Ithaca 37. Yay or Nay?

Should I Get them?

  • Yes, Get one

    Votes: 8 26.7%
  • Yes, Get Both

    Votes: 22 73.3%
  • No, pass

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    30
Status
Not open for further replies.

RCR29

Member
Joined
Dec 18, 2006
Messages
164
I found a couple of Ithaca 37s, both in about 60-65 percent condition for $165 and $135 respectively. The cheaper gun has a hairline crack in the wrist, but it still feels solid. I should be able to get both for $275. Should I pass on these, or is this a good deal?

I know nothing about Ithaca shotguns, and Gunbroker values seem to vary greatly. Is there any particular thing I should check on these guns if I do buy them?
 
The cheaper gun has a hairline crack in the wrist

This is pretty common for some reason. I've found that guns that have seen a lot of time in the field tend to have this. I'm going out on a limb, but I assume it's from moisture seeping in where the stock meets the receiver, since this is where the cracks tend to start.

They're good shotguns, just check to make sure they're solid. I always take a look at the screws on the outside. What i've found is if someone who doesn't really know what they're doing tries to get in there - those screws will be all torn up. Pretty much a dead giveaway right there.
If they're generally well cared for, but well worn - that's a pretty good deal. They clean up pretty nice - and i've seen plenty of stocks/parts on gunbroker for reasonable prices.

Also - check the serial number. If it's below 855,000 - the barrels are NOT interchangable. Not sure if this is a big deal for you or not - but if it is, be aware that anything below 855,000 is going to need some work to change the barrel.

One other thing you can check - just to get an idea for the level of care - is open up the magazine and take a look at the spring. If the spring is in good condition (for it's age) and generally rust-free, it's probably been cared for. A lot of people i've seen tend to ignore this, and the springs look like they've been sitting at the bottom of a pond for long periods of time.

I wouldn't really make that a deal breaker - but just something else to look at to get an idea of the level of care the gun has received.
 
I voted for just one. But, that's just me. I can't see much sense in having two or more guns of the same model.
I just joined the Ithaca 37 club myself. Seems like a really sweet gun. The action is slicker than snot on a glass doorknob! :D
 
The action is slicker than snot on a glass doorknob!

Just make sure you keep the action bar clean/oiled as needed. I neglected mine for awhile - and didn't realize I had some crud building up. Started binding it up a bit (took about a year before it happened though).
 
BUY BOTH!

I picked up a 12 gauge featherweight with 26" IC for $108.25. Same hairline crack in the stock as you describe.

Parts are available, but it's hard to find some of them if you don't know where to look. IIRC, Numrich has replacement stocks and a few other parts. I'd have to dig through all my bookmarked pages to find the other places. If all else fails, Ithaca will do repairs. :)
 
Ithaca pts

If anyone is interested I have some Ithaca 37 parts bbl,stock& FOREARM W/ACTION BAR Firing pins raybar front sight .These were bought just in case back when I owned my 37.If interested email me for price.
 
West System Epoxy

Try it!

Pound a wedge (like a skewer or shaved popsicle stick) into the wood to separate the crack a bit. Put the epoxy in it, make sure it's spread throughout (WS has a wetting agent, so this happens easily with gravity), then clamp it together.

Wipe the stuff off the outside while it's wet!

I could show you some former hairline cracks, except you'd have a hard time seeing them, since I fixed them with West System.:)
 
Update:

I did get both for $250 OTD. I haven't tried to take them apart yet, but I hear this is a pretty complicated process. I don't know if I'll jump in to that just yet, but I would like to maybe remove the barrel. Any tips on how to do this?
 
Removing the barrel is really easy on a 37. Unscrew the magazine cap and give the barrel about a 1/3-1/2 turn and the barrel will come out of the receiver.
 
Removing the barrel is really easy on a 37. Unscrew the magazine cap and give the barrel about a 1/3-1/2 turn and the barrel will come out of the receiver.

You screw the magazine cap down towards the forearm. Unscrewing the cap tightens the cap the the barrel lug.
 
You screw the magazine cap down towards the forearm. Unscrewing the cap tightens the cap the the barrel lug.

and if i recall - the barrel will only be able to turn in one direction, counter-clockwise if i'm not mistaken...

I actually learned this the hard way. Was sitting in a tree stand with the gun across my lap - about 14 years old. Was looking at the cap and thought it seemed loose, so i tightened it. Luckily - the barrel moved immediately after - and i realized i screwed up before i tried shooting it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top