Help me find a gun that matches these criteria...

Status
Not open for further replies.
Magnum research just brought back the baby eagle II

my friend has one in .45 (also made in 40 or 9) its gone bang every time no maintainance issues and hits where you point it

and the decocker isnt flimsy lol
 
My girlfirend and I are in the process of trying to pick a handgun out for her. She put together what she learned from my guns, and made a list of features that she wants in her gun.

1)9mm or .380
2)a midsize pistol....somewhere close to 7" in length
3)decocker external safety
4)not too heavy, not too light.....24-27oz?
5)external hammer
6) da/sa
7)about 600 bucks(quality used guns would be considered)

Best I could come up with is a Beretta px4. Anything else out there?

Beretta PX4 Compact is an excellent choice, but I've got to second the suggestion for the FN-Herstal FNX-9

1)9mm or .380 (9mm)
2)a midsize pistol....somewhere close to 7" in length (7.4 inches. 0.2 inch shorter than the full-size PX4 Storm, but 0.6 inch longer than the Compact PX4)
3)decocker external safety (Yup - both)
4)not too heavy, not too light.....24-27oz? (21.9 ounces)
5)external hammer (Yup)
6) da/sa (Yup)
7)about 600 bucks(quality used guns would be considered)(Retail is $699.00, discount is between $525 and $599. Bud's price is $557.00 Beretta MSRP is $550.00 for the full-size or compact, Bud's price is $465.00 )

Plus you get three 17-round magazines with the FNX-9.

The Beretta is less expensive and a wonderful pistol (I have a PX4 Storm F) but the FN is worthy of your consideration and hits just about every feature you wanted.

If you do get the Beretta, get the Compact, not the Sub-Compact; the Compact has the rotating barrel that makes the gun such a pleasure to shoot.

I also have the FNP-9, the FNX-9's predecessor; the big difference is that it does not have an external safety; just the decocker. That doesn't make the gun any less safe (it won't fire unless you pull the trigger) but some folks just want the safety. On the other hand, if you can find an FNP-9, the price should be about the same as the Beretta.

Now for the .380s. 1.) The Beretta 84FS Cheetah is a beautiful pistol and can hold up to 14 rounds of ammunition. It's straight blowback so there might be some slide issues, but the gun's weight really dampens the recoil. The big downside is the price: the Cheetah retails for nearly $800.00. 2.) The Walther PK380 is one of the best 380s on the market unless you absolutely, positively think you can only get away with a mouse gun. Delayed blowback means reduced recoil and reduced effort to rack the slide. Single-stack magazine means a slimmer grip but you still get a total capacity of nine rounds. You can get them brand-new for about $350.00.
 
Last edited:
USPc 9mm
uspc_large_right.jpg


P2000 9mm
hk_p2000.jpg


can find them for 600 used pretty easily.

i have a p2000sk and its the perfect size for carry
file_27_1.jpg


you can get any of them in 9mm or .40 or .357 sig (not sure about the USPc, but the p2k for sure - for the 357)
 
And still has the rotating barrel design
I was thinking of getting a px4 storm tomorrow, and I don't understand what roatating barrel design means? Is that refering to the polygonal rifling?
 
I second a used HK P2000 or USP.

Another option, albeit way under your price range, is a Ruger P89 or 95. I picked up a LE trade in P89 for $200 bucks that never leaves the car except to shoot or clean. It runs like a champ.
 
I have a CZ Rami 9mm. It's not the decocker model but one is available. While the barrel is a bit small if you use the 14 round magazines with sleeves the grip is large enough. I've gone through 750 round or so and mine has been perfect. There is a good selection of holsters available and the availability of custom grips makes it more personalized.
 
Smith & Wesson Model 3913 is a wonderful weapon in 9mm. The Beretta models -84 and 85 are excellent .380 weapons.

Taurus 24/7 though I am not sure if it has an external hammer.
 
In addition to the Bersa Thunder 9 there’s also the Bersa Thunder 380.

1. .380
2. 6.6” length
3. Decocker external safety
4. 23 ounces loaded
5. External hammer
6. DA/SA
7. $300
 
I've been looking at FNH's FNP or FNX 9mm pistols.

It looks like they match every one of your criteria.
 
i would recomend 1st. sig 228/229 in 9mm 2nd. cz 75d pcr 9mm 3rd.sig 239 9mm 4th. sig 225/p6 5th. sig 232 the only reason this is last is beecuse its a .380. the sig p228 is only .2" wider & 3oz heavier then the p228 but mag capacity is 13/15rounds vs 8rounds. i carry a p228 with mecgar 15rounders. you can find used cpo sig p 228/229's for $550. i have had 2 239 .40 cal's & a p6 (imo) for the little bit of extra weight the best option with her desires is the 228/229 or cz 75d pcr.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top