Don Gwinn
Moderator Emeritus
I want to give the author of the article quoted below something to chew on. This is the first time I can remember a major news service or paper mentioning the little-known fact that Chicago aldermen (and indeed, every small town Mayor and alderman across the state) can carry pistols while their constituents can't even own one legally!
I emailed him about the two cases of aldermanic carry of which I am aware--"Wild Bill" Henry and Dorothy "The Hat" Tillman.
1. Bill Henry is on record, in Judge Posner's decision in Nelson vs. Streeter, as having carried and brandished a pistol. The case was heard in the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals and centered around a controversial painting a student made of Harold Washington (Chicago's first black mayor) and the efforts of five black Chicago aldermen to confiscate and destroy the painting. It's a clear-cut and disgusting case of censorship by force, but more germane to our purposes here, it contains Judge Posner's statement that William Henry brandished a gun while an accomplice (Alderman Jones) removed the painting from the wall of a private museum. It could very well be, however, that Wild Bill was carrying illegally rather than exploiting the statute. I have no idea whether he could even pass the background check to get a FOID card. He died in 1992, and a 1991 blurb about the Chicago aldermanic races notes that he was running even though he stood accused of racketeering, extortion, fraud and tax evasion.
2. The one I really want help with is Dorothy Tillman. I've seen numerous references to the day she waved a pistol around in a Chicago City Council meeting, but no hard references to when it happened. Even the year would be a help from those of you who remember this incident--or even a lead on where I could find that information. I would like to give this reporter a date or a specific meeting he could ask his sources about, since I'm sure he can find it easier than I can. What I do NOT want to do is feed him a story that he finds out is untrue with a phone call or two.
3. I also intend to remind him of Arenda Troutman, the alderman who told reporters they were "damn right" she deserves to have 24-hour police protection in front of her building even though she's known to be intimately involved with gangbangers in Chicago, and even though her constituents aren't allowed to have so much as grandpa's police .38 in the sock drawer, much less two police officers and a cruiser stationed outside their front doors.
I emailed him about the two cases of aldermanic carry of which I am aware--"Wild Bill" Henry and Dorothy "The Hat" Tillman.
1. Bill Henry is on record, in Judge Posner's decision in Nelson vs. Streeter, as having carried and brandished a pistol. The case was heard in the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals and centered around a controversial painting a student made of Harold Washington (Chicago's first black mayor) and the efforts of five black Chicago aldermen to confiscate and destroy the painting. It's a clear-cut and disgusting case of censorship by force, but more germane to our purposes here, it contains Judge Posner's statement that William Henry brandished a gun while an accomplice (Alderman Jones) removed the painting from the wall of a private museum. It could very well be, however, that Wild Bill was carrying illegally rather than exploiting the statute. I have no idea whether he could even pass the background check to get a FOID card. He died in 1992, and a 1991 blurb about the Chicago aldermanic races notes that he was running even though he stood accused of racketeering, extortion, fraud and tax evasion.
2. The one I really want help with is Dorothy Tillman. I've seen numerous references to the day she waved a pistol around in a Chicago City Council meeting, but no hard references to when it happened. Even the year would be a help from those of you who remember this incident--or even a lead on where I could find that information. I would like to give this reporter a date or a specific meeting he could ask his sources about, since I'm sure he can find it easier than I can. What I do NOT want to do is feed him a story that he finds out is untrue with a phone call or two.
3. I also intend to remind him of Arenda Troutman, the alderman who told reporters they were "damn right" she deserves to have 24-hour police protection in front of her building even though she's known to be intimately involved with gangbangers in Chicago, and even though her constituents aren't allowed to have so much as grandpa's police .38 in the sock drawer, much less two police officers and a cruiser stationed outside their front doors.
Daley speaks in defense of gun-control measures
By MIKE RAMSEY
COPLEY NEWS SERVICE
CHICAGO - Chicago Mayor Richard Daley urged state lawmakers Tuesday not to pass a "concealed-carry" law for average Illinoisans, even though his city's aldermen can carry guns under a little-known statute. Daley held a news conference with victims of violence to highlight the gun-control measures his lobbyists are again pushing in Springfield. He also took shots at the latest concealed-carry bills that would allow qualified residents to pack firearms in public.
Phil Cline, Daley's superintendent of police, weighed in against one version that passed the House Agriculture and Conservation Committee earlier this month. It would supersede the Chicago ordinance that prohibits residents from keeping handguns that were not registered with police before 1983. "When there are fewer guns on the streets, our residents and our officers are safer," Cline said. "From a police officer's perspective, the lines between criminals and law-abiding citizens are blurred immensely when you allow everyone to carry a weapon."
Chicagoans may not be able to carry guns, but their elected leaders technically can under the Illinois Municipal Code. Aldermen can become "conservators of the peace" with police powers if they get special training, and peace officers are exempted from state restrictions on concealed weapons.
Some proponents of concealed carry say it's unfair to give the aldermen the opportunity to arm themselves while denying regular citizens the chance. Daley, however, said the only aldermen who have used the gun allowance are a few current or former police officers.
Comment: Daley was adamantly against CCW for police officers and especially for retired officers when he was fighting HR 218 tooth and nail. Now it's legitimate?
One ex-cop on the Chicago City Council, Ald. William Beavers, said he stopped wearing a gun because the ankle holster he used cut off the circulation in his leg. He said he doesn't know of any colleagues who carry weapons. Ald. Walter Burnett Jr., who attended the Daley news conference Tuesday, said he's never had a gun and doesn't want one.
"I've got God to protect me," he said. "I will say this: Just like the judges were threatened (in recent incidents), aldermen get threatened, too. We deal with putting gang-bangers (in jail), getting them arrested and a whole bunch of other terrible situations. We don't have bodyguards; we're not like the mayor."
Chicago aldermen do not get a special niche in the state code to carry guns. The law applies to a variety of municipal elected officials, including mayors and board presidents and trustees across Illinois. Gun lobbyist Richard Pearson of the Illinois State Rifle Association said he recently used the statute twice as mayor of downstate Chatsworth when local alarms went off and no police officers were available. Pearson said he cannot carry his gun beyond his own jurisdiction, according to his reading of the law.
"I'm not trying to replace a police officer. My only job is to protect" local residents, Pearson said.
Illinoisans must have a Firearm Owner's Identification card to have a gun. Most cities allow residents to keep firearms at home or at their personal businesses. Under a new federal law, retired police officers can carry weapons in public.
Also Tuesday, in response to scathing comments made by Gov. Rod Blagojevich, a fellow Chicago Democrat, Daley said his lobbyists do a good job pushing his gun-control measures in Springfield. Blagojevich on Monday said he supports Daley's proposed restrictions but claimed the mayor's liaisons haven't asked his administration for lobbying help in legislative committees, where the measures have fared poorly. Daley said his representatives communicate with the governor's office.
"Everybody knows where these bills (are)," the mayor said. "These are the hottest bills down there. You know that, that's the talk of Springfield."
Daley said the media pouncing on the governor's comments is a "diversion" and a "sideshow" from the real issue of gun control. The mayor's agenda includes a proposed state ban on assault weapons, a requirement that gun-show sales include background checks and the state licensing of gun dealers.
Mike Ramsey can be reached at (312) 857-2323 or [email protected].