If you were restricted to CC a BP revolver, what would it be.....

I think there are a couple guys that go on woods walks with BPs on the forum, and pretty sure there is one or two who said they have carried BP cartridge guns. I have thought about carrying my Pietta 45 colt birdseye once or twice and may do so around the new property come spring but if going to town it’s gonna be my semi auto for me.

If I were going to carry a percussion revolver it would probably be my 1858 Remington Sherrif’s model with my 1851 .44 avenging angels as backup. Still heavy but they are pretty reliable for me with Remington caps.
 
I think that's highly improbable except for felons not allowed to possess modern cartridge firearms. CAS or range use, sure, but EDC?

So, a moderator and staff member of a Black powder forum, says if they were a convicted felon they would not carry at all rather than carry a cap gun? Hmmmmmm . . . can you explain?

Mike
 
I would choose 1862 pocket police .38 which I bought specifically for this reason. After you fix cap-jams it’s allright. Colt 1851 Navy .44 is the most reliable for me , but too big for everyday carry. Blackpowder is the only gun without BIG permit here. And when you have war 200km away it’s always good to have any gun in my opinion.
 
Michael Tinker Pearce has graciously agreed to cut down to 3" and provide proper height front sight on the Fluted cylinder version of one of my two gorgeous ASM made 1860 Army .44s ! I want him to also trim down and smooth off the huge grip which will be the challenging part as I don't want to completely fabricate a Birdshead grip which would be ideal and I believe grip frame for such is unobtainium for an ASM .
 
Hey Gordon,
Make sure to get a few 'before' pics to share and compare to the 'after'.

JT
I am gonna go get the before pictures now, got to send one to Tinker. The good news is only the ASM copies had steel grip frames. Those are a lot easier to modify. VTI doesn't have them anymore tho.
Also I had this brain storm to keep the long original loading lever assembly intact and use some push pins or something to slip it back on and the short barrel be damned during reloading. I actually saw it on a 2004 THR thread That I can't retrieve where someone did just that !
 
I would carry a Remington 58 with 5.5" barrel. And I'd have at least one extra cylinder for a reload on me. In a simplyRugged sourdough pancake holster, it'd carry just about like my Ruger Blackhawk 44 special that I carry daily already. No reason to reinvent the wheel on holsters and method for me. I've never carried a BP revolver, but I feel well armed with a singleaction sixgun, so I'd probably be just fine with it. Throw in a spicing of Colt 1851 with 5.5 barrel and I'd be happy enough I reckon.
 
I really like the Ruger Old Army SS .45

It would definitely not conceal well at all but I would feel well armed with a couple of those and a BP shotgun
 
I am gonna go get the before pictures now, got to send one to Tinker. The good news is only the ASM copies had steel grip frames. Those are a lot easier to modify. VTI doesn't have them anymore tho.
Also I had this brain storm to keep the long original loading lever assembly intact and use some push pins or something to slip it back on and the short barrel be damned during reloading. I actually saw it on a 2004 THR thread That I can't retrieve where someone did just that !

Both have steel back straps.The fully fluted cylinder model is notably lighter and has a serial # 20,000 newer and higher polished blue . The older Army model inspires heavy loads in it's unfluted cylinder and someday I hope to have a shoulder stock on it. Going forward these guns have no visible attachment for the ram rod.I guess a quick detachable version of the stock loading lever will require a drilled and chamfered hole for a pin with a ring to be inserted. PXL_20230227_185335635.PORTRAIT.jpg PXL_20230227_185215167.PORTRAIT.jpg PXL_20230227_185308466.PORTRAIT.jpg
 
Last edited:
I am thinking old army in a shoulder holster a 1858 on my hip and a 44 snubnose in my boot.
 
years ago i fired a .44 colt 1860 army repo, 40 times with 41 hammer drops, one cyinder chamber failed to fire on the first try,but fired on the second try. the load was 30 grs fff with a round ball and a wonder wad over powder and crico over the balls. the .44 colt 1860 army to me is the best looking BP revolver ever made.
 
years ago i fired a .44 colt 1860 army repo, 40 times with 41 hammer drops, one cyinder chamber failed to fire on the first try,but fired on the second try. the load was 30 grs fff with a round ball and a wonder wad over powder and crico over the balls. the .44 colt 1860 army to me is the best looking BP revolver ever made.

Most likely the one that took two strikes the cap wasn't seated on the nipple and the first strike seated it.
 
Both have steel back straps.The fully fluted cylinder model is notably lighter and has a serial # 20,000 newer and higher polished blue . The older Army model inspires heavy loads in it's unfluted cylinder and someday I hope to have a shoulder stock on it. Going forward these guns have no visible attachment for the ram rod.I guess a quick detachable version of the stock loading lever will require a drilled and chamfered hole for a pin with a ring to be inserted. View attachment 1136512View attachment 1136513View attachment 1136514

Hey brother I have three different new ASM grips I've been trying to sell for a while if your interested pm me
 
Back
Top