I made two. These are both musclewood (American Hornbeam) from my state. The one on the left was striped down to the bare wood, while the one on the right had the outer back taken off but not the under-bark. Appearance is a matter of taste I suppose. I like them both.
The left one had part of a trunk when I cut it, so the "derby" handle is carved. Be warned this stuff is tough! It will fight you every step of the way and most conventional wood-carving knives will not really take much wood off, often requiring both hands just to make a dent. I used a jigsaw, several thick-bladed knives and a lot of sanding.
The right one was originally more straight, but I bent it into shape using a steam chamber made from PVC pipe and a wallpaper steamer. It was a brand new green sapling when I did this, and it still split a little, but that's ok because this wood often "checks" as it dries and the fibers are just as strong. I kept it bent for 24 hours then moved it to my basement where I left it wedged under a beam for 6-8 months (I forget).
Both have the "checks" filled with a little wood glue and then were coated in clear poly. Years later they are still good, though my hand never got used to the "derby" handle, so I prefer the half-crook.
You probably noticed neither is particularly straight. This is a reality of this wood and I think it adds to the charm.