Good first gun for my wife to use?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Let her start out with one that appeals to her so she'll be more inclined to want to learn everything about shooting it and caring for it. As she gains more knowledge about usage and tactics, she'll make more knowledgeable choices about the right gun(s) for her.
 
:rolleyes: I don't recommend semiautomatic pistols for lightly experienced users. My own wife carries a Ruger SP-101 with a 3" barrel and Hogue Monogrip.

It's in 357 magnum caliber which I have taught her to use well; but, if she hadn't had me to fall back on, I would have wanted her to start out with nice and mild 38 Special wadcutters.

My wife's one and only firearm -

josnewrugerrc1.jpg


(All the rest are in my name! She, still, makes me clean it for her, though.) ;)
 
My wife has had three, Taurus JUNK did I say JUNK, ya JUNK, A Springfield Lt wt 9mm ultra compact. The ultra compact was too jumpy, kinda like others mentioned. Today she shoots A Sig Backwater Tactical and she has a smile on her face. Little guns, no matter what the (EXPERTS SAY) have lots of recoil, no weight. Just trying to tell it like it is. She can go to many shops but what do the experts know. Hey maybe I can be an expert. Not really life experience, from my wife.
 
I would recommend a S&W 9 shot .22lr airweight for everyday and a Ruger MKII for the range. If she is comfortable with .22lr go with it. Love mine, since I got my first with dad at 11, went in halves on a Ruger Standard. Still take it everywhere too, hmm must be a reason.
Also some .22lr can be picky on ammo. Try alot and find what shoots best. Mine likes the Federal match target 325 blk pack.
 
I don't recommend semiautomatic pistols for lightly experienced users.
Automatically assuming women can only handle a "simple revolver" is sort of condescending, isn't it?
At least you can see what is wrong with a semi-auto and fix it, if you get a (admittedly more frequent) malfunction.
 
Here is the chronology from my experience with my wife:
- go with wife to gunstore...SHE picks S&W 638, loved the lite weight.
- go to range with wife, HATED 638 recoil because of lite weight.
- husband picks up steel fame m36 so that hubby can have J frame also and wife can practice more with J frame. Wife like M36 much more...638 collects dust in safe.
- Wife try's out husbands Ruger Security Six snubbie...LOVES IT!!!
-Wife carries the Six whenever she can...husband needs to get another Six when he finds good deal!

My wife will occasionally shoot my SIG P6 (slim single stack grip!). She WILL not shot any of my other pistols. She prefers revolvers, calls them "idiot proof"...likes simple manuel of arms.
 
From: bigfatdave
Automatically assuming women can only handle a "simple revolver" is sort of condescending, isn't it? At least you can see what is wrong with a semi-auto and fix it, if you get a (admittedly more frequent) malfunction.

Now that would depend upon your individual point-of-view, wouldn't it, dave.







(I've spent a lot of my life on numerous firing lines and taught this stuff for a good many years, now. Frankly I'm inclined to trust my own experience and judgment rather than your opinion. But, hey, opinions are what make the world go around. So, please, don't let me interfere. Go right ahead and do whatever you want.) ;)
 
if you know someone with a good .22LR revolver (or semi) that would let her plink w/it for a box or 2 of ammo? she may like that but decide for 'a little more power is better'. in which case a .32 or even .38spcl?
one of my (5) sisters is not really anti-gun but she's anti-ccw so to speak and when I talked her into busting water filled balloons tied to a tree limb with my Taurus 9-shot she got a real kick out of that.
shot all the balloons I had AAMOF.
 
Let her rent/shoot whatever she can find appealing. My wife is on the hunt for a pistol too. I could give her all my thoughts and recommendations, but I know for a fact it won't work out well for her. We'll see what she decides on, but I'll make a guess that she'll pick the Taurus 941 or Glock 19.:eek:
 
Now that would depend upon your individual point-of-view, wouldn't it, dave.
Not MY opinion, the opinion of the potential female shooter. this same question gets asked far too often, and everyone posts up what THEY think a new female shooter will want, but does anyone ever take the lady to a rental range? Does anyone provide the lady with information to help HER make an informed choice?

Buying a first handgun for someone else without their input is dumb. Handgun preferences are so personal, and so hard to predict, that assuming that female=snub revolver is patently ridiculous.
If you buy anyone a handgun because you think they need one, generally it will be shoved into a dark corner and forgotten, because it doesn't fit the hand, and doesn't fit the defensive philosophy of the recipient.
I don't care if a bunch of first-time female shooters did OK with a revolver, did they go on to practice with it? Did they go on to get a CC permit? Or do they just shoot once to satisfy the jerk who got them the thing and then shove it in a drawer for the next 30 years?
 
:) Dave, take a moment to read what you wrote! Wow, talk about being egocentric! Where is your self-confidence? Whatever happened to: experience, judgment, and good old fashioned know how? I’ve selected handguns for many women. In fact several of them sought me out in order to ask for my help.

I don’t tell accountants how to do my taxes; I don’t tell carpenter’s how to replace my roof; however, I have told their wives what guns to buy. What happens to these handguns? Good question! Like learning how to: bowl, fish, or play canasta, they are used to attain a certain level of proficiency before they are either thrown into a large handbag, or placed somewhere near the bed.

(Yes, there are women in this world who won’t carry a handgun for an extended period-of-time unless they remain thoroughly good and scared by whatever their life circumstances happen to be; but, neither you nor I are going to change that; and, the psychology behind this, ‘sheepish’ behavior has absolutely nothing to do with whatever handgun they started out carrying.)

Perhaps you do, or would; but, I do not allow students to dictate to me. If I’m the teacher then we do things my way until such a time that sufficient proficiency is reached. After that the student is welcome to select any handgun he or she wants. When my job as an instructor is finished, I no longer offer input into what weapon should be used.

However, during the learning curve things will get done my way. (Which is, by the way, exactly what the NRA requires of me!) I don’t recommend or prefer to start out inexperienced shooters with semi-automatic pistols. I’m not saying I never have; but, given my druthers, I prefer not to. Neither have I ever had a student who shot himself or anyone else by accident.

You know what they say: ‘Opinions are like noses; everyone has one.’ You need to remember that some people will pay you good money in order to form an opinion on a subject about which they know next-to-nothing. Pink pistols, lightweight pistols, cute pistols, small pistols, or whatever might be attractive to a woman who is new to firearms. However, none of this means that; ‘I like this one’, or; ‘This has the best recoil’ are acceptable reasons for an inexperienced shooter to buy a certain handgun.

When you’re on someone else’s payroll, you give him (or her) the gun you want them to become familiar and proficient with, and drill them over and over in how to handle and fire it correctly. After about 500 to 1,000 rounds that person should be well, ‘anchored’ enough with that particular weapon to adequately defend himself with some real pizzazz. If handgun self-defense were really all about, ‘This is what I feel like using;’ can you imagine all the missing fingers and toes, or how full the morgues would be!

You’ve got to crawl before you walk. You’ve, also, got to trust those with more experience than you in a certain subject to take you where you want to go. After you get there the rest is up to you – NOT before.

Understand? :cool:
 
We won't be buying a gun just because someone on a website tells us it is a good one for her but it's nice to have a direction to start. So far she likes my .22 but it's a bit heavy for her, although she had no problem firing a couple hundred rounds today. She's not fond of the glock 9mm because the recoil. Thanks for the suggestions.
It's good to know that the 9 mm recoil is too much for her. The last thing you want to do is to force her into something with too much recoil. Over time, people typically build up a tollerance to recoil and can slowly increase the caliber they shoot. Too many men force women to shoot something they don't like and then wonder why their wives won't go shooting with them.

I'd be tempeted to start with a .22 either as a pistol (Ruger Mk II or III; S&W revolver in .22) or a rifle (Ruger 10-22; lever action Henry). They are accurate, inexpensive and has almost no recoil.

Another possibility would be a Rem 700 bolt action rifle in .223 caliber.

There are lots of good choices and your approach to trying them is a great idea.
 
a lot of good suggestions here, i recommend letting her try a Bersa .380. although, i don't know if a range would have one to rent.
they are extremely easy to shoot, low recoil, very accurate, lifetime warranty & if there is a problem, Colorado Gunworks will have it back to you in about a week.
my daughter-in-law loves her Duo-Tone, $250.00 at gander mtn.
 
My stepdad gave my mother a Ruger MkIII shortly after they got married. After we took her to the range and let her shoot it, she loved it, so he told her "it's yours now." Out of the SIG and S&W 9mm's, XD40, and Para .45, the .22 was her favorite. But she had to shoot all to decide that. About the best comparison that I can give you, as I'm 22 and don't plan on getting married anytime soon.
 
My friend is still waiting for her KY permit. But she pretty much 'confiscated' my KelTec P11 for nightstand/SD duty...until I got my Kahr K9 which she likes more, but isn't getting.:p

Know what her favorite is? My Sig 220 .45. "I like the kick and the big bullet. It puts big holes in things.":rolleyes:

So don't ass-u-me she'll like a little 380 or something. My old all-steel J frame is her least favorite.
 
Okay, here's what you do.

Go to your favorite gun shop and look at everything there. Find the one that YOU like the best and buy it.

Take it home and give it to your sweetie and tell her you got it just for her. After one trip to the range she'll hand it to you and tell you to keep the thing and she'll pick out her own, thank you.

Take her to the gun shop and let her handle all that she likes and pick out her own and buy it.

There. Now you're both happy!
 
"The lowest recoiling, most accurate handgun that fits her hand". Low recoiling to make the shooting as pleasant as possible, accurate to reward her for effort made to aim correctly. That would be my first answer, but there are other things to consider;

Recoil sensitive.. or not?
First you have to find out what her "unpleasantness" threshold is considering blast and recoil. Forcing someone to endure what he/she considers too much BOOM! will turn them off very fast.

What purpose does she expect the gun to serve?
Target shooting, general purpose-all around firearm, CCW, hunting... you have to think about what role it will be serving most of the time.

If self defense is a very low priority, go with a large frame .22LR (EVERYBODY has fun with a .22). S&W 617, Ruger Mk IIs, Browning Buckmark, or .22 conversion kits for large bore guns(1911 Ceiner, Kadet CZ75) are good too.

A gun that I think deserves special mention is the Beretta model 70 in .32ACP as the most pleasant centerfire gun I have shot. It has minimal recoil, has very good accuracy, the grip is very lean and comfy for small hands, and it looks quite sleek and attractive if you ask me. It is better suited than a .22 as general purpose carry/range gun, hardly adding any more recoil and blast. http://media.photobucket.com/image/beretta model 70/jriler/Beretta70S_Metalife_1.jpg

If self defense is a primary role for the gun and she is not intimidated by considerable recoil go with a service caliber(9x19mm and up) handgun that she likes and fits her well.
 
Last edited:
Ruger MK II Target or 22/45 Target. Try to find one with the 4 inch bull barrel as that is a little handier but still very accurate. Browning Buckmark is another great choice.

If she likes revolvers a Ruger Bearcat or Single Six would be my choice. I prefer the Single Six due to its larger size and adjustable sights.
 
.....So far she likes my .22 but it's a bit heavy for her, although she had no problem firing a couple hundred rounds today. She's not fond of the glock 9mm because the recoil......

Sorry but I didn't seen anywhere where you said which .22 you have now. That would help.

The all steel pistols like the Ruger and Buckmark tend to be a little heavy in the hand but the recoil is lessened by this mass. Lighter semi auto pistols like the S&W 22A, the discontinued 422 and the early Colt Woodsman are quite a bit lighter but because of that the recoil is slightly increased. But the recoil is still nothing at all like you'd get with even the smaller center fire options. I selected a sweet used 422 because I LIKE the little bit of extra recoil. But it's backfiring on me now that I'm using this pistol in some Speed Steel shooting matches. The guy with the big heavy long barrel Buckmark is beating me handily. I got to shoot his gun after a match and my own times went down too. Not to his level but definetly the heavier gun is easier to put onto the next target more quickly. BUT... it is a lot heavier. Anyhow if she wants a lighter gun I suggest you find a S&W22A for her to look at or if you can buy a 422 in nice condition. Or the regular Ruger Mark II or III with aftermarket skinny grips may well do the trick.

Keep in mind that a lot of the semi auto grips tend to be pretty wide because of the room needed for the magazine and often the mainspring. If she has small hands some of the revolvers would be nicer in that regard. Rugers tend to be slightly better in that regard and the 22/45 has been complained about because the grip width is rather flat for big hands. But they may well fit your wife quite well.

Small revolvers are around and again they are lighter so there's a touch more felt recoil but it's still nothing compared to the 9mm kick. Ruger options are the Bearcat and Single Six. Both are single action cowboy style guns that load and unload one chamber at a time through a side gate. That can slow things down but a hoard of folks love theirs. The hand grip is fairly small on both. S&W options are numerous. One I've shot that I loved is the old model 34 Kit Gun with a 4 inch barrel. Small grips, light but pleasingly accurate. This is the J frame size so other grips to suit are also available. Next up the line is the Model 63. For smaller hands I'd recomend the round butt style grip. It'll likely fit her better and provide more support. They came in a variety of barrel lengths and the current version is 5 inches. Long enough for a nice sight line length but not so long that it feels barrel heavy. The current version is an 8 shot model while earlier verions were 6 shot. A lot of folks will recomend the 617 but it's a heavy gun. 41 oz for the 617 to 29 for the 63. If she wants a lighter gun then the 617 won't be the way to go even though it's a great shooting iron.
 
im a pretty small guy and i recently purchased a 32 beretta tomcat its alittle on the heavy side for its size but i can hardly feel the recoil. so its almost perfect for me. holds 7 rouns in the clip and one in the chamber. and ive never heard of or had any problems with jamming (i love the break barrel) all and all i think it would be a great gun for her but of course its ultimately her choice. downside, small caliber, and ammunition can be a bit pricy (remington FMJ were 26.99 for a box of 50)
 
For a self defense gun, I would have her try a 1911. My mother is a fan of that and a .22 revolver but doesn't like 9mm or .40.

My wife on the other hand likes the Ruger MkII.
 
"Let her decide" can be reinterpreted to mean that she needs to find out what fits her hand and then decide what to shoot.

A gun that points naturally for her that has the grip angle that matches her will allow her to shoot more accurately and more comfortably. That translates to more enjoyment and greater likelihood that she'll want to shoot and become better at it.

Show her corneredcat.com and specifically the "how to fit" part then make a trip to a rental range. You may find that she fits a 1911 and that she's comfortable shooting .45. If .45 is too pushy for her she might enjoy a .40 or 9. If the 1911 doesn't point for her a slim BHP or CZ75 might have the grip angle and reach to trigger that she enjoys. Perhaps a smaller frame revolver works. The challenge is that she has to handle the guns and point them to see what points naturally for her and then let her try it out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top