I responded to another post, but I think it begs a new thread. I am going to use my response as an opener for discussion. The question was, "why are people against guns". My answer can be found below, which does go a little off-topic. I also edited it for clarity.
The issue in this thread is "freedom". After reading my response, I'd like constructive argument for what I had to say and what our problem is as a society when it comes to freedom.
The reason for the Constitution, in my opinion, is so that a "majority rules" could not undermine a mans basic freedom. At times our freedoms are threatened by a "majority rules" vote. Would you like to be out-legislated because your belief is the minority?
Comment please...
-------------
Admittedly, I did not read every post here. Many were variations of the same theme.
I'd like to answer question 1 with sort of a different spin, and I will rant a little - forgive me. I'll leave the other questions alone as I don't have much to add that hasn't been said.
True freedom means not just my freedom or your freedom to pursue our desires, but the freedom for everyone to practice what they choose. I'm not pointing the finger at any one person, but I see a lot of gun owners who are very passionate about their 2A rights and make a lot of talk about freedom, but when it comes to behaviors or pursuits that are unpopular or activities they don't partake in, they want them outlawed or forbidden. Many times they point to the Bill of Rights or the constitution saying gun ownership is a "right" and other behaviors not covered in any of the founding documents are not. The point is the Constitution and Bill of Rights were written with freedom in mind and if the founding fathers were to debate modern issues, I know they would side with freedom on these issues.
If asked, I'd say we're all pretty lucky the right to arms is even mentioned, or the whole practice would have been outlawed sometime last century.
Some quick examples; gay marriage, drugs, abortion. I am neither gay nor a drug user and I'm not in the market for an abortion, but since I believe in freedom above anything else, I think they ought to be legal. I don't want to debate drugs, but drugs fall into the same argument guns do - that is, neither is harmful by itself. Just as guns don't kill people, neither do drugs.
The point is, anti-gun people don't practice guns as a hobbie and have no interest, therefore their stance is to criminalize them. They simply don't care about the freedoms of others, they want laws written around what suits them, just as some gun owners are ignorant to rights they don't practice. People just don't care about other peoples freedoms. It's all a load of hypocracy.
I'm not speaking of everyone, but far too many people are selfish when it comes to freedom.
---------------
The issue in this thread is "freedom". After reading my response, I'd like constructive argument for what I had to say and what our problem is as a society when it comes to freedom.
The reason for the Constitution, in my opinion, is so that a "majority rules" could not undermine a mans basic freedom. At times our freedoms are threatened by a "majority rules" vote. Would you like to be out-legislated because your belief is the minority?
Comment please...
-------------
Admittedly, I did not read every post here. Many were variations of the same theme.
I'd like to answer question 1 with sort of a different spin, and I will rant a little - forgive me. I'll leave the other questions alone as I don't have much to add that hasn't been said.
True freedom means not just my freedom or your freedom to pursue our desires, but the freedom for everyone to practice what they choose. I'm not pointing the finger at any one person, but I see a lot of gun owners who are very passionate about their 2A rights and make a lot of talk about freedom, but when it comes to behaviors or pursuits that are unpopular or activities they don't partake in, they want them outlawed or forbidden. Many times they point to the Bill of Rights or the constitution saying gun ownership is a "right" and other behaviors not covered in any of the founding documents are not. The point is the Constitution and Bill of Rights were written with freedom in mind and if the founding fathers were to debate modern issues, I know they would side with freedom on these issues.
If asked, I'd say we're all pretty lucky the right to arms is even mentioned, or the whole practice would have been outlawed sometime last century.
Some quick examples; gay marriage, drugs, abortion. I am neither gay nor a drug user and I'm not in the market for an abortion, but since I believe in freedom above anything else, I think they ought to be legal. I don't want to debate drugs, but drugs fall into the same argument guns do - that is, neither is harmful by itself. Just as guns don't kill people, neither do drugs.
The point is, anti-gun people don't practice guns as a hobbie and have no interest, therefore their stance is to criminalize them. They simply don't care about the freedoms of others, they want laws written around what suits them, just as some gun owners are ignorant to rights they don't practice. People just don't care about other peoples freedoms. It's all a load of hypocracy.
I'm not speaking of everyone, but far too many people are selfish when it comes to freedom.
---------------
Last edited: