How much of a deterrent?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Carl Levitian

member
Joined
Jun 3, 2008
Messages
1,160
Location
Maryland
Last fall I was stupid.

We talk lots about how much it takes to defend against a criminal, and how much it takes to stop a crime. I often wondered how much of a weapon it takes to deter a crime about to happen?

What, or how much does it take before the would be criminal thinks to himself "Uh-oh, this guy ain't gonna go down easy. He's gonna fight. Maybe better move on and find another mark."

Since this is the non-firearms weapons section, that suits me as in my native peoples republik of Maryland I can't carry a gun. I've had to trust to other means.

Since the age of 30, when I was involved in a constuction accident while serving with the army engineers, I've had the perfect exuse of carrying a nice stout blackthorn or other walking stick with me. After all, I got a medical discharge for being injured on active duty, and the government sends me a little check every month, so what the hey. I got real used to having the stick right there with me.

There-in lays a problem.

Last fall, Karen sends me to to town to get a Tiffany lamp she was having fixed. There's a guy who does nice stained glass and solder work. So it goes on my honey-do list, and off I go on the errends.

I get to the shop, and I park around back in the little ally parking area since street parking in Gaithersburgs old town is scarse. I get out of the car totally in condition white, thinking of the other errends. As I walk towards the back door to the lamp shop, two young African-American males step out from an alcove by the dumster. About 19 to early 20 something years old. One has a 3 or 4 inch small kitchen knife in his hand.

The one without the knife says to the other "Go ahead, do him."

The guy with the knife tells me to hand over my wallet and cell phone, or he's "gonna cut me real good."

At this point I'm getting mad. I mean really mad. Mostly at myself mind you, for being so stupid and blundering along like Mr. Magoo. But also at these couple of low lifes who think robbing an old fart is okay. The bad part of being 100% Irish on my fathers side and 50/50 Irish and French on my mothers side, is that I inherted a rather touchy temper if rubbed the wrong way. Kind of like the Easter 1916 uprising with a dash of "storm the bastile" attitude.

While this is going on inside me, I'm groping around in my pocket for something. Anything. I'll be #*$$## if I'm going to give up my wallet and cell phone without a fight.

Since I was going to be coming out carrying a lamp, I'd left my blackthorn stick in the car, and all I had was whatever was in my pockets. To make matters worse, I'd been having some trouble with my left thumb, and was due for surgery on the thumb tendon in about a month. As a result of that, I had removed my normal pocket knife that I couldn't open from my pocket, and was carrying a Buck Hartsook with a lanyard attached to my belt loop. Nothing to open, just pull out and use, then slide back in sheath and into pocket.

At this point I'm cursing a blue streak and I pull the little Hartsook out. The one guy with the knife asks what I'm gonna do with that little knife, and I tell him I'm gonna cut his blankety blank blank throat if it's the last thing I do. "Blanketly blank blank, come on you blankety blank blanks". Like I said, I was really mad, and my Celtic/gallic emotionalisim had worked itself into a nice rage. It was 1916 and the farmers with pitchforks were about to charge the British Enfields at Kilkenny.

They went away.

They stared at me for a moment, backed away and then turned and ran across the railroad tracks to some public housing apartments. I stood there for a bit, in a "what the heck just happened" daze while Hammid the nice Turkish guy who does the stained glass work came out with a baseball bat wondering what was going on in the ally behind his shop.

So two would be punk robbers, ran from a 67 year old white bearded old guy with a 1 and 7/8th inch little knife.

Two punk would be robbers ran from a half crippled, one handed, 50% disabled, white bearded old vet with a 1 and 7/8th inch knife.

I pick up the lamp and Hammid escorts me to my car with ball bat in hand.

I've thought a lot about this over the past several months, and just one thing keeps floating to the top, no matter how much I stir it.

They didn't want a fight on thier hands.

It was like a few years ago in Frederick when the three latino guys backed off when I choked up on my blackthorn stick and got ready to start swinging. They want the wallet, but aren't ready to fight for it.

I wonder how much weapon is needed for a crime deterrent for the steriotypical robbery/assault? I see on the gun forums that most gun people think using anything less than a magnum or wonder tactical auto of the month is asking to be killed. But for 40 years I've been reading the American Rifleman, and the first thing I look at is the Armed Citizen collum. I see plenty of little old ladies with thier late husbands old Ivor Johnson break top .32 revolver send a criminal fleeing. Sometimes I even see an old fart with a. 22 rifle shoot a would be burgler, and stop the crime. I wonder if it's the same with non firearm weapons. Certainly a nice big combat knife is nice, as would be maybe a nice sharp Bowie knife. But they're kind of impractical to carry around, let alone leagal. And something smaller will still get the job done.

Could it be that the run-of-the-mill low life who would slit your throat for whatever was in your wallet, dosen't have the guts for any kind of a fight with a victim that has any means of inflicting harm on them?

The two guys in the alley weren't scared of me, but when I came up with a knife, even a small one, swore to cut their throats if it was the last thing I did on this earth, they were unsettled. It made them wary and uncomfortable to have me with a weapon in hand, even if it was a tiny one. It wasn't they way they thought it would go.

So, how much weapon do you really have to carry?
 
Good to hear you came out unharmed.
I think the question of how much is enough is different for each individual. I think it could be broken down to what personally gives you confidence in a bad situation. For myself I feel confident in a 5-shot J frame, others feel confident with 13 rounds of 9 or 45. And some are completely confident in a quality knife or using hand to hand training.
I think it comes to what can you effectively use to protect yourself and deter a threat. In this case it was a simple 1 7/8” pocket knife :)
 
You just demonstrated that your best weapon is your mind and your heart, way to come back from condition white.

You won that encounter with your mindset and determination. It was won before you pulled your knife. The two punks wanted some quick and easy cash and you let them know it wasn't going to be as easy and painless as they thought.

I salute your determination! Thank you for standing-up for yourself.

Next time, I'll bet your blackthorn will be ready!
 
Criminals like low hanging fruit, they don't care to work too hard at getting what they want.

They use fear and intimidation to try and control the situation.

It's good you unsettled them, if they had been a bit more "hungry", or jacked up on something, it may have turned out different.
 
Wonderful story. Wonderful outcome. It is the size of the fight in the dog not the size of the dog in the fight so to speak.

You were the alpha male there sir.

I hope there are plenty of MEN in our younger generations that have the same determination to not take it lying down.

I have had similar incidents. My response is a scorched earth assault once they have crossed the line.

Scares the living s**t out of people will bad intent. They want easy. I give 'em hell.


Regards,


Nq
 
the old addage of "its not the size of the dog in the fight but the size of the fight in the dog" fits right in

most "bullies" back away from a real fight and most muggers are nothing more than media glorified bullies

given your description and the fact you didnt back away they probably thought you were either crazy or ex-military either way ghetto busters dont wanna mess with crazy or trained individuals

BRAVO to you for useing your head and giving them what-for
 
Remember the punch line from the old hiker joke? The one that says, "I don't have to outrun the bear- I only have to outrun you?"

I think that's the way it is with a certain percentage of thugs. They want the easy mark, and will pass up anyone who shows signs of mounting any kind of efective resistance. Now what percentage of thugs work with that attitude, I don't know. For some, resistance is likely to provoke a fight. Again, I don't know what percentage.

Most of human communication is nonverbal. People give subliminal signs of what they're going to do, or not going to do. Many of us can't even articulate how we know what another person is likely to do in a given situation- but we pretty well know.

Those two KNEW what you would do, Carl- words or no words. And they wanted no part of it...

lpl
 
The weapon you had didn't really matter. They ran from the determination and resolve you showed. Like you said, they don't want a fight, just an easy 40 bucks.

Good on ya, and once again, a well told story. Find myself looking forward to your next one... :)

J
 
in my experiences (I've been held up 5 times in 3 years and have never given up a thing) most would be thugs lack the courage of their convictions, just show them that there is a chance things can go wrong for them and they don't want to risk it.
 
"I think the question of how much is enough is different for each individual. I think it could be broken down to what personally gives you confidence in a bad situation."


I guess that's what I'm wondering, in a nutshell. How much is enough?

Again, using the firearms analogy, everyone on the gun forums thinks anything less than a .45 or a magnum is being underguned, but we read all the time of people being very sucsessful in driving off criminals with far less. Like those covered in the Armed Citizen collum, people stopping home invasions with everything from a .22 bolt action rifle to a old .32 revolver, to a modern handgun. In every case, no matter whgat is used, the criminal always flees the home. Sometimes they drop dead outside, sometiimes they make it down the street, and sometimes the are found at the hospital seeking treatment for a bullet wound. I know its a common saying among some of the gun crowd that a .22 will make them really mad, but it seems to make them want to leave the house. In the 40 years I've been reading the Armed Citizen, I've never read of a case where a home owner shot an intruder witha .22 and got it taken away from them and beat with it.

In the non-firearms weapons field, I wonder if the same is true? I remember the elderly lady that was attacked in a church of all places, where she had been sitting in a pew writing. She just used the pen in her hand and gave her attacker a hard way to go. The police had no trouble finding him, he had bloody pockmarks all over his face from a ball point pen. No high dollar Emerson this, or Benchmade that, just a plastic Bic pen.

400 years ago people carried a sword for defense. Yet even in the days of swords, there was a market for slim little stilletos that could be concealed easy. In the 1800's the revolver came to be as the personal weapon, and Mr. Colt's .44 was the gun of choice, yet there was a market for derringers, and the Sharps 4 barrel pepperbox that was a .22 short of all things.

So if most people like a nice big bore gun, some still want something small they can carry easy. Some like a nice big Bowie, while others like a trim folder. I would hazzard a guess that a heck of a lot of the sales of Spyderco's are not for utility knife chores, but self defense, weather they want to admit it or not.

I guess I'm at a crossroads of sorts. With our befriending of this lady Kate, and her unique outlooks on somethings, I have wondered at my own convictions. Like how much is enough? Does one carry a weapon big enough for anything, or play the odds and carry something small and handy for most situations? If most criminals will back down from the sight of possable armed resistance, is anything more than a .22 mini revolver or a small lockblade really needed. Or for that once in a lifetime 250 pound hyped up crack addict, do we carry a .44 magnum with a Bowie knife for backup?

It's all in how far do we go in carrying.

What are some of your edc choices in non-firearm weapons?
 
In order of choices
1 Situational awareness. Avoid all things you can.
2 Mindset.If confronted use your brain as you did with the hartsook.
3 Use your words to make your intentions known once confronted.
4 At this level it either gets good or bad. If it gets good, I go about my business, If it gets bad.....
5 cane, knife, fists, boots, pen, boxcutter, rolled up magazine, 20 oz bottle, eyegouge, headbutt, and ultimately gun.
Whatever it takes to go home to homemade meatloaf.
 
What are some of your edc choices in non-firearm weapons?

Stainless Parker Jotter ball point pen.
Free Bic ink pen, from the hardware store, pocket clip and button clicker type.

Carton Cutter, good used one, with single edge razor blade.
Victorinox Classic. Trick here, if need, is using the scissors.
Victorinox Spartan. I ain't using the main blade if matters get serious I can access the corkscrew, while in my pocket, and have a "t" grip. Old old method and tool in the toolbox, with a people friendly knife, not one hand assist, non-locking. It fits restrictive settings real well.

Screwdriver, just a small one.

Newspaper, magazine, coffee cup, 20oz plastic bottle of water (whatever beverage), belt, eyeglasses (often overlooked by eyeglass wearers), cigarette case( I roll my own, and pipe smokers have an impact tool as well).

Vehicles have antenna's, and I have busted off an antenna, and stopped a threat against 3 younger males, one with knife, and one with gun, with said antenna.

Trash can, and/or lid. I have stopped something with a trash can, and another time a trash can lid, the old fashioned metal ones.


Often times predators want easier prey, and "that fella is crazy" can mean predators will seek easier prey.
So will "I am old, don't give a rat's arse, but I want a piece of yours if you choose to go rodeo".

Age has its perks, thank goodness, as getting old ain't for the weak. Get older, and some "meaness" comes out.
Another perk is having hung around this long, and in doing so, lots of life has been experienced, and one has life experiences to fall back on.

Some things in life you just have to experience it. You can not learn it from a book, or from TV, Movies, or Video Games.
You gotta just go through it, mistakes and all.
 
Spyderco Endura. Zebra F-402 Stainless Ballpoint pen. In the truck, a hickory cattle cane. In the jeep, a 36" x 1.25" oak stick from long ago martial arts training. Usually an ASP baton rattling around in the console.

Wyoming is a shall issue state, so I always have a pocket gun of some sort, usually a KelTec .380. But I like having a couple of non-lethal options. As per Carl's experience, I think it doesn't take much for the bad guys to think about looking for an easier mark.
 
Love the story with the lamp. It's a great example of taking back your freedom, safety, etc. and not letting the scum have the final say. But I'm still glad to have a pistol on me in Missouri. Thanks for sharing.
 
What are some of your edc choices in non-firearm weapons?

Well, you probably know about my fondness for sticks.

As a fellow Meirlinder, one of mine is Fox OC spray. Yes, I know all the criticisms of OC. One of my pastimes is calling people's bluff on that through volunteer "product testing" videos. (no, that one isn't mine, but good for a laugh). And I always have a back-up plan. There's a valuable lesson there: Be ready for ANY weapon to fail, even a gun.

Outside work if I don't have my stick, I carry a 16" baton, because the 22" was just too heavy (I used to work security to pay for college, and they're actually legal here).

I always have a pen handy. One of my favs is a free one from Sun Microsystems they hand out at conferences. Nice solid steel with just the right shape, yet nice and professional.

I must say I am looking at my little Benchmite II in a whole new light after reading this. I have to carry smaller than 2.5" at work so this is my goto edc. Not that work is a dangerous place, but it's always good to be prepared.
 
Great story! Happy it turned out well for you. Most criminals are spineless wastes of skin. They tend to loose interest real quick if you show you're not scared.
 
I am one of those strange few who does live in a carry with permit state who doesn't always carry a handgun.

As I have said before I live on the borders of three states,one won't let me carry, one wants me to jump through hoops and pay $100 each and every year for the right.:banghead:

I am not unarmed without it. Along with my brain I do have a few everday items I can use to defend myself.

I have a stainless Parker Jotter pen, mini-mag, one small fixed blade, one larger (3"-4") fixed blade , my SAK, and even the little solitaire on my keyring can be a pocket stick.

I am a big fan of pocket sticks for striking.As I have a few deformed knuckles and have had a couple of broken bones in my hand from my young and dumb days.:eek:

I also find my personality keeps me out of harms way. I dislike crowds and people in general. Much to my better-halfs dismay it shows on my face, I get anoyed by people easily. So I do not look friendly or approachable.:confused:

I am not the guy that someone would ask for a light,or spare change.

100_0767.gif
 
Last edited:
Carl,

Most criminals are opportunistic predators lower than a jackal. They no more want prey that fights back than a jackal wants to have to deal with something that might hurt them. There's just no percentage in it for them.

Determination, Mind Set, Heart, Combative Nature, call it what you will, the simple fact that you intimidated them had more to do with the fact that they were convinced they would have to pay dearly for whatever they tried to take is what scared them off and not the tool you did it with. You made them believe that the profit from the blood they'd have to shed wouldn't be worth it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top