Hand Size and Grip Fit, How do you Measure Up?

What size hands do you have?

  • Tiny: Way below average

    Votes: 2 1.5%
  • Smallish: Below average

    Votes: 21 15.9%
  • Medium: Average

    Votes: 48 36.4%
  • Large: Above average

    Votes: 52 39.4%
  • Very large: WAY above average

    Votes: 9 6.8%

  • Total voters
    132
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

holdencm9

Member
Joined
Oct 25, 2011
Messages
1,369
(Note: Answer the poll before doing anything else) and Sorry for the long post! Even if you just answer the poll and nothing else, that would be useful.

Okay, I read it all the time:

"The grip was WAY too big for me, and I have pretty large hands"

or

"It was very comfortable, even for my smallish hands and stubby fingers."

Et cetera.

But I always wonder what constitutes small, medium, large hands. Obviously there are different ways of measuring. But it would be good to know sort of a baseline, so we aren't misleading others. (For example, if I perceive myself to have average hands but they are actually LARGE, then I tell someone on the internet that such and such gun is very easy/comfortable to grip, and they have small hands but perceive themselves to have average hands, there is a huge disparity there.)

So I am bored at work and maybe you are too, and I happen to have a ruler so I measured some things! (No, not THAT thing. See below for how/what I measured) It should only take a few seconds and I think could yield some interesting results if we get enough folks to participate.

* Trigger Finger Length = 4.4"
** Spread = 9.0"
*** Palm length = 4.4"
**** Palm width = 3.6"

Here is how I measured.

* Trigger Finger Length: Find an L somewhere, maybe a corner of a room or in my case, my L-shaped desk. Stick your 3rd knuckle into the corner and straighten your finger. Measure from the corner out to the edge of your finger.

**Spread: Spread your thumb and fingers as WIDE as they will go, comfortably. Kind of like when you made those turkey drawings as a kid. Either outline your hand or just put a dot at the edge of your thumb and pinky, and measure the distance in between them.

***Palm Length: This is kind of the hardest to measure. I just went from the first wrinkle of my middle finger, to the first wrinkle on my wrist. I hope that makes sense.

**** Palm width: I took this measurement at the knuckles. Basically you judo-chop your desk and measure the height of your hand at the knuckles. Or with all 4 fingers together, mark on paper and measure.

Now, I never considered myself to have "big hands" but I have always considered my fingers skinny/long. I have never had trouble gripping a Glock or Beretta 92, and on some smaller guns I don't know what to do with my fingers sometimes. So maybe I have large hands but I dunno! That is the whole point of this. I will answer slightly above average for the poll, maybe after this is all said and done I will discover that my perception was erroneous.

Nerd alert: The goal of the poll is that in theory, we should have a relatively normal (bell-shaped) distribution of the responses, and if it is skewed in either way, or inverse bell curve, then that means either gun-owners hand sizes are not representative of the overall population, or people's perceptions are deceiving them.
 
FWIW:

* Trigger Finger Length = 4 3/8"
** Spread = 9.0"
*** Palm length = 4.5"
**** Palm width = 3 3/8"

Palm spread is somewhat dependent upon connective tissue flexibility; my left hand is more flexible than my right. I answered "Large" but that's based more on buying gloves than owning j-frames, SP-101s and Seecamps... or delusions of grandeur...

:)
 
Interesting concept. :)

I buy large or XL gloves depending on the fit.

Trigger finger length - 3.75" (4.5" - see edit note)
Spread - 10.0"
Palm length - 4.5"
Palm width - 4.125"

Edited to add:

Wow, I was way off measuring the trigger finger. I measured the inside instead of the outside, using the drawing below as a guide, trigger finger measures 4.5".
 
Last edited:
The only thing that was a bit confusing was "Stick your 3rd knuckle into the corner"...1) the front of the knuckle, the middle, the back? 2) the point of the corner, the side, the rear?

A better method, might have been to place your thumb on one side of the corner and the index finger on the other. It is more consistent and takes into consideration musculature of the hand

With that in mind, here's what I came up with
Trigger finger: 4.25
Spread : 9.25
Palm Length : 4.5
Palm Width : 3.4

I also voted Large, based on glove purchase size
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the responses guys. If I get enough I would put them all into a spreadsheet and graph out the results, but seems like so far not a lot have taken the time. I have no idea what size gloves I would buy since they vary so much. I think I could range from medium to XL. It does seem from the poll that so far, most people are above average. Whether that is reality or perception is yet to be determined! :)
 
I wear a mens cadet. That means short fingers and big hands.
Trigger finger 4.375"
Palm Length 4.75"
Palm Width 3.625"
 
Last edited:
The only thing that was a bit confusing was "Stick your 3rd knuckle into the corner"...1) the front of the knuckle, the middle, the back? 2) the point of the corner, the side, the rear?

A better method, might have been to place your thumb on one side of the corner and the index finger on the other. It is more consistent and takes into consideration musculature of the hand

9mmepiphany, I was talking more of like an inside corner of a room or L, (concave corner? rather than convex corner). So you are sticking your knuckle into the V of the corner. The reason I thought of it this way was it eliminates the the "webbiness" of your hand. I mean if you have really long fingers but they are more webbed, then it would yield a lower measurement.

I don't have a camera handy so I tried to sketch what I am talking about for the measurement. Excuse the crudeness of it lol.
 

Attachments

  • FingerMeasure.jpg
    FingerMeasure.jpg
    9.3 KB · Views: 51
Got it...OK, I gained a quarter of an inch...my Trigger Finger measurement is now at 4.25"

You do realize that this means that folks with fatter/puffier hands (which add nothing to trigger reach) will have a longer measurement
 
You do realize that this means that folks with fatter/puffier hands (which add nothing to trigger reach) will have a longer measurement

Perhaps, but even the most pleasantly plump individuals I have encountered don't accumulate too much extra tissue around their knuckles. I mean, most people can still make a fist and have the knuckle feel relatively "bony." But I imagine it can add 1/8" or so.

If nothing else this exercise shows why there are so many grip shapes and "go to the store and handle it" is such popular advice and there is no one-size-fits-all ergonomic solution for everyone. :)
 
Trigger- 4.25"
Spread- 9.75"
Length- 4.5"
width-4.25"

I wear XL gloves and they are snug
 
A full sized Beretta 92 dissapears into my hands does that count as extra large??

Like magic? I don't know if that counts.

All kidding aside, if you could take the time to measure out what constitutes XL that can make a full size 92 disappear, that would be appreciated.
 
This is a concept I'm all too familiar with, and I'll probably be one of the smaller hands

* Trigger Finger Length = 2 3/4" from first crease on palm side to tip (3.70" from rear edge of first knuckle to tip)
** Spread = 8.4"
*** Palm length = 4.1"
**** Palm width = 3 1/4"


I was cursed with medium-ish hands and short stumpy fingers. After getting annoyed that my whole collection consisted of mostly pocket guns all of which were exclusively single stacks I decided I wanted to find a full size double stack. I went to gun show after gun show with a list in hand, I held and rated by grip size and trigger reach over 100 pistols....Turns out there's only 3 double stacks I can hold while still reaching the trigger and all controls:

S&W M&P9 with the smallest back strap (striker guns aren't really my thing)

Browning BDM (slimmest and shortest trigger reach double stack DA/SA in the world for small hands but very hard to find hi-cap mags for)

Browning Hi Power (what's not to love).

I went with the Hi Power and I'm extremely pleased with it, might buy another. I'll also give an honorable mention to the Ruger SR9 which would have made my list, but the stupid trigger safety is just at the edge of my reach. Sometimes with my short fingers I'm pulling the edge of the trigger before the safety which makes for a heavy trigger and a loud plasticy click when the safety finally clears the frame, or even worse no trigger pull at all. In single stack the 1911 and Walther P38 are the best full size fitters.


Just putting that out there in case anyone has similar measurements to me and can't find a full size that fits.
 
I suspect that perception and glove size labels are skewing the results, as opposed to gun enthusiasts' hands actually being larger on the average than those of other people. :scrutiny: There may also be some displacement between the range of hand sizes and how common they are among the general population (i.e. "large" may well be more average among the population than medium, even though medium is presumably the middle of the normal range, independent of population).
 
Hand size is about length and thickness. Hmm, where have we hear that before. And, ultimately, it's about how the grip fits the size AND shape of your hand and how the trigger finger aligns. Length of your fingers can matter as much as how "meaty" your hands are.

There are guns that will fit more naturally to a shooter. These guns will be easier for that shooter to consistently shoot well. Ergonomics can be changed at the device level or overcome at the shooter level only. Practice can help, but the better natural fit will always be the better performer. Type of trigger matters as well.

I shoot .45acp Glocks naturally well. Ergonomics overcome DAO trigger. But, I have more issues with 9mm size Glocks. Ergonomics and DAO trigger. I shoot the 9mm XD naturally better. Ergonomics and SA trigger. I shoot the 1911 and CZ naturally better. Ergonomics and SA trigger. I shoot the 92fs not as well as I'd like, and terribly in DA. Ergonomics trump SA trigger and DA trumps all. I shoot the Sig P226 naturally better in SA, but poorly in DA. Ergonomics and SA trigger vs. DA trumping ergonomics. IMO, ergonomics often prevail so why fight it if you don't need to.
 
Last edited:
Trigger- 4.0"
Spread- 8.0"
Palm length- 4.0"
Palm width- 3.0"

Glove size is usually Small though some of them can be a little too snug for long term comfort.

The Browning Hi-Power, M1911, Ruger SR9c, CZ P-01, any .380 semi-auto, and any J and K frame S&W all feel great in my hand, and there's no problem with proper engagement of the trigger.

On the other hand (forgive the pun), the Beretta Model 92, SA XD, any full size frame Glock, and N frame S&W's are not such a great fit for my hand size.
 
After seeing the illustration, I gained 3/4" for the trigger finger; but my long sleeve shirt size remains the same - 19"x37".:D
 
Trigger- 4.25"
Spread- 9.25"
Length- 4.5"
Width- 3.875"

I think that would be large. I have no problem shooting guns with large grips like the Glock 21, the main pistol I shoot is a tt33 with bicycle inner tube around the grip to make it slightly larger with extra pieces shoved under it to give it a bit of a palm swell and to expand parts of the grip that my hand normally wouldn't touch.
 
I voted in the poll and I have large hands, XL glove size. I have an XDm 4.5 in .45 ACP and I started out using the medium size backstrap, have tried the largest backstrap. Right now I have the smallest backstrap installed because it allows me to get a better purchase with the pistol with a both thumbs forward type grip. I am anxious to shoot it with the small backstrap thumbs forward. Going on feel alone, the largest backstraps felt the best but I shot better with the medium backstrap. I am looking forward to seeing if I shoot better still with the small backstrap using the thumbs forward grip. The XDm is a tackdriver. ;)
 
I wear LG gloves for the most part. I have long fingers so many times I'll opt for the XL to get the finger length.

I voted Large. I use the largest backstrap on my Glock Gen 4's

Trigger finger. 4.35"
Spread. 9.30
Length. 4.30
Width. 3.43

My middle finger is .85 longer and ring finger is .65 longer than my index finger. That makes glove finger lengths often too short.
 
I'd say I have large hands, not unusually large but I do wear Size XL gloves and some are better fitting than others. I did not vote as my perception of WAY above average seems different than the pollster's.

Measurements:

Trigger Finger: 4.5"
Palm Spread: 10.1"
Palm Length: 4.6"
Palm Width: 4.4"

I measured using dial calipers, for knuckles I simply snugged them up and let them re-open (against the rack & pinion) which increased the measurement ~.045", for palm length, I too measured to the first wrinkle, though it only crosses 1/2 my palm (opposite my thumb). Measuring to the first full line across would add .23", hope I did things correctly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top