Good state to hunt in from AZ

Status
Not open for further replies.

sumpnz

Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2004
Messages
2,281
Location
Sedro-Woolley, WA
Although I've only been hunting for a short time (forth year now for putting in, been out twice, successful once) I'm starting get rather frustrated with the big-game hunting situation here in AZ. For rifle deer, as an example, there's usually ~35K tags, and 100k+ applicants. Average success rate for deer hunting is all of 20%. Statistically that means the average rifle deer hunter only actually kills a deer every 15 years. Now, I could get into archery and get over the counter deer tags, but I'm not that good at stalking yet and with a full time job and two little kids time is not a commodity I have a surplus of.

So, I want to find a way to get out and have a reasonable chance of success each year by going to another state that actually has a sufficient number of deer, elk, antelope, etc such that obtaining tags and having the opportunity to see enough examples that I can hone my hunting craft is actually feasible. Issues standing in my way are, of course, time, money, and having someone that lives in and/or regularly hunts that area to help get me access (if the land is private or only accessible through private land) and to enjoy the experience with.

Since time and money are constraints, I'd need to be able to drive to that area within 1 day. I figure from Phoenix 1200 miles is the absolute outer limit, preferably under 1000 miles. I figure that would include perhaps as far as the western portions LA, AR, MO most of NB, WY and portions of ID, SE OR, CA plus all of NV, CO, UT, NM and TX and maybe a corner of SD and the southern edge of MT.

And, licenses/tags cannot be outrageously priced for a non-resident hunter. As an example, resident elk tags in AZ are going up to $121.50 next year and deer tags are going up to $42.25 and general hunting licenses are going up to $32.25. So, if I got drawn for both deer and elk next year it would cost me $196. I would consider non-res fees that are ~2-2.5x that for that same license + deer and elk tag to be within reason, and the lower the better of course. I did take a quick look at Wyoming's G&F website and their fees, at least for "reduced-price" (i.e. antlerless) tags were quite reasonable. Elk tags $252, deer and antelope tags $41 and it appeared to me that a seperate license was not required - total $333 for two antlerless deer, and one antlerless elk. Casper at least is under 1000 miles from my home (988.62 according to Mapquest). Since I don't particularly care about antlers (for deer or elk) those would be the tags I'd probably target.

Anyway, does anybody here live/hunt within that range that would be willing to help a (barely) under 30 year old guy gain the experience to become a better hunter? Any info would be appreciated. I know dakotasin and Smoke Rizen posted a willingness to help in SD and CO respectively so any info from those gentlemen and any others would certainly be appreciated.

Even if its not too late to get tags this year my job won't give me the time to take vacation during hunting season. Big tests starting in early October and carrying through into Nov with lots of data analysis and test reports to write by year end. Next year may be possible depending on what the job and other family demands there are on my time. But, I figure identifying a place to go and establishing a relationship with someone there to hunt with is a process that needs to start now.

Thanks is advance.
 
if you really want a fantastic deer experience, let's plan for next year. i can promise you a good time, breathtaking scenery, and seeing critters.

if you want densely forested hilly terrain, i prefer still-hunting. if you want prairie, spot-n-stalk is what i prefer. i'd be happy to have you out w/ us (us= myself, and a b-i-l). let me know if you want to do it - i can help you w/ all parts of the process from units to apply for (and when) to lodging and meals, and making sure you get the after-kill part of the hunt taken care of.
 
That would be wonderful! I assume that the prairie terrain is eastern SD? That spot and stalk is what I'd prefer, but that might be a bit too far. Still hunting the woods would certainly be a lot of fun too, of course. What are the towns closest to your preferred respective prairie and forested hunting grounds?

How cold is it during deer season (e.g. witches tit at the North Pole, just dang cold, or above freezing in the middle of the day)? Being a desert rat I don't have much cold weather gear any more, in spite of growing up in Rochester, and Philly so I'd need to know what gear to buy (the deer hunt, and elk hunt I've been on in AZ one could be comfortable in a tee-shirt by noon - nights got chilly but didn't freeze).
 
mmmm...
sounds like you are trying for hard to draw hunts.

Statistically that means the average rifle deer hunter only actually kills a deer every 15 years.
maybe "statistically", but that is not my real world experance.

I "only" got drawn for a cow elk tag this year, (with a 50% chance of being drawn on the 1st OR 2nd choise, and a 50% chance of harvest)

Many whitetail hunts in S. AZ have as good or better chances of being drawn.

You will not have that kind of luck in other surrounding states. And they WILL be more expensive for non-residents.
The grass is always greener.....
 
I hate the draw as well since that's all we have to go by. But, I bowhunt and have gotten close to the big bruizer that I've been hunting for the last 3 years. It's driving me nuts but one day I'll win.

As for the draw, we got a mule deer tag in 36B which is in the lower part of the state on the border. Success rate for that hunt is ~45%. We went to that area today and seen several deer to include a nice 4X4. The terrain is tough but I feel confident in getting one this year.

I have no desire to hunt whitetails since I can harvest them anytime back east. I have land in WVA for that and a buddy takes me to Missouri to hunt as well during Nov.

Andrew, its tough out here to apply for a hunt, manage a family life and find time to get out and scout/hunt. It's much easier back east since the deer are more plentiful than here in Arizona. Best of luck to you my friend.
 
John, Yeah there's units that have nearly 100% deer tag draw success, but the those are usually areas with either tough access (private land) or very low deer popluation density. The areas with better density have lower draw odds. My hope was to go elk hunting here every second or third year, and deer hunt (and possibly elk too) during the off years out of state. Basically for deer here it seems you either put up with low draw odds, or low deer density and correspondingly low success. What I want more than anything is to get out and see lots of deer so that I can get better as a hunter and thereby do better when I do manage to get drawn here. WRT to fees, at lease SD and WY are no more expensive if you're willing to "settle" for does. Since I don't care about horns that works just fine for me.

Lenny - I read you 5x5.
 
I have been hunting for more than 30 years, have worked for oufitters in Wyo and CA, and I still think that that the hunting oppertunitys in AZ are some of the best around.

Yes, many of the hard to get tags are "hard to get", but are you applying for everything? Deer, Elk, Javalina, Analope, Bighorn Sheep, Bufflo...? While I have only drawn deer and elk since moving here 5 years ago, I have friends that have been drawn for all of the above.

I have found that I have a choice in how I put in for tags. Either I try for "hard to get", or I go for "meat in the pot" depending on my personal situation that year. Are you applying every year for hard to get tags even if you cant hunt so as to get your "bonus" points?.

You will be hard pressed to find Muleys with bigger racks than on the Kaibab Plateau. A world record elk was taken right outside of Williams, and there might be more "Whitetail" back east but have you ever hunted Coues deer in the Sonoran Desert?

The odds on drawing AND harvesting a cow elk in this state are VERY good.

As for "public vs private" land I think you will find the ratio in this state to be one of the best around, with 80% of the land being public(if the rezs are counted)

Its called "hunting" not "killing" for a reason. IMHO I think you will have a better time "hunting" close to home, where you can easly scout, where the tags and licences are cheap, where you can just get away for the weekend with no planes flights, no outfitter fees, and without putting 1000's of miles on your truck or taking large amounts of time off work. With the extra money the above things cost for out of state hunting, you could just go "Buy" a animal off "The Rez" if you really need to kill somthing, and still stay in state.

Hunting in the mountains and deserts of this state is trully a joy, and while it might not be killing a whitetail under a feeder from a treestand every weekend all season long like some SE states, I think that the hunt, and the "hunting" experance here is just as good as almost anywhere, AND I have had WAY more problems with other states draw systems.

Im tellin ya, the grass just looks greener...
 
Problem with Arizona is the fact that deer are bucks only. For me, meat in the freezer is better than racks on the wall. I understand that the population is too low to harvest does but damn, I could of killed 100 does in the last 5 years hunting here. For meat I have to go back east.

As for the draw, that's just a thing that we have to deal with. I have 4 bonus points for Elk and plan on putting in for cow only hunts cause I'm tired of getting turned down for trophy hunts and I dont know how much longer I'm gonna be stationed in AZ.

Guess what I'm saying is for a guy that grew up back East where there is plenty of game, its hard to deal with the whole draw issue. Such is life.
 
LennyJoe,

You hit the nail on the head for me here in WA. I moved here from MO where I own some property, you probably remember. There, it's usually not a matter of whether or not you're going to get a deer but a matter of which one and how many. You can buy unlimited doe tags there. In WA here, it's bucks only (in most of the state that is) and doe tags are difficult to draw. The success rates here are low also. I barely even bother deer hunting here since I go to MO every year. I sandwich in a trip to Montana every other year or 3 years also. There are too many deer there than I can even explain.
 
I was stationed in Tacoma for 2 years and know how you feel. Blacktails are much different than Whitetails to hunt. Too bad I missed out on the property in MO.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top