag. It's a major indication the knife is actually a sharpened pry bar - not an EDC user - and that the maker has gone cheap. Blade grinds with multiple intersections are part of the art of blade design, but some use them to visually enhance the knife rather than make it a useful tool. They think their customers can provide that to them.

Blade openers are usually studs, discs, or holes. The assisted openers are of benefit to those with arthritis, otherwise healthy users can forgo them. They all work, the leverage point vs. the blade axis for that persons hand is the particular issue. The best thing to do is try them at a knife shop. It's completely individual.

Blade steels run from cheap to overkill, the midrange stainless will do. AUS8, ATS34/154CM, 440C, and even the newer Chinese steels from major makers do the job.

Locks are only important to those who misuse knives. They cut, and using the tip or back of the blade in a way that would fold up a slip joint knife is not cutting. The most prevalent lock in "one hand openers" is the liner lock invented - but not patented - by Mike Walker. Three important aspects make or break a good liner lock and make it reliable: It should be at least 1/2 the thickness of the blade at the lock ramp, the leaf length should be at least 3/4 blade length, and it should not be the same material as the blade. Short, thin liner leaf are prone to walking out of the lock and failing. Even $100 knife makers can get it wrong, and sometimes, they do follow the rules.

You can check it by trying to compress the blade and work it back and forth to see if the lock works out, but don't forget, YOUR FINGERS WILL BE IN THE WAY. Another method is to tap the back of the locked blade against something unmarking but firm, like a steering wheel or 2x4. It's called spinewhacking, and as a lock test method has a negative reputation from all the internet dweebs chopping concrete to prove how tough their sharpened prybars are. Don't take it too far - it's just an EDC knife.

Traditional back locks, button locks, and sliding pin or rollers are also used. The #1 law about knife locks is that they are all just simple mechanisms and will fail.

Grips are made from a variety of materials. Brass with natural grips in wood or stag antler flexes too much over a period of years, and will loosen up and crack. Aluminum or stainless is popular, but tends to appear in cheap knives, often with guady cutouts. Fiberglass reinforced nylon is common, and extensively used, but the cost of molds prohibit a lot of style changes. The Griptilian is a great example of doing it right, the 99c buncha knives in a jug at checkout lanes exactly what to avoid. G10 is a fiberglass sheet material that has to be cut and shaped, and what I recommend. It doesn't need liners like FRN, and makes for a thinner, lighter handle. Titanium is sometimes used, and generally expensive. It allows the maker to use that grip scale directly as the liner lock. They don't come cheap, but used titanium frame locks can come to trade in the $100 range.

Grip shapes run from the ridiculous, like the 1911 with too much straightness and one corner where it shouldn't be, to molded multifinger grooved monstrosities that prevent alternate grips or uses. Simple is better, the less curves overall works, with a gentle back arc, and a cutout for the lock.

Clips come in a variety of shapes, control the amount the knife protrudes from the pocket, and let the knife ride tip up or down. Claims can be made for both about how easy it may be to get out and opened, I've tried both. The one thing I find important is whether the hand is irritated reaching past the knife with multiple slots or knurling, and whether I trust the detent to keep the blade closed. Tip up is not my favorite in that regard.

Examples (not necessarily recommendations,) include:Spyderco Tenacious, Benchmade Vex, Boker Plus M type, Spyderco Endura, Emerson CQC6 and 7, CRKT M16 series. While seeming to lean toward tactical, they don't go too far, and aren't overly expensive. A hundred others could be mentioned - but at this time, only one will do, and that's going to be solved best by seeing and handling them.

Get thee to a knife retailer, but be warned: you can get tempted by the sirens near the rocks and wind up ruined. Don't ask how I know.
 
I agree with most of what Tirod provided but strongly disagree with the following -
Locks are only important to those who misuse knives.

Locks are a safety feature that covers many uses one might put a knife to. They are not just important for misuse.

I always recommend a lock of some sort on a folding knife.
 
Probably the best deal I can recommend, though, is the Spyderco Persistence. Terrific knife, great size for daily carry, G10 handle, and less than $30, shipped from Amazon. :)

I just picked up an Ambitious (the smaller 2" bladed sibling) for a relative. I think it was $25 shipped. Really nice little knife, I'm kind of impressed. The edge grind is a little rough but the design is great. I highly recommend this series of Chinese Spydercos, amazing knife for the price.
 
I have a CRKT M18 large size which has proven itself indestructible. It is open design, so cleanup is easy. The large size comes out as fast as anything I've seen. Small size not quite as easy/quick due to less blade mass . It's a Carson flipper, with Aus 8a steel. Not current production, but can be found on Internet. They replaced with M21 with automatic lock, which I don't care for. M18 has lock, but it only locks when you choose. The knife has been fabulous.
 
Like lots of others in my generation, the knives we were raised on were largely slipjoints. As my cutting chores increased, I moved toward the lockbacks that were becoming predominant in the 1970's. And, along with just using the cutting edge, I began to use the point of a lockback, as opposed to an awl or other more appropriate tool. That often caused the force of pressing the point to fall on the back of the blade, where a slipjoint would simply fold up. Well, if the force used is anywhere other than exerted on the cutting edge to separate the material, it's not using it in the manner for which it was built. It's misuse.

Doesn't mean I don't, or won't, just recognizing what I do - which is rely on locks to keep from hacking off my fingers. At least with that method.

One thing I did leave out was protective coatings or treatments on blades. The most successful so far is nitriding, usually with titanium. It doesn't make the blade black in every case, but it does reduce a lot of friction, increase surface hardness, and prevents a lot of scratching. That gives them a fresh, unused look a lot longer than chrome, paint, teflon, or bluing, and when a patina does develop, it's just as difficult to change.

Just ordered another one.
 
If you're using a knife for hunting, I'd also shy away from a folder. A nice fixed blade is not hard to find, kabar for 50 bucks, small Gerber for 20.

Folder for general edc without hunting, you're good to go with recommendations already made.
 
Spydercos!

Emerson licensed the Wave opener on 2 models, the Delica and the Endura. I have the Endura as my EDC. The wave is a small hook on the spine of the blade, near the thumb hole. It catches on the back (or leading edge, depending on how the clip is mounted) of your pocket as you draw it. The hook causes the blade to open as it is drawn. A quick draw will lock the blade open.
 
I would recommend a Spyderco Endura. It really is as usable as any other knife out there, although some cost more.

I've owned dozens of knives from Benchmade, Cold Steel, Benchmade, Spyderco, etc. with G10 handles and expensive tool steel. Now that I've grown out of "that" phase and am more interested with using knives than collecting them, an Endura rides in my pocket daily. Often it gets swapped out for a Delica, like when I have to go into a nearby city with a 3" blade limit.

The best money I've spent, on blades, was my $75 Endura and it's trainer dupicate.
 
I generally suggest a Delica. It's like the baby bear's porridge- just right, size-wise.
 
If you mean skinning/dressing, there are many better knives for the purpose, such as the Cold Steel Master Hunter.
 
I am very fond of the Spyderco Delica for a general purpose knife. Got one in my pocket at the moment. It would not be my primary choice for a "hunting" knife, but would make a good combo with a fixed blade for hunting. I carry two knives most of the time in the woods.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top