Help me pick out a single action revolver

Status
Not open for further replies.
Try an EAA, they are one the best of the cheaper models. I lost count of the rounds that I fired and no misfires. They come in 4 3/4 and 7 1/2 barrels model and 357 mag and 45 colt. A ruger or USFa would also be fine guns.
 
I think I am going to start off with one of the Ruger Blackhawks

Good call. If Ruger SAs had been around back in the day, they would have won the west. Built like a tank, and shoots well.

I have a old model 357 BH with a 6.5" barrel that is smooth as silk, and shoots like a dream. I like the Colt types too, but Blackhawk is a great place to start with single actions.
 
Do you want something with a transfer bar safety for six-up carry, or are you willing to get seriously religious on the "load one, skip one, load four, lower the hammer on the empty chamber" drill needed for a true zero-safety gun like the Colt SAA or it's true clones?

Jim, thanks for the explanation. I'm new to SAA ownership and was just about to post a question on how to load a SAA clone (USFA Rodeo). Luckily I did a search and you've made it very clear as to the best way to load five with the hammer down on an empty chamber.

Thanks!

:)
 
If you want something really cool, unusual, and fun, I'd suggest this...

A ruger black powder revolver

Then buy the aftermarket cylinder that converts it to 45LC

This isn't a really economical route to take, but it does get you a gun that very few people have. The cylinder is about 250 bucks, I think.
 
I bought a 5.5" Ruger "old" Vaquero with the Bisley grip frame, trigger and hammer in .45 Colt.
It's a great revolver and I'm very happy I found this one.

As for the post which said, "If price is no problem get a USAF Revolver." While many of their revolvers do cost as much as a Colt or even more they do have a line that will cost you no more than an Uberti revolver mentioned in the same post. The USAF Original Rodeo Gun has a list price of only $550 and the USAF New Rodeo II which is in Nickel rather than Blue has a list price of only $605. Remember, these revolvers are made in the USA with American parts and hand fitted by American Craftsmen.

I don't regret buying the Ruger at all, especially for the price I paid but when I do buy a second SA revolver it is going to be a USAF revolver.

Here is my Ruger Vaquero:

Vaquero-2.jpg

Vaquero-3.jpg
 
I have a pair of old model Vaqueros that I enjoy a lot. You can't go wrong with a Ruger. If you want western authenticity get a Vaquero, if you want something you can target shoot and hunt with, get a blackhawk. You'll never regret it, they're all great guns.
 

Attachments

  • DSCF2250.JPG
    DSCF2250.JPG
    575.8 KB · Views: 13
My personal preference is the Ruger .357 Blackhawk, or the .44 Magnum
Ruger Super Blackhawk. I own a stainless Ruger Single-Six (.22LR/.22 WMR),
and a 50th Anniversary Ruger Blackhawk .357 Magnum. Both, are great
guns and a joy too shoot. Reloading is kind'a slow, but the way I look at
it; that makes the ammo last a bit longer (Laughing Loudly :D:D:D), and
having fun on a great day is PRICELESS~! ;)
 
These have been discontinued but I'm not sure why ... they looked like they were really nice revolvers.
They are really nice revolvers. They're the Cadillac of the BP revolver set. Unfortunately they also cost almost as much as a standard cartridge revolver. Compare that to reproduction Colts and Remingtons coming out of the Italian manufacturers for $200-250 or less.

The Ruger is the nicer gun with modern innards and a perfected design. But the reproductions have more history, are significantly cheaper, and aren't bad guns either. It's hard to justify buying the Rugers for a lot of people.

Unfortunately now the Old Army has become the Packard of the BP revolver set.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top